Method and apparatus for communicating tooth characteristics and tooth restoration produced thereby
A method and apparatus for communicating specific idiosyncrasies in tooth appearance to be replicated in the fabrication of tooth restorations, as well as a method for creating reference images of a tooth are disclosed. The apparatus contains images of a tooth, wherein categories of specific features are displayed in the images, and codes are assigned to the images according to variations within the categories. The method of communication utilizes the apparatus by allowing a first user to compare an actual tooth to the images, record the codes for images with features that most closely resemble the actual tooth, and transmit the codes to a second user who may reference the same selected images using the recorded codes. The reference images of a particular type of tooth are created by separating and enhancing specific features in photographs of an actual tooth.
This application is a continuation of U.S. application Ser. No. 10/156,968, filed 28 May 2002 (the '968 application), now U.S. Pat. No. 6,951,459 B2, issued 4 Oct. 2005 (the '459 patent). The '968 application and the '459 patent are both hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety as though fully set forth herein.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates to the communication between dentists, dental auxiliaries, and laboratory technicians of specific idiosyncrasies in tooth appearance to be replicated in the fabrication of porcelain or ceramic restorations.
2. Description of Related Art
Traditional methods of assigning features or characterizations in tooth appearance for the purpose of accurate and consistent communication of the appearances from a dentist or dental auxiliary to a laboratory require a significant input of information for a life-like output in a final restoration of a patient's tooth. The dentist who provides greater detail in the nature and intensity of desired tooth characteristics is much more likely to have a positive result than the dentist who provides a less specific description. Likewise, the laboratory technician who is able to reference more detailed information has a much higher potential to achieve a positive result than one who is provided limited information. While traditional methods may sometimes be successful, there are many variables that can complicate the process, resulting in inadequate or misinterpreted communication, which in turn lead to greater time demands for treatment.
Features relevant to tooth appearance can be communicated from the dental office to the dental ceramist through several different means. For instance, the dentist or dental auxiliary may create a diagrammatic illustration depicting various specific features of tooth appearance including narratives. Tooth appearance may be communicated to the dental ceramist using photographic technology, such as a 35 mm color print or a digital photo image transmitted electronically. Alternatively, the ceramist may examine the patient directly while simultaneously creating his or her own schematic or recording tooth appearance using photographic technology for later reference. Prescribing particular features and fabricating restorations to fulfill these requirements is performed on an individual basis requiring one or a combination of the aforementioned methods of communication for each patient.
While current techniques may allow for successful replication of particular features relevant to tooth appearance, significant limitations exist leading to increased time and equipment costs, as well as error that is introduced through the subjectivity of interpretation and multiple steps in communicating the desired results. For instance, the ability to adequately identify and describe features of tooth appearance varies among dentists and dental auxiliaries depending upon motivation, experience, and skills. When using photography, multiple variables are introduced that may compromise dependability, for example, method of display, exposure, subject framing, film processing, and loss of feature contrast or detail due to flash illumination coupled with the fact that certain features are difficult to consistently capture photographically. The use of photography also requires additional expenses in equipment, film, and film processing. The use of photographs, diagrams, and narratives provided to the ceramist are subjectively interpreted and susceptible to error when changing contexts from one case to the next.
Presently there is no industry standardization in the categorization and encoding of features in tooth appearance that allow for accurate descriptions of the degree or intensity of features in tooth appearance. Esthetic dentistry, by its very nature, is a very visual endeavor wherein all parties are trying to translate a visual impression of what they see and what they would like to see in a completed dental restoration into words. There is a need for a process of accurately matching a restoration to natural definition that is less difficult, time consuming, and expensive than traditional methods when considering varying degrees in motivation and abilities of a dentist and a laboratory technician. An improved process would reduce or eliminate the inability to achieve an acceptable and anticipated result and the subsequent need to re-make restorations. An improved process would also reduce patient frustration and treatment time, as well as uncompensated costs to the dentist and technician in time, effort, and materials.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTIONThe present invention addresses the shortcomings of the tooth restoration process by inexpensively creating a level of standardization in the communication of specific idiosyncrasies in tooth appearance to be replicated in the fabrication of porcelain and/or ceramic restorations by significantly reducing the amount of subjectivity associated with such communications. The invention provides a communication tool for reference by the dentist and dental laboratory in order to fabricate life-like restorations. Repetitive use of the invention may also enable the dentist and laboratory to provide consistent and predictable results. Additionally, the present invention significantly reduces the amount of expertise required to facilitate communications between dentists, dental auxiliaries, and ceramists and further facilitates such communications in a more consistent and objective manner.
In one embodiment, the present invention depicts, categorizes, and encodes specific features of tooth appearance in a communication tool to enable documentation of the features. The array of features depicted may be sufficiently inclusive so as to command applicability to tooth characterizations or features which any patient may present. Categories representing features of tooth appearance are presented with specific illustrations of variation within each category. Illustrations representing variations in degree and intensity of particular features are also provided. Specific features diagnosed are transcribed on an accompanying laboratory prescription and sent to the dental laboratory where the restoration may be fabricated. The laboratory technician or ceramist may refer to the same pictorial display in fabricating the porcelain or ceramic portions of the restoration that have been delineated on the laboratory prescription to accurately create the prescribed presentation of the final restoration.
Basing communication on pictorial images eliminates the need for complex diagrams or narratives, and fixed presentation of the images reduces the negative impact of metamerism (i.e., the change in appearance caused by different lighting conditions). Thus, the error and potential error in current formats and methods of communicating features may be minimized or eliminated. Additionally, the dentist sets all technical parameters and directs the laboratory technician to stay within the parameters in order to support accountability of the technician in following direction of the dentist. The content and format of the images support recognition of individual features because, with repetitive use, the user is trained to recognize these features both singly and in composite. Therefore, the invention is conducive to use by dental auxiliaries who may have less knowledge, training, or experience in the field by improving the communication of these less skilled practitioners.
The images presented in the present invention may be a singularity on an unchanging template. Composite representations of multiple specific features in context may also be presented as a secondary reference. Displaying single features on a constant template eliminates visual distractions inherent with changing contexts. Displaying both single features and composite images provides for immediate reference to verify the accuracy of selected features. In either case, the dimensions of the gingival tissue framing the tooth and the dimensions of the tooth template may remain constant. Representative slides based on clinical observations may be converted to a digital format and specific features may be digitally separated from the original image and applied to the respective template. All features depicted in the present invention thus may be true representations of natural phenomenon. In some cases, further digital manipulation of an image may be used to heighten or enhance the respective feature in order to maintain its natural appearance. The images may be sufficiently large to enable deciphering of detail while not demanding extraordinary perceptual interpolation or extrapolation by the user for accuracy.
When using the present invention while examining a patient in order to select specific features that occur in tooth appearance, a dentist or dental auxiliary may first select a category of feature. The dentist or dental auxiliary will then compare the images displayed for the selected category to the patient's tooth. The dentist or dental auxiliary will then document the code for the image that most closely depicts the actual features on the tooth on a prescription form. If the images are displayed, for example, in a booklet, diagnosed features may be transcribed on a laboratory prescription form that is consistent with the booklet itself. The lab technician or ceramist will then use the codes documented on the prescription form to cross reference to identical images displayed using the present invention in the laboratory in order to fabricate a porcelain and/or ceramic restoration of the patient's tooth.
The invention may also utilize semi-transparent overlays of various images displaying specific selected features of tooth appearance in order to construct a composite image of the tooth. However, when overlaying layers, for example, of acetate, one must be sure that a lifelike image is attainable. In addition to semi-transparent overlays, the invention may utilize a video display to present composite images of the tooth for reference by the dentist or technician, for example, through the use of image morphing software on a computer. When using video displays, care must be exercised to make sure the consistency of the images is not compromised by such equipment variables as monitor calibration.
The foregoing and other aspects, features, details, utilities, and advantages of the present invention will be apparent from reading the following description and claims, and from reviewing the accompanying drawings.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGSThis patent or application file contains at least one drawing executed in color. Copies of this patent or patent application publication with color drawings will be provided by the United States Patent and Trademark Office upon request and payment of the necessary fee.
The present invention will now be described in detail with reference to various embodiments thereof, with some aspects of the invention being described in the accompanying drawings. Numerous specific details are set forth in order to provide a thorough understanding of the present invention. It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the present invention may be practiced without some or all of the specific details, that operations may be rearranged, that some operations may be eliminated or performed in a different way, and that other changes may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention.
An exemplary embodiment of the present invention is referred to herein as a Laboratory and Dentist Digitally Enhanced Reference (LADDER). The LADDER is a pictorial reference guide displaying true photographic images of features of tooth appearance. The scope, intensity, coloration, contrast, and character of the features are combined to simplify what would otherwise be a significantly more involved means of communication into one universal pictorial and encoded reference. Dentists, dental auxiliaries, and laboratory technicians may use the LADDER to communicate these features between the dental office and dental laboratory. The LADDER depicts, categorizes, and encodes specific features that occur in tooth appearance in the context of an unchanging template, enabling the user to visualize the specific feature(s) and readily communicate such onto a laboratory prescription for fabrication of a porcelain or ceramic restoration. Samples of composite features are also included in the LADDER to provide further reference. The encoded prescription is then forwarded to the laboratory technician or ceramist who references the same images to accurately replicate the prescribed feature(s) in the porcelain or ceramic restoration.
Respective tooth features are accurately depicted in the LADDER on a constant template in both individual and composite formats. The features and images depicted may be digitally reconstructed to be accurate in reflecting a life-like appearance. A constant template is maintained with only the respective tooth feature changing. Specific tooth features are identified using the LADDER and are added individually to create the final appearance. The LADDER allows any user to identify specific features, and the respective coding provides for exact communication of the identified features to the laboratory. Once the specific features are identified, the user can utilize the composite images provided in the LADDER to verify and support the accuracy of his or her selection(s) in a literal, photographic context.
In one embodiment, the LADDER utilizes a multi-page booklet 2, as depicted in
When using a booklet to display images, the size may be compact to make it convenient to use chair-side in referencing the natural dentition of a patient, as well as on the work surface of the laboratory technician when fabricating the final restoration. All pages of the booklet may also be laminated so they may be cleaned or disinfected without damaging the booklet. Images may be displayed that are sufficiently large to enable the deciphering of detail while maintaining proportion to the subject reference that does not demand extraordinary perceptual interpolation or extrapolation by the user for accuracy. For example, one embodiment of the invention displays images that are approximately 1.5″ high and 1″ wide.
When examining a patient to document how a particular tooth restoration should appear, a dentist or dental auxiliary may use the LADDER to effectively communicate the specific features of tooth appearance to the laboratory technician. The specific features of tooth appearance may be transcribed on a prescription form.
One method for using the LADDER is depicted in
Referring to
Four translucency pages 64 (
Translucency hues 46 (
Referring to
In
In
Four types of hypocalcifications 48 are depicted in
The coding for the images shown in
In the
Four types of brown discolorations 50 are depicted in
In
Four types of crack lines 52 are depicted in
The four pages shown in
Occasionally, surface anatomy takes on a more uniform characteristic, as shown in the surface anatomy variations images of
The category of chroma 56, or the degree of color saturation, is depicted in the four images 4 shown in
The category of value 58, or the degree of brightness, is depicted in the four images 4 shown in
The category of variations 60, which combines features in less commonly occurring formats, is depicted in the four images 4 shown in
The LADDER may also be used to supplement standardized methods known in the dental industry for choosing a base color or shade 30 (see
For example,
With this understanding of the LADDER scheme, the prescription form 300 of
Several factors may be considered in determining the base shade of the tooth restoration. Initially, the principal shade 30 of the tooth restoration must be chosen to match the natural dentition. This may be done by indicating one or more shades 30 on the tooth template 314. For example, in prescription 300 of
The prescription form 300 provides additional tooth templates 314 for the recordation of specific characteristics of the other categories 42 of tooth appearance classified in the LADDER 2. It should be recognized that one or more characteristics of tooth appearance in each category 42 may be present in a subject tooth and each of these characteristics is then combined to create an appropriate restoration. The second tooth template 314 is designated to receive information regarding the translucency category 44. In the exemplary prescription form 300 of
Once a ceramist receives a prescription form, he must then determine how to recreate the indicated characteristics into the desired tooth appearance in a restoration. This typically requires great knowledge and skill on the part of the ceramist in choosing, for example, the appropriate ceramic or porcelain, the colors and surface treatments, and whether cutbacks or multiple bake cycles are required to achieve the desired effects. Unfortunately, in the hands of a less skilled ceramist, even the best instructions may not result in a quality restoration. This disparity in quality of restorations may be alleviated, however, by providing recipes corresponding to each of the tooth characteristics depicted in the ladder.
The LADDER may incorporate multiple formulations for each applicable image outlining the necessary tints, opaquers, and mixtures respective to dominant porcelain/ceramic manufacturers. The colors, modifiers, and other applications are essentially the same to achieve the image, but termed differently by each manufacturer. For example, Jeneric-Pentron (Wallingford, Conn.) manufactures Finesse® porcelain and Vita manufactures Vita® porcelain. For example, one might take samples of an incisal modifier from both manufacturers and find them to be identical in coloration, while Jeneric-Pentron labels this modifier “blue incisal” and Vita labels this modifier as “indigo incisal.”
Most all dental laboratories tend to use one or two lines of porcelain or ceramic. The set-up expense of having multiple lines is quite costly. Outlining multiple “recipes” using the jargon of varied manufacturers thus accommodates universal applicability of the reference. The recipes themselves readily allow for an average technician to output a much higher quality of esthetic restoration and encourages such by eliminating the time and costs of experimentation to achieve the desired effects.
Several exemplary recipes are shown in
Although the description of the invention has thus far focused on the use of a booklet containing images depicting various features of tooth appearance in order to document and communicate these features to the laboratory technician or ceramist, a dentist or dental auxiliary may use various other means for displaying images. For example, images may be stored on a computer server for ready access by a user. Composite images may also be displayed by using semi-transparent overlays or computer morphing software. The dentist could then select the appropriate image presented on the visual display and a software program could automatically record the selection for preparation of a prescription. Computers linked via a communication network, for example, a local area network or the Internet, could further enable a user to transmit a prescription directly to the laboratory. When displaying images using a monitor or overlays, care must be exercised to insure that the quality and consistency of the images are not diminished.
The quality and type of images viewed by users of the LADDER are an important aspect of the invention, because they help to assure more accurate communication of specific features of tooth appearance between the dentist or dental auxiliary and the laboratory technician or ceramist. In one embodiment of the invention, the images may be created according to the method depicted in
Although various embodiments of this invention have been described above with a certain degree of particularity, or with reference to one or more individual embodiments, those skilled in the art could make numerous alterations to the disclosed embodiments without departing from the spirit or scope of this invention. It is intended that all matter contained in the above description and shown in the accompanying drawings shall be interpreted as illustrative only of particular embodiments and not limiting. Changes in detail or structure may be made without departing from the basic elements of the invention as defined in the following claims.
Claims
1. A communication tool for communicating characteristics of observable tooth appearance for replication in the fabrication of tooth restorations, the communication tool comprising a plurality of images of a tooth, wherein each of the plurality of images depicts at least one specific color-independent feature of tooth appearance:
2. A communication tool for communicating characteristics of observable tooth appearance for replication in the fabrication of tooth restorations, the communication tool comprising a plurality of images of a tooth, wherein each of the plurality of images depicts at least one single, isolated feature of observable tooth appearance separated from a first image of a particular tooth and applied to a second image of a constant tooth template.
3. A communication tool for communicating characteristics of observable tooth appearance for replication in the fabrication of tooth restorations, the communication tool comprising:
- a plurality of images of a tooth, wherein each of the images depicts at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of observable tooth appearance; and
- a plurality of codes, wherein each of the codes is assigned to a respective one of the plurality of images, and each of the codes uniquely identifies the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of its respective assigned one of the plurality of images.
4. The communication tool of claim 3, further comprising a categorization of the images, wherein
- the plurality of images comprises at least a first image and a second image; and
- a basis for the categorization is a common relationship between the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of the first image and the specific color-independent feature of the second image.
5. The communication tool of claim 3, wherein the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature is a single, isolated feature of observable tooth appearance.
6. The communication tool of claim 3, wherein the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature is a composite of a plurality of single, isolated features of observable tooth appearance.
7. The communication tool of claim 3 further comprising a schematic drawing indicating a location and/or shape of the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature in one of the images.
8. The communication tool of claim 3 further comprising a means for documenting at least one of the plurality of codes when an actual feature similar to the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature uniquely identified by the at least one of the plurality of codes is observed in a subject tooth by a user of the communication tool.
9. The communication tool of claim 3, wherein the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of tooth appearance is depicted on a constant, unchanging tooth template.
10. The communication tool of claim 3, wherein each of the plurality of images of the tooth is set into a template representing attached gingival tissue.
11. The communication tool of claim 10, wherein each of the plurality of images of the tooth and the template is set against a high contrast background.
12. The communication tool of claim 3, wherein the categorization of the plurality of images comprises at least one category selected from the group comprising: translucency, translucency hues, characterizations, hypocalcifications, brown discolorations, crack lines, surface anatomy, chroma, value, and variations.
13. The communication tool of claim 3, further comprising a recipe related to at least one of the plurality of codes for recreating the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature on a tooth restoration.
14. A booklet communicating characteristics of observable tooth appearance for replication in the fabrication of tooth restorations comprising:
- at least one page;
- a plurality of images of a tooth displayed across the page, wherein each of the images depicts at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of tooth appearance;
- a plurality of codes displayed across the at least one page, wherein each of the codes is assigned to a respective one of the plurality of images, and each of the codes uniquely identifies the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of its respective assigned one of the plurality of images.
15. The booklet of claim 14 further comprising a categorization of the images using a plurality of categories, wherein
- the plurality of images comprises at least a first image and a second image; and
- a basis for the categorization is a common relationship between the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of the first image and the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of the second image.
16. The booklet of claim 15, wherein the categorization is displayed on the at least one page.
17. The booklet of claim 16, wherein the categorization is displayed in a color coded manner.
18. The booklet of claim 15, wherein the categorization of the images further comprises at least one category selected from the group comprising: translucency, translucency hues, characterizations, hypocalcifications, brown discolorations, crack lines, surface anatomy, chroma, value, and variations.
19. The booklet of claim 14, wherein each of the codes is displayed in association with its respective assigned one of the plurality of images.
20. The booklet of claim 14, further comprising an index that documents the categorization of the plurality of images as the plurality of images appear on the at least one page of the booklet.
21. The booklet of claim 14, wherein the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature is a single, isolated feature of observable tooth appearance.
22. The booklet of claim 14, wherein the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature is a composite of a plurality of single, isolated features of observable tooth appearance.
23. The booklet of claim 14 further comprising a schematic drawing indicating a location and/or shape of the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature in one of the images, wherein the schematic drawing is displayed on the page.
24. The booklet of claim 14, wherein the plurality of images is divided into a plurality of subsets of the plurality of images according to the categorization and at least a portion of the images of one of the subsets is printed together on the at least one page.
25. The booklet of claim 14, wherein the at least one page comprises a plurality of pages and at least two of the pages are viewable simultaneously.
26. The booklet of claim 14, wherein
- the at least one page comprises a plurality of pages;
- each of the pages contains an aperture; and
- the booklet further comprises a binding ring, wherein the binding ring passes through each of the apertures to attach the plurality of pages together.
27. The booklet of claim 14, wherein the at least one page is laminated.
28. The booklet of claim 14, wherein the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature of tooth appearance is depicted on a constant, unchanging tooth template.
29. The booklet of claim 14, wherein at least one of the plurality of images is digitally enhanced to highlight the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature depicted in the at least one of the plurality of images.
30. The booklet of claim 14, wherein each of the plurality of images of the tooth is set into a template representing attached gingival tissue.
31. The booklet of claim 30, wherein each of the plurality of images of the tooth and the template is set against a high contrast background.
32. The booklet of claim 31, wherein the high contrast background is matte black.
33. The booklet of claim 14 further comprising a prescription page for documenting at least one of the codes when an actual feature, similar to the at least one specific, isolated, color-independent feature depicted in at least one of the plurality of images and uniquely identified by the at least one of the codes, is observed in a subject tooth by a user of the booklet.
34. The booklet of claim 14, wherein the plurality of images comprises at least one of the images as shown in FIGS. 6A, 6B, 6C, 6D, 7, 8A, 8B, 8C, 9A, 9B, 9C, 10A, 10B, 11A, 11B, 12A, 12B, 12C, 12D, 13, 14, 15, 16A, 16B, 16C, 16D in this specification.
35. The booklet of claim 14, wherein the plurality of codes comprises at least one of the codes as shown in FIGS. 6A, 6B, 6C, 6D, 7, 8A, 8B, 8C, 9A, 9B, 9C, 10A, 10B, 11A, 11B, 12A, 12B, 12C, 12D, 13, 14, 15, 16A, 16B, 16C, 16D in this specification.
36. The booklet of claim 14 further comprising at least one recipe related to at least one of the plurality of codes, the recipe providing instructions for recreating the at least one specific, isolated, feature on a tooth restoration identified by the at least one of the plurality of codes.
37-50. (canceled)
Type: Application
Filed: Oct 4, 2005
Publication Date: Apr 20, 2006
Inventor: Steven Weinstein (Englewood, CO)
Application Number: 11/243,897
International Classification: A61C 19/10 (20060101);