Abstract: A reversible mold comprises a pan having a bottom wall and upstanding side walls surrounding the bottom wall to form an outer receptacle. A convex shape formed in a mid-portion of the bottom wall forms an inner receptacle when the pan is inverted. The outer receptacle of the reversible mold is filled with a first edible batter and caused to set by either baking, chilling or freezing to form a firm shell portion. The inner receptacle is subsequently or in another reversible mold is filled with a second edible batter and caused to set by either baking, chilling or freezing to form a firm filler portion that is inserted into a hollow portion of the firm shell portion. Two such filled shell portions can then be assembled to create a convenience food with a contrasting center.