Abstract: The present invention includes a teething pacifier for infants comprising: a nipple, where said nipple includes an inner chamber; a mouth shield, where said mouth shield supports the nipple and prevents accidental swallowing of the nipple; a handle; where said handle is attached to the outer side of the mouth shield; and a non-toxic liquid within the inner chamber, where the non-toxic liquid is capable of being frozen. In one exemplary embodiment, the non-toxic liquid may include either water, saline or distilled water. The present invention also includes a method of making a teething pacifier comprising the steps of: assembling a hollow nipple with an inner chamber onto to a mouth shield; attaching a handle to the outer side of the mouth shield; inserting a non-toxic liquid into the inner chamber of the nipple; and sealing the liquid in the inner chamber.