Abstract: An apparatus, method and program product allow two factor token authentication in the presence of multiple tokens. When multiple tokens are detected, a user desiring access needs merely to provide a unique biometric identifier, referred to as a capture BIR, and that capture BIR is evaluated against a stored BIR associated with at least one of the tokens to determine if access is to be granted. If there is a match, that user is given access. If not, the capture BIR is evaluated against the stored BIR associated with another of the detected tokens. The process may repeat until either a match is found and the user is granted access, or none is found and access is denied. The foregoing occurs without the user having to input any user ID or the like and without the inconvenience or risk of error associated with selecting a user ID from a list of potential user ID's.