Abstract: An emulsified condiment including ground, cracked, or milled mustard seeds, an acid component such as vinegar, water, and a significant amount by weight of an edible oil, provides a condiment with a thick, spreadable texture, a creamy mouthfeel, and separation stability without the inclusion of emulsion forming gums or additives. The process of making the condiment includes rough cracking mustard seeds, mixing the mustard seeds with water, an oil, an acid component, and water to obtain a mixture, soaking the mixture with moderate agitation, stone milling the mixture, and deaerating the mixture.