Patents by Inventor Robert L. Kanzelman

Robert L. Kanzelman has filed for patents to protect the following inventions. This listing includes patent applications that are pending as well as patents that have already been granted by the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO).

  • Patent number: 10621297
    Abstract: A computing system determines a first set of registers having constant next-state functions in the netlist. The computing system identifies an observable gate in fan-out of a register in the first set, wherein an observable gate is a gate that is critical to a verification or synthesis context. The computing system identifies a second set of reducible registers in the fan-in of the observable gate. The computing system modifies at least one of an initial value and a next-state function of at least one reducible register of the second set to reflect an observable value of the at least one reducible register observed at the observable gate. The computing system simplifies one or more logic gates implementing the observable gate and the fan-in of the observable gate by eliminating a reference to a constant next-state function register in the first set of registers.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: September 28, 2018
    Date of Patent: April 14, 2020
    Assignee: International Business Machines Coporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Robert L. Kanzelman, Pradeep Kumar Nalla, Raj Kumar Gajavelly, Dheeraj Baby
  • Publication number: 20200104434
    Abstract: A computing system determines a first set of registers having constant next-state functions in the netlist. The computing system identifies an observable gate in fan-out of a register in the first set, wherein an observable gate is a gate that is critical to a verification or synthesis context. The computing system identifies a second set of reducible registers in the fan-in of the observable gate. The computing system modifies at least one of an initial value and a next-state function of at least one reducible register of the second set to reflect an observable value of the at least one reducible register observed at the observable gate. The computing system simplifies one or more logic gates implementing the observable gate and the fan-in of the observable gate by eliminating a reference to a constant next-state function register in the first set of registers.
    Type: Application
    Filed: September 28, 2018
    Publication date: April 2, 2020
    Inventors: Jason R. BAUMGARTNER, Robert L. KANZELMAN, Pradeep Kumar NALLA, Raj Kumar GAJAVELLY, Dheeraj BABY
  • Patent number: 10565338
    Abstract: Embodiments of the present invention provides methods, computer program products, and a system for processing hierarchical references for a formal equivalence check. In certain embodiments, hierarchical references of a first design are identified as functionally equivalent to hierarchical references of a second design. Value outputs of the first design can be compared to the value outputs of the second design to determine whether the value outputs of the respective designs match.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: December 13, 2017
    Date of Patent: February 18, 2020
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Ali S. El-Zein, Mark A. Williams, Robert L. Kanzelman, Viresh Paruthi, Wolfgang Roesner
  • Patent number: 10540468
    Abstract: A logic verification program, method and system provide an efficient behavior when verifying large logic designs. The logic is partitioned by cut-nodes that dominate two or more RANDOMS and a check is performed for a given cut-node to determine whether any of the dominated RANDOMS can be merged to a constant by performing satisfiability checks with each RANDOM merged to a constant, to determine whether a range of output values for the given cut-node has been reduced by merging the RANDOM. If the range is not reduced, the RANDOM can be added to the set of merge-able RANDOMS along with the corresponding constant value. If the range has been reduced, the opposite constant value is tried for a node and if the range is reduced for both constants, then the cut-node is abandoned for merging that dominated RANDOM and the next dominated RANDOM is tried.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: July 11, 2018
    Date of Patent: January 21, 2020
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Raj Kumar Gajavelly, Jason R. Baumgartner, Robert L. Kanzelman, Alexander Ivrii, Pradeep Kumar Nalla
  • Publication number: 20200019653
    Abstract: A logic verification program, method and system provide an efficient behavior when verifying large logic designs. The logic is partitioned by cut-nodes that dominate two or more RANDOMS and a check is performed for a given cut-node to determine whether any of the dominated RANDOMS can be merged to a constant by performing satisfiability checks with each RANDOM merged to a constant, to determine whether a range of output values for the given cut-node has been reduced by merging the RANDOM. If the range is not reduced, the RANDOM can be added to the set of merge-able RANDOMS along with the corresponding constant value. If the range has been reduced, the opposite constant value is tried for a node and if the range is reduced for both constants, then the cut-node is abandoned for merging that dominated RANDOM and the next dominated RANDOM is tried.
    Type: Application
    Filed: July 11, 2018
    Publication date: January 16, 2020
    Inventors: Raj Kumar Gajavelly, Jason R. Baumgartner, Robert L. Kanzelman, Alexander Ivrii, Pradeep Kumar Nalla
  • Publication number: 20190179974
    Abstract: Embodiments of the present invention provides methods, computer program products, and a system for processing hierarchical references for a formal equivalence check. In certain embodiments, hierarchical references of a first design are identified as functionally equivalent to hierarchical references of a second design. Value outputs of the first design can be compared to the value outputs of the second design to determine whether the value outputs of the respective designs match.
    Type: Application
    Filed: December 13, 2017
    Publication date: June 13, 2019
    Inventors: Ali S. El-Zein, Mark A. Williams, Robert L. Kanzelman, Viresh Paruthi, Wolfgang Roesner
  • Patent number: 9483595
    Abstract: Liveness verification of a logic design is performed using various shadow abstraction refinement techniques. An initial subset of state elements are included in the shadow abstraction, and verification is performed (liveness-to-safety conversion) using this initial subset. If a liveness counterexample is detected, the shadow abstraction is refined by designating a second subset of the state elements different from the initial subset for inclusion in a refined abstraction. The initial subset can be designated by choosing all registers in a combinational fan-in of a liveness property of the design. High-performance algorithms for abstract liveness-to-safety conversion can be based upon simulation and counterexample refinement, bounded model checking and counterexample refinement, bounded model checking and proof-based refinement, proofs obtained during bounded model checking of a precise liveness checking problem, a hybrid of counterexample-based refinement and proof analysis, and proofs obtained.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: June 3, 2015
    Date of Patent: November 1, 2016
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Raj K. Gajavelly, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony, Pradeep K. Nalla
  • Patent number: 9471734
    Abstract: Liveness verification of a logic design is performed using various shadow abstraction refinement techniques. An initial subset of state elements are included in the shadow abstraction, and verification is performed (liveness-to-safety conversion) using this initial subset. If a liveness counterexample is detected, the shadow abstraction is refined by designating a second subset of the state elements different from the initial subset for inclusion in a refined abstraction. The initial subset can be designated by choosing all registers in a combinational fan-in of a liveness property of the design. High-performance algorithms for abstract liveness-to-safety conversion can be based upon simulation and counterexample refinement, bounded model checking and counterexample refinement, bounded model checking and proof-based refinement, proofs obtained during bounded model checking of a precise liveness checking problem, a hybrid of counterexample-based refinement and proof analysis, and proofs obtained.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: January 19, 2015
    Date of Patent: October 18, 2016
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Raj K. Gajavelly, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony, Pradeep K. Nalla
  • Publication number: 20160210388
    Abstract: Liveness verification of a logic design is performed using various shadow abstraction refinement techniques. An initial subset of state elements are included in the shadow abstraction, and verification is performed (liveness-to-safety conversion) using this initial subset. If a liveness counterexample is detected, the shadow abstraction is refined by designating a second subset of the state elements different from the initial subset for inclusion in a refined abstraction. The initial subset can be designated by choosing all registers in a combinational fan-in of a liveness property of the design. High-performance algorithms for abstract liveness-to-safety conversion can be based upon simulation and counterexample refinement, bounded model checking and counterexample refinement, bounded model checking and proof-based refinement, proofs obtained during bounded model checking of a precise liveness checking problem, a hybrid of counterexample-based refinement and proof analysis, and proofs obtained.
    Type: Application
    Filed: January 19, 2015
    Publication date: July 21, 2016
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Raj K. Gajavelly, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony, Pradeep K. Nalla
  • Publication number: 20160210389
    Abstract: Liveness verification of a logic design is performed using various shadow abstraction refinement techniques. An initial subset of state elements are included in the shadow abstraction, and verification is performed (liveness-to-safety conversion) using this initial subset. If a liveness counterexample is detected, the shadow abstraction is refined by designating a second subset of the state elements different from the initial subset for inclusion in a refined abstraction. The initial subset can be designated by choosing all registers in a combinational fan-in of a liveness property of the design. High-performance algorithms for abstract liveness-to-safety conversion can be based upon simulation and counterexample refinement, bounded model checking and counterexample refinement, bounded model checking and proof-based refinement, proofs obtained during bounded model checking of a precise liveness checking problem, a hybrid of counterexample-based refinement and proof analysis, and proofs obtained.
    Type: Application
    Filed: June 3, 2015
    Publication date: July 21, 2016
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Raj K. Gajavelly, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony, Pradeep K. Nalla
  • Patent number: 9280626
    Abstract: A mechanism is provided for efficiently determining Boolean satisfiability (SAT) using lazy constraints. A determination is made as to whether a SAT problem is satisfied without constraints in a list of constraints. Responsive to the SAT problem being satisfied without constraints, a set of variable assignments that are determined in satisfying the SAT problem without constraints are fixed. For each constraint in the list of constraints, a determination is made as to whether the SAT problem with the constraint results in the set of variable assignments remaining constant. Responsive to the SAT problem with the constraint resulting in the set of variable assignments remaining constant, the constraint is added to a list of non-affecting constraints and a satisfied result is returned.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: April 27, 2012
    Date of Patent: March 8, 2016
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Michael L. Case, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Patent number: 8589837
    Abstract: A computer-implemented method simplifies a netlist, verifies the simplified netlist using induction, and remaps resulting inductive counterexamples via inductive trace lifting within a multi-algorithm verification framework. The method includes: a processor deriving a first unreachable state information that can be utilized to simplify the netlist; performing a simplification of the netlist utilizing the first unreachable state information; determining whether the first unreachable state information can be inductively proved on an original version of the netlist; and in response to the first unreachable state information not being inductively provable on the original netlist: projecting the first unreachable state information to a minimal subset; and adding the projected unreachable state information as an invariant to further constrain a child induction process.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: April 25, 2012
    Date of Patent: November 19, 2013
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Michael L. Case, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Patent number: 8589327
    Abstract: A mechanism is provided for efficiently determining Boolean satisfiability (SAT) using lazy constraints. A determination is made as to whether a SAT problem is satisfied without constraints in a list of constraints. Responsive to the SAT problem being satisfied without constraints, a set of variable assignments that are determined in satisfying the SAT problem without constraints are fixed. For each constraint in the list of constraints, a determination is made as to whether the SAT problem with the constraint results in the set of variable assignments remaining constant. Responsive to the SAT problem with the constraint resulting in the set of variable assignments remaining constant, the constraint is added to a list of non-affecting constraints and a satisfied result is returned.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: April 22, 2011
    Date of Patent: November 19, 2013
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Michael L. Case, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Publication number: 20130305197
    Abstract: A computer-implemented method includes a processor identifying, within the netlist, at least one strongly connected components (SCCs) that has a reconvergent fanin input with at least two input paths from the reconvergent fanin input having a different propagation delay to the SCC. The method then computes an additive diameter for the netlist comprising at least one SCC, where the additive diameter includes a fanin additive diameter determined based on a propagation delay difference of the at least two input paths to a SCC and a number of complex feed-forward components within at least one input path. In response to the reconvergent fanin input to the SCC providing a binate function, the method computes a multiplicative diameter for the SCC utilizing a least common multiple (LCM) derived from one or more propagation delay differences across each reconvergent fanin input leading to the SCC.
    Type: Application
    Filed: May 9, 2012
    Publication date: November 14, 2013
    Applicant: IBM CORPORATION
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Patent number: 8578311
    Abstract: A computer-implemented method includes a processor identifying, within the netlist, at least one strongly connected components (SCCs) that has a reconvergent fanin input with at least two input paths from the reconvergent fanin input having a different propagation delay to the SCC. The method then computes an additive diameter for the netlist comprising at least one SCC, where the additive diameter includes a fanin additive diameter determined based on a propagation delay difference of the at least two input paths to a SCC and a number of complex feed-forward components within at least one input path. In response to the reconvergent fanin input to the SCC providing a binate function, the method computes a multiplicative diameter for the SCC utilizing a least common multiple (LCM) derived from one or more propagation delay differences across each reconvergent fanin input leading to the SCC.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: May 9, 2012
    Date of Patent: November 5, 2013
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Michael L. Case, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Publication number: 20130290918
    Abstract: A computer-implemented method simplifies a netlist, verifies the simplified netlist using induction, and remaps resulting inductive counterexamples via inductive trace lifting within a multi-algorithm verification framework. The method includes: a processor deriving a first unreachable state information that can be utilized to simplify the netlist; performing a simplification of the netlist utilizing the first unreachable state information; determining whether the first unreachable state information can be inductively proved on an original version of the netlist; and in response to the first unreachable state information not being inductively provable on the original netlist: projecting the first unreachable state information to a minimal subset; and adding the projected unreachable state information as an invariant to further constrain a child induction process.
    Type: Application
    Filed: April 25, 2012
    Publication date: October 31, 2013
    Applicant: IBM Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Patent number: 8527922
    Abstract: A computer-implemented method includes receiving an input containing a candidate netlist, a target, and a number, K, of cycles of interest, where K represents a number of cycles required to be analyzed for the proof-based abstraction. In response to receiving the inputs, a computing device builds an inductively unrolled netlist, utilizing random, symbolic initial values, for K cycles and provides the unrolled netlist with a first initial value constraint to a satisfiability (SAT) solver, with the first initial value constraint empty. The method includes determining whether a result of the SAT solver is satisfiable, and in response to the result not being satisfiable, performing an abstraction on the netlist and outputting the abstraction. However, in response to the result being satisfiable, the method includes performing one of: (a) outputting a valid counterexample of the original netlist; and (b) lazily adding initial value constraints to avoid spurious counterexamples.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: April 25, 2012
    Date of Patent: September 3, 2013
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Michael L. Case, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Patent number: 8484591
    Abstract: A mechanism is provided for simplifying a netlist before computational resources are exceeded. For each of a set of suspected equivalences in a proof graph of a netlist, a determination is made as to whether equivalence holds for at least one of an equivalence or an equivalence class by identifying whether the equivalence or equivalence class is either affecting or non-affecting. Responsive to the equivalence or equivalence class being affecting, a proof dependency is recorded as an edge in a proof graph. For each node in the proof graph, a determination is made as to whether the node has a falsified dependency. Responsive to the node failing to have a falsified dependency, identification is made that all dependencies are satisfied and that the equivalences represented by the node in the proof graph are sequential equivalences. The netlist is then simplified by consuming the sequential equivalences.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: April 27, 2012
    Date of Patent: July 9, 2013
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Michael L. Case, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Patent number: 8478574
    Abstract: A mechanism is provided in an integrated circuit simulator for tracking array data contents across three-value read and write operations. The mechanism accounts for write operations with data values and address values having X symbols. The mechanism performs writes to a tree data structure that is used to store the three-valued contents to the array. The simulator includes functionality for updating the array contents for a three-valued write and to read data for a three-valued read. The simulator also includes optimizations for dynamically reducing the size of the data structure when possible in order to save memory in the logic simulator.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: April 30, 2010
    Date of Patent: July 2, 2013
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Michael L. Case, Robert L. Kanzelman, Hari Mony
  • Patent number: 8418093
    Abstract: Methods and systems are provided for reducing an original circuit design into a simplified circuit design by merging gates that may not be equivalent but can be demonstrated to preserve target assertability with respect to the original circuitry design. A composite netlist is created from the simplified netlist and the original netlist. The composite netlist includes a number of targets that imply the existence of a target in the simplified netlist and a corresponding target in the original netlist. The implications are verified and then validated to ensure the simplified circuit design is a suitable replacement for the original circuit design.
    Type: Grant
    Filed: May 15, 2009
    Date of Patent: April 9, 2013
    Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
    Inventors: Jason R. Baumgartner, Michael L. Case, Geert Janssen, Robert L. Kanzelman