Abstract: Methanol tolerant catalyst materials and a method of making the same are provided. These novel catalyst materials are obtained by mixing together and heat-treating at least two different transition-metal-containing nitrogen chelates. In preferred embodiments, the nitrogen chelates comprise metalloporphyrins such as transition-metal-containing tetraphenylporphins. Preferred transition metals are iron, cobalt, nickel, copper, manganese, ruthenium, vanadium, and zinc, but could be any transition metal other than platinum or palladium. These materials offer improved catalytic oxygen reduction in the presence of methanol, as may occur at a fuel cell cathode after methanol crossover.