Abstract: A returnable toy assembly including a body enclosing a flowable filler material that is conformable, at least one appendage extending from the body to create a life-like appearance, and an elastically extendable tether to removably couple the body to a portion of a user. The toy assembly may also include an adjustable fastening feature having an adjustable loop formed at an end of the tether such that a circumference of the loop is sizable to couple the body to the portion of the user. Also, a method of playing with a returnable toy assembly includes the steps of securely coupling a body, having at least one appendage extending from the body, to a portion of the user with a sizeable fastening feature; and propelling the body in a direction away from the portion of the user to which the body is coupled.