Optimized central cutter and method
A central cutting structure for use with a drill bit includes a plurality of cutters, of which at least one overlaps the center of a supporting member from which the cutters extend. Each cutter has a side rake angle that provides an overlapping relationship with at least one other cutter to provide an aggressive cutting surface for penetrating hard formations.
The present application claims priority to the co-pending U.S. patent application having the Ser. No. 12/218,832, filed Jul. 18, 2008, the entirety of which is incorporated herein by reference.
FIELDThe present disclosure relates, generally, to central cutting structures, usable in conjunction with a drill bit, to provide a portion of the drill bit that normally penetrates through a formation with reduced efficiency with a more optimal angle of attack, especially with respect to harder and/or more abrasive formations.
BACKGROUNDPDC (Polycrystalline Diamond Compact) drill bits were introduced in the oil and gas industry in the mid 1970's. During the past 30 years, numerous technological improvements to PDC cutters and drill bits have enabled them to take an important and growing share of the drilling bit market. In 2003, about 50% of the total footage drilled was performed using PDC bits, compared to 26% in 2000. Further in 2003, the total revenue of PDC bit sales was about $600 million.
Despite improvements in drill bit hydraulics and stability, and tougher and more abrasion resistant cutting elements, PDC drill bits experience a significantly reduced average rate of penetration and usable life when used in harder and more abrasive formations. Therefore historically, the use of PDC bits has been restricted to soft to medium and nonabrasive formations.
Of particular concern is the inability of the central portion of the bit face of a PDC drill bit to cut effectively. During use, the central cutters rotate a shorter distance per revolution than the outer cutters, causing less efficient boring of the drill bit as a whole. The comparative inefficiency of the central region of the bit is further accentuated when boring through a hard and/or abrasive formation.
While improvements have been made in the quality and variety of the cutters, such as new manufacturing techniques to prevent cutter wear and breakage, and improved impact and abrasion resistant diamond material and the interface geometry between the diamond layer and the tungsten carbide substrate, the high inefficiency of the central cutters of a drill bit has continued to provide difficulty.
PDC drill bits bore through a formation by shearing, like the cutting action of a lathe, as opposed to roller cone bits that drill by indenting and crushing rock. The PDC bit's cutting action plays a major role in the amount of energy needed to drill a rock formation, and can be modeled by studying the interaction between a single PDC cutter and the rock formation. Many models have been developed during the past 30 years to predict the forces on the PDC bit. The single cutter-rock models generally take into account the PDC cutter characteristics (cutter size, back rake angle, side rake, chamfer, etc.) and properties of a formation to calculate the forces necessary to cut an amount of rock. The 2D or 3D rock-bit interaction model takes into account the bit characteristics (profile, cutter layout, gauges) and the bit motion to calculate the Weight On Bit (WOB), Torque On Bit (TOB) and side force on the bit at given operating conditions in a given rock formation, either isotropic or heterogeneous formations. Laboratory single-cutler tests and full scale PDC bit tests have been carried out at atmospheric pressure or under bore-hole conditions and tend to validate these models, enabling many advances made in bit design and optimization.
The design of a PDC bit is largely a compromise between many factors, such as drillability, rate of penetration, hydraulics, steerability and durability. Typically, the design emphasizes the three parts of the PDC bit that interacts with the rock formation: the cutting structure (bit profile and cutter layout characteristics), the active gauge (gauge cutters or trimmers), and the passive gauge (gauge pads). There are three basic types of PDC bit profile: flat or shallow cone, tapered or double cone and parabolic, according to IADC fixed cutter drill bit classification there are nine bit profile codes. The type of profile plays an important role for the bit stability and durability and bit directional responsiveness. The choice of bit profile depends on the type of application, and it is difficult to give or apply general rules. Nevertheless, it is generally thought that the bit cone tends to make the bit more stable and that very flat profiles are generally used for sidetrack applications.
Thus, the characteristics of PDC cutters, i.e. back rake angle, cutter layout, cutter count, and cutter size, are the main parameters that control the drillability of the bit. The back rake angle is defined as the angle of the cutter face with respect to the rock. The back rake angle controls how aggressively the cutters engage the rock formation. Generally, as the back rake is decreased, the rate of penetration increases, however the cutter also becomes more vulnerable to impact breakage. A large back rake angle will typically result in a lower rate of penetration, but will also result in a longer PDC bit life. The side rake angle generally affects the cleaning of the cutters, by directing the cutting toward the periphery of the bit.
A need exists for a PDC drill bit or similar type of drill bit having a central cutting structure with improved efficiency, drilling with effectiveness at the center portion of the bit comparable to that at the extremities of the bit face.
A need also exists for a PDC drill bit or similar type of drill bit having an efficient attack angle with respect to the portion of the formation adjacent the center of the bit.
A further need exits for a removable and replaceable central cutting structures for use within the center of a the bit face of a PDC drill bit or similar type of drill bit.
Embodiments usable within the scope of the present disclosure meet these needs.
SUMMARYEmbodiments usable within the scope of the present disclosure include central cutting structures for use with a drill bit, such as a PDC drill bit having a bit body and bit face, and drill bits incorporating use thereof.
A central cutting structure can be fixedly secured to the center of a bit face, or removably secured thereto to facilitate replacement thereof should the central cutting structure and/or the drill bit become damaged and/or worn. The central cutting structure can include a support member having an attachment member extending from a side. In an embodiment, the attachment member can include a cylindrical body adapted for engagement within a complementary receptacle of the bit face.
Opposite the attachment member, a plurality of cutters can extend from the support member, each cutter having a cutting surface with an inner edge extending from the support member toward the inner edge of each other cutter, to define an apex of the central cutting structure. The cutting surface of each cutter can be include a side rake angle, such as −15 degrees to 15 degrees that provides an overlapping relationship with the cutting surface of at least one of the other cutters. The configuration of the cutting surfaces provides an aggressive cutting structure for penetrating hard or abrasive formations, despite the smaller amount of rotation per revolution inherent in the central region of the bit face.
While the configuration of the cutters can vary, in an embodiment, one or more of the cutters can overlap the center of the support member. Further, one or more of the cutters can have a base surface that extends radially between the center and edge of the support member. Additionally, one or more cutters can include an outer edge, such as curved, arcuate, and/or angled edge, that extends from the apex of the cutting structure toward the edge of the support member. Moreover, while any number of cutters can be disposed on the support member, in an embodiment, the central cutting structure can include three or more cutters.
The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute a part of the specification, illustrate certain embodiments of the invention and together with the general description given above and the detailed description given below, describe numerous embodiments usable within the scope of the present disclosure.
The above general description and the following detailed description are merely illustrative of various embodiments of the invention, and additional modes, advantages, and features of this invention will be readily suggested to those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTSReference will now be made in detail to the embodiments described and depicted in the accompanying drawings.
As identified above, there exists a long-standing problem in bit design associated with the inefficiency of central cutters of any drill bit. Due to the working size of a typical PDC cutter, the possible positions of the central cutters are limited to a very inefficient angle for engaging the formation. This results in side rake angles that penetrate a formation more slowly than cutters proximate to the extremity of the drill bit, and in some cases, the center of the drill bit does not drill at all.
In soft to moderately hard rock, the inefficiency of the central cutters of the bit does not normally pose a significant issue. However, in hard, abrasive formations, such as, for example, sandstone within the Travis Peak formation, an advantage can be gained by improving the drilling efficiency of the center of the bit.
It is common in the art to design bits with many different types of cutter layouts or distribution patterns. What is common to each of these patterns is that there are between one and four central cutters whose spatial disposition is severely inefficient. This severe lack of sufficiency is due to the fact that in the central part of the bit, a 0.5″ diameter cutter can only be optimized with respect to attack angle for a small portion of its diameter. Thus, there will be parts of the cutter with an efficient attack angle, and parts having an acceptable attack angle, and parts with an inherently poor attack angle. This phenomenon normally disappears an inch or two outside of the central portion of the bit.
As described previously, in soft or even moderately hard formations, this phenomenon rarely occurs, as the rock is either too soft or too brittle to cause this type of effect. Portions of the formation proximate to the center of the bit either break off as they becomes too tall to support themselves, or are broken or worn off simply by the drill bit body material rubbing against them. However, in hard, abrasive formations with high rock strength, inefficient cutting at the center of the bit can severely slow the rate of penetration.
All of the embodiments as well as those appreciated by one skilled in the art after appreciating this disclosure allow for placing cutters immediately adjacent to and overlapping, within a central structure attachable to a drill bit. In an embodiment, the central cutting structure can be made from sintered tungsten carbide and/or a tungsten carbide matrix material, having polycrystalline diamond compact cutters affixed and/or bonded thereto.
In a further embodiment, embodiments of the central cutting structure can be cast as an integral part of a drill bit during the drill bit molding process, and then specialized cutter shapes can be brazed or otherwise attached thereto. Additionally, while the depicted embodiments include two and three cutting elements extending from a central cutting structure, it should be understood that embodiments can readily include any number of cutting elements, e.g. four or five cutting elements.
Additionally, the central cutting structures disclosed herein can allow a single brazing operation to be performed at the center of a drill bit to replace two, three, or more separate cutters with a single, higher efficiency cutting structure.
Additional advantages and modification will readily occur to those skilled in the art. The present invention in its broader aspects is therefore not limited to the specific details, representative apparatuses, and the illustrative examples shown and described herein. Accordingly, departures may be made from the embodiments herein without departing from the spirit or scope of the disclosed general inventive concept.
Claims
1. A central cutting structure for a drill bit, the central cutting structure comprising:
- a base member having a surface; and
- a plurality of cutters secured to the surface, wherein each of said cutters comprises a cutting surface having an inner edge, wherein the inner edge of each of said cutters extends away from the surface and proximate to the inner edge of each other of said cutters to define an apex, and wherein the cutting surface of each of said cutters has a side rake angle that provides an overlapping relationship with the cutting surface of at least one other of the cutters to provide an aggressive cutting structure for penetrating hard formations.
2. The central cutting structure of claim 1, wherein the cutting surface of at least one of said cutters overlaps a center of the base member.
3. The central cutting structure of claim 1, wherein the cutting surface of each of said cutters further comprises a base edge extending from a center of the surface toward an edge of the surface.
4. The central cutting structure of claim 1, wherein the plurality of cutters comprises at least three cutters.
5. The central cutting structure of claim 1, wherein the side rake angle ranges from −15 degrees to 15 degrees.
6. The central cutting structure of claim 1, wherein the cutting surface of at least one of said cutters further comprises an outer surface extending from an edge of the surface to the apex.
7. The central cutting structure of claim 1, further comprising an attachment member disposed on a side of the base member opposite the surface, wherein the attachment member is configured for engagement with a bit face of the drill bit.
8. The central cutting structure of claim 7, wherein the attachment member is configured for removable engagement with the bit face of the drill bit.
9. The central cutting structure of claim 7, wherein the attachment member is configured for fixed engagement with the bit face of the drill bit.
10. The central cutting structure of claim 7, wherein the attachment member comprises a cylindrical body configured for engagement within a complementary receptacle within the bit face.
11. A drill bit for forming boreholes in subterranean formations, the drill bit comprising:
- a drill bit body having a bit face with a center;
- a central cutting structure secured to the center of the bit face, wherein the central cutting structure comprises: a base member having a first side, a second side, a center, and an edge; an attachment member extending from the first side and engaged with the center of the bit face; a plurality of cutters extending from the second side, wherein each of said cutters comprises a cutting surface having an inner edge, wherein the inner edge of each of said cutters extends away from the second side proximate to the inner edge of each other of said cutters to define an apex, and wherein the cutting surface of each of said cutters has a side rake angle that provides an overlapping relationship with the cutting surface of at least one other of the cutters to provide an aggressive cutting structure for penetrating hard formations.
12. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the central cutting structure is removably engaged with the bit face.
13. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the central cutting structure is fixedly engaged with the bit face.
14. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the plurality of cutters comprise polycrystalline diamond compact cutters.
15. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the attachment member comprises a cylindrical body configured for engagement within a complementary receptacle within the bit face.
16. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the cutting surface of at least one of said cutters overlaps a center of the base member.
17. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the cutting surface of each of said cutters further comprises a base edge extending from the center of the base member the edge of the base member.
18. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the plurality of cutters comprises at least three cutters.
19. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the side rake angle ranges from −15 degrees to 15 degrees.
20. The drill bit of claim 11, wherein the cutting surface of at least one of said cutters further comprises an outer surface extending from the edge of the base member to the apex.
21. A method for penetrating a hard or abrasive formation with a drill bit, the method comprising the steps of:
- providing a central cutting structure to a center of a bit face of a drill bit, wherein the central cutting structure comprises a plurality of cutters extending therefrom, wherein each of said cutters comprises a cutting surface having an inner edge, and wherein the inner edge of each of said cutters extends away from the bit face and proximate to the inner edge of each other of said cutters to define an apex; and
- contacting the hard or abrasive formation with the central cutting structure, wherein the cutting surface of each of said cutters has a side rake angle that provides an overlapping relationship with the cutting surface of at least one other of the cutters to provide an aggressive cutting structure for penetrating the hard or abrasive formation.
Type: Application
Filed: Oct 5, 2010
Publication Date: Feb 3, 2011
Inventors: James Shamburger (Spring, TX), Vincente Salvo (Spring, TX)
Application Number: 12/924,770
International Classification: E21B 7/00 (20060101); E21B 10/42 (20060101);