Abstract: The present disclosure is directed to compositions and methods of preparing a shelf-stable, plant-based, gluten-free dough (e.g., cookie dough) that can be stored in non-refrigerated conditions for a prolonged period without the need for time and/or temperature controls. Shelf stability is achieved based on the disclosure of compounds that have desired low moisture content and such that the dough, and methods of making the dough, regulate the water activity and pH to levels at which microbial growth is minimized or is otherwise prevented. The dough can use all-natural, organic, plant-based, and/or vegan ingredients to be devoid of preservatives and to be part of a healthy, balanced diet. Other aspects of the present disclosure, including various combinations of ingredients used and their relative proportions and ratios, and methods for combining the ingredients, are also provided.