Abstract: A toy for retaining multiple size pacifiers includes a toy structured to retain at least one button handle pacifier. The toy further includes a retention ring. The retention ring is secured to an outer surface of the toy. Each button handle pacifier includes a nipple portion, a lip shield and a retention knob. The nipple portion extends from one side of the lip shield and the retention knob extends from the other side thereof. A ring groove is formed between the lip shield and one end of the retention knob. The other end of the retention knob is preferably rounded to facilitate insertion into the a knob opening in the retention ring. The size of the nipple portion and lip shield are increased in size to accommodate larger oral cavities of older children. A retention ring may also extend from an outer surface of the toy.