Abstract: Systems and methods for evaluating the evaluation behaviors of an evaluator are presented. In contrast to evaluation methods that monitor and analyze click behaviors, the disclosed subject matter is directed to evaluating non-click behaviors. After obtaining results of an evaluation request submitted to a response service for evaluation by the evaluator, evaluation behaviors of the evaluator are monitored. The monitored evaluation behaviors are in association with an evaluation of the obtained results and one or more heuristics or rules are applied to the monitored evaluation behaviors to determining whether the monitored evaluation behaviors are within predetermined quality thresholds. If the monitored evaluation behaviors are not within the predetermined quality thresholds, the monitored evaluation behaviors are flagged as anomalous evaluation behaviors.