Abstract: Disposable paper eating utensil enabling most of the utensil-constituent paper to be recycled. A blank composed of at least one thin ply laminated onto a thick ply is inserted between the core and cavity of a compression mold and molded into the utensil. The molding process clenches corrugations produced in the thin ply into corrugated portions of the thick ply, produced in the rising sidewall surfaces of the utensil, yielding a paper eating utensil of not readily separable two-ply construction. The eating utensil thus obtained can contain foodstuffs bearing liquid condiments, and after the utensil has been used the thin ply can be separated from the thick ply and disposed of as soiled waste, while the thick ply portion discarded as recyclable waste.