Pump Cavitation Device
A sacrificial body mitigates cavitation damage to components within a pump. The sacrificial body is mounted in the pump so that flowing fluid passes over the sacrificial body, which causes the sacrificial body to shed electrons into the flowing fluid in the vicinity of the cavitation. The excess electrons tend to suppress hydrogen ions from releasing, which can mitigate cavitation. The sacrificial body is formed of a material having less resistance to corrosion due to the flowing fluid than the components of the pump. Needles are attached to the sacrificial body for immersion in the flowing fluid to facilitate the release of the electrons for the sacrificial body.
Latest S.P.M. Flow Control, Inc. Patents:
This application claims priority to provisional patent application Ser. No. 61/355,878, filed Jun. 17, 2010.
TECHNICAL FIELDThis disclosure relates in general to pumps and in particular to a sacrificial body that mitigates pitting and corrosion due to cavitation.
BACKGROUND OF THE DISCLOSURECavitation in pumping devices causes early failure of components due to erosion/corrosion and the resulting pitting. The pitting causes several problems: leaks in sealing areas, loss of pressure integrity, or loss of pressure integrity due to sudden catastrophic failure from a crack in the pressure chamber that begins at a cavitation corrosion pit and rapidly propagates through the pressure containing wall of the pumping chamber. Cavitation usually initiates in predictable places such as, but not limited to, near the edge of a sealing surface, areas where there is a sudden drop in pressure that produces turbulent fluid flow, or at microscopic discontinuities in the surface of the metal grain and composition properties.
Cavitation occurs when there is a rapid drop in pressure in areas of turbulence, particularly at the beginning of the suction stroke on a reciprocating pump or on the trailing edge of an impeller style centrifugal pump. Small air bubbles are formed and the collapsing of the bubbles can reach boundary velocities high enough to erode the metal away, causing pitting. During the formation and collapse of these bubbles chemical changes also occur, due to the rapid phase change from a liquid to gas, and back from a gas to liquid which propagates the release of hydrogen ions. These hydrogen ions have a corrosive effect on the molecular structure of the metal, causing small particles of the metal to separate and enter into the fluid stream, contributing to further acceleration of the pitting process. These hydrogen ions cause the formation of hydrogen embrittlement cracks, which propogate during each pumping stroke of a reciprocating pump. Eventually this cracking begins to penetrate into the pressure containing wall and rapidly results in a structural failure of the pressure vessel.
In applications where a lot of fluid is pumped at high velocities, the maintenance costs due to cavitation erosion/corrosion can be a significant part of the operating costs. Eliminating cavitation is unrealistic due to the high pressures and rapid flow rates needed in many industries. An industry that experiences high costs of “expendables” is the well service frac industry. Due to governmental limitations on the weight and the width of vehicles that are allowed highway access, frac trucks used in the well service frac industry are made as light and as small as possible while still being able to achieve the pumping pressures and flow required. Designed to be as light as possible, the fluid end and its internal components of the pumps associated with such well service equipment can wear and fail quickly, due to erosion and corrosion. When pitting occurs in the pumping chamber of the fluid end, the stresses concentrate in the pit with the result that corrosion cracking is initiated and results in the failure of the fluid end to hold pressure. Replacing of fluid ends is one of the highest maintenance costs of the well service frac business. Obtaining a longer lasting fluid end and longer lasting valves, seats and packing is an important objective of this industry. Efforts are commonly made to either reduce the cavitation or to select materials that are more resistant to cavitation erosion and corrosion. Valves, seats and packing are also destroyed quickly due to erosion and corrosion, which are accelerated when cavitation occurs. Slowing the pump speed down can mitigate this problem, but due to the competitive nature of the business, and the demand for higher pressure operations, the pumps are run at high speeds, and cavitation is unavoidable at these speeds.
Raising the supercharge pressure to the inlet of the pump may reduces cavitation. Using a properly sized suction pulsation device can reduce cavitation. But with these solutions implemented in the industry, and with cavitation erosion/corrosion still causing expensive maintenance issues, the demand continues for equipment that will last longer so that operating costs can be further reduced.
SUMMARYIn a first aspect, embodiments are disclosed of a method that reduces cavitation damage to a component within a pump including mounting a sacrificial body within the pump and operating the pump to pump fluid at a rate that causes at least some cavitation to occur on the component, wherein the pumped fluid flows over the sacrificial body to shed electrons into the flowing fluid in the vicinity of the cavitation. Since the cavitation damage of a component having a sacrificial member is reduced as compared to component not having a sacrificial body, the sacrificial member advantageously extends the working life of the component beyond a component not having a sacrificial body mounted therein.
In certain embodiments, the sacrificial body includes a material that is more easily corroded than the component within a pump.
In yet other embodiments, during use, the operating step causes hydrogen ions to release from the component within the pump, the release of which is mitigated by the shedding of electrons from the sacrificial body.
In certain embodiments, the method includes attaching at least one needle to the sacrificial body to facilitate the shedding of electrons from the sacrificial body.
In other embodiments, in use the needle is pointing downstream.
In certain embodiments, the needle is formed of a metal that is less subject to corrosion than the sacrificial body.
In certain embodiments, the method step of mounting an upstream portion of the sacrificial body into the pump, provides a sacrificial body having a profile to enhance turbulence of the fluid flowing over the sacrificial body.
In certain embodiments, the pump is positioned such that no portion of the pump is immersed in the fluid to be pumped by the pump.
In certain embodiments, the sacrificial body is formed from one or more materials from the group comprising zinc, aluminum, magnesium or alloys thereof.
In certain embodiments, the turbulence created from mounting the sacrificial body in the component produces cavitation on a surface of the sacrificial body rather than allowing the cavitation bubbles to form on the component. The amount of purposely created cavitation bubbles and the resulting deterioration of the sacrificial body is related to the energy needed to overcome the energy consumed as a gas phase changes to a liquid and a liquid phase changes back to a gas during cavitation. The energy of the phase change demands the release of hydrogen ions, which is a corrosion phenomenon. The sacrificial body is made from materials that more readily release ions than does the steel of the fluid chamber; which directs the damaging cavitation corrosion pitting to the sacrificial body.
In yet another embodiment, the component includes a fluid end block having a chamber, a plunger bore leading to the chamber, a suction valve port leading to the chamber, and a discharge valve port passing from the chamber.
In certain embodiments, the method includes mounting the sacrificial body within the chamber.
In certain embodiments, the method includes mounting the sacrificial body stationarily within the plunger bore surrounding the plunger.
In certain embodiments, the method includes mounting the sacrificial body to the suction valve for movement therewith.
In certain embodiments, the method includes mounting the sacrificial body within the suction valve port upstream from a suction valve.
In another embodiment, the component includes a plunger in the plunger bore.
In yet another embodiment, the mounting step includes mounting a sacrificial body to the plunger.
In certain of the embodiments, the component includes a housing having a rotatable impeller therein.
In certain of the embodiments, the method includes mounting the sacrificial body within the housing adjacent a periphery of the impeller.
In certain of the embodiments, the method includes mounting the sacrificial body to the impeller for rotation therewith.
In a second aspect, an embodiment provides a pump having a fluid end block containing a chamber, a plunger bore leading to the chamber, a suction valve port leading to the chamber, and a discharge valve port passing from the chamber. The suction and discharge valves are mounted for reciprocation within the suction valve port and discharge valve port, respectively.
A sacrificial body is mounted within the fluid end block for immersion during use in the fluid flow as the plunger strokes. The sacrificial body is formed of a material less resistant to corrosion as compared to the fluid end block. The embodiment advantageously provides a pump having a targeted area of cavitation to mitigate cavitation on the fluid end block, which extends the working life of the fluid end block. Moreover, the sacrificial member targeted for cavitation can be replaced over the life of the fluid end block.
In certain embodiments, at least one needle is mounted to the sacrificial body, the needle in use being immersed in the flowing fluid and pointing in a downstream direction.
In certain embodiments, the needle is formed of a metal more resistant to corrosion due to the fluid flowing over the needle than the sacrificial body.
In certain of the embodiments, a profile configured to enhance turbulence is located on an upstream portion of the sacrificial body.
In certain embodiments, the sacrificial body is formed from one or more materials from the group comprising zinc, aluminum, magnesium or alloys thereof.
In certain of the embodiments, the sacrificial body includes a sleeve mounted stationarily within the plunger bore surrounding the plunger.
In certain of the embodiments, the sacrificial body is mounted to a forward end of the plunger for movement therewith.
In certain of the embodiments, the sacrificial body is mounted to the suction valve for movement therewith.
In certain of the embodiments, the sacrificial body is mounted within the suction valve port upstream from the suction valve.
In a third aspect, an embodiment provides a pump including a housing, a rotatable impeller mounted within the housing, and a sacrificial body mounted within the housing for immersion in use within fluid flow as the impeller rotates. The sacrificial body formed of a material less resistant to corrosion due to the fluid flow than the impeller and the housing.
In certain of the embodiments, the sacrificial body is mounted to an interior portion of the housing adjacent a periphery of the impeller.
In certain of the embodiments, the sacrificial body is mounted to the impeller for rotation therewith.
In a fourth aspect, an embodiment provides an apparatus for retarding damage to a pump due to cavitation includes a sacrificial body adapted to be mounted within the pump, the sacrificial body being formed of a material selected to shed electrons when immersed within a flowing fluid of the pump. At least one needle is mounted to the sacrificial body and formed of a material more resistant to corrosion due to the flowing fluid than the sacrificial body.
In certain embodiments, the sacrificial body includes a sleeve having a profile formed on an exterior surface to enhance turbulence of fluid flowing over the sleeve, the profile adapted to be upstream of the at least one needle.
In certain embodiments, the sacrificial body includes a disk having a circular periphery and adapted to be mounted to an inner end of a plunger of the pump. The needle is mounted to a face of the disk in alignment with an axis of the disk.
In certain embodiments, the needle is recessed within a cavity formed in the face of the disk. A flow port extends through a portion of the disk to a base of the cavity for directing fluid to the needle.
In certain embodiments, the sacrificial body includes a ring adapted to be mounted to a downstream face of an suction valve of the pump. The needle is mounted to the face of the ring in alignment with an axis of the ring.
In certain embodiments, a flow port leads from one side of the ring to the face of the ring adjacent the needle, the flow port being outboard of an inner diameter of the ring.
In certain embodiments, the sacrificial body is mounted on a support rod. The support rod adapted to be mounted to an interior portion of the pump.
In certain of the embodiments, the sacrificial body is formed from of a material from the group consisting of zinc, aluminum, magnesium or alloys thereof.
Other aspects, features, and advantages will become apparent from the following detailed description when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, which are a part of this disclosure and which illustrate, by way of example, the principles disclosed.
The accompanying drawings facilitate an understanding of the various embodiments.
Referring to
A schematically shown discharge valve 20 is located in the discharge passage 19. The discharge valve 20 is spring-biased to a closed position, and will open when the pressure in the chamber 15 is sufficiently high. A suction valve 22 is located in the suction passage 21. The suction valve 22 is biased to a closed position and will open when the pressure differential of the intake pressure over the pressure in the chamber 15 is sufficient to overcome the bias of the spring and allow fluid to be admitted to the chamber 15.
A flange connector 23 secures to the fluid end block 13 on one side around the plunger bore 17. A plunger 25 reciprocates within the flange connector 23 and the plunger bore 17 and is stroked between an outer intake position and an inner discharge position by a conventional power source (not shown). A seal or packing assembly 27 is located in the flange connector 23 and sealingly engages the outer diameter of the plunger 25. A packing nut 29 secures to internal threads at the outer end of the flange connector 23. The packing nut 29, when rotated, preloads the packing 27 to provide a seal for the plunger 25. Normally, the fluid end block 13 will have three or five of the chambers 15, plungers 25, and sets of valves 20 and 22.
In a first embodiment, a device to retard the effects of cavitation includes a sacrificial body in the form of a sleeve 31, which surrounds the plunger 25 and fits stationarily within the bore of the flange connector 23 and the plunger bore 17. As shown in
Referring still to
The sacrificial body includes a number of needles 39 (only one shown) mounted around rim 40 of the sleeve 31. The turbulent fluid flowing out the annulus during the power stroke flows around them. Each of the needles 39 has a sharp tip and protrudes inward or downstream from the rim 40 into the chamber 15 (
The sleeve 31 is a sacrificial body formed of a material or materials that has characteristics for easily releasing electrons. The material may be, for example, zinc, aluminum, magnesium or alloys of these metals. This material is of a less noble metal than the fluid end block 13, which is formed of a steel alloy. The material of the sleeve 31 has a lower electrochemical potential than the steel alloy of the fluid end block 13, thus the sleeve 31 will corrode more easily due to fluid flowing over it.
The needles 39 can be made of a metal more resistant than the metal of the sleeve 31 to mitigate corrosion and pitting of the needles. Thus the needles 39 will be of a material with a higher electrochemical potential than the sleeve 31. For example, the needles 39 may be fanned of stainless steel. The metal of the base of each of the needles 39 will be in contact with the metal of the sleeve 31 such that the needles 39 and the sleeve 31 serve to shed or emit electrons from the sleeve 31 into the fluid flowing past the needles 39.
As mentioned, the sleeve 31 may have profiles to enhance cavitation, causing the formation and collapse of bubbles which, if unchecked, can result in chemical changes of the steel components, particularly the release of hydrogen ions. Hydrogen ions have a corrosive effect on the molecular structure of the metal of the fluid end block 13, causing small particles of the metal to separate and enter the fluid stream. This release of metal particles contributes to pitting. The release of negatively-charged electrons from the needles 39 mitigates the formation of hydrogen ions, which are also negatively charged. Because of the cavitation, erosion and corrosion will occur on the sleeve 31; however, it is intended to be expendable. The sleeve 31 is not connected to any voltage potential, rather releases electrons as a result of the turbulent fluid flowing over it.
Referring to
As the plunger 49 strokes inward, the fluid will flow into each of the cavities 61, around one of the needles 63, then out one of the bypass ports 65 to the outer diameter of the plunger 49. The swirling fluid causes cavitation to occur as it flows around the needles 63. The components of the needles 63 and the disk 53 may be the same materials as in the first embodiment to facilitate the shedding of electrons for the same purpose as discussed above.
Referring to
The ring 89 has a plurality of needles 91 (only one shown) mounted to its face. The needles 91 extend inward, parallel with an axis of the seat ring 81. The needles 91 protrude inward past the inner end 85 of the suction valve 73. The ring 89 and the needles 91 may be formed of the same materials as the first embodiment for emitting electrons. To facilitate the cavitation occurring in the vicinity of the needles 91, a number of bypass ports 93 (only one shown) extend obliquely from the inner side of the ring 89. Each of the bypass ports 93 also extends to the valve body outer diameter 83. As the valve 73 strokes toward and away from the seat 81, fluid will be forced through the bypass ports 93 and around the needles 91. Preferably one of the bypass ports 93 will be located adjacent each of the needles 91.
Another embodiment is illustrated in
As shown in
At least some of the embodiments for the reciprocating pumps illustrated in
Referring to
In this embodiment, a number of sacrificial bodies 131 are mounted stationarily around the inner wall of the housing 121. The sacrificial bodies 131 include needles 135 that point generally in a downstream direction so that fluid flowing past will collect electrons to suppress hydrogen ions that might otherwise occur in the vicinity of the inner wall of the housing 121. In this example, the sacrificial body 131 has a mounting portion shown on the exterior of the housing 121. The mounting portion could be located within the interior. Also, the inner wall of the housing 121 could include a portion of a diffuser for each of the impellers 125. As in the other embodiments, the sacrificial bodies 131 are formed of a sacrificial metal for shedding electrons into the fluid flow.
In the embodiment of
The various embodiments in
In the foregoing description of certain embodiments, specific terminology has been resorted to for the sake of clarity. However, the disclosure is not intended to be limited to the specific terms so selected, and it is to be understood that each specific term includes other technical equivalents which operate in a similar manner to accomplish a similar technical purpose. Terms such as “left” and right”, “front” and “rear”, “above” and “below” and the like are used as words of convenience to provide reference points and are not to be construed as limiting terms.
In this specification, the word “comprising” is to be understood in its “open” sense, that is, in the sense of “including”, and thus not limited to its “closed” sense, that is the sense of “consisting only of”. A corresponding meaning is to be attributed to the corresponding words “comprise”, “comprised” and “comprises” where they appear.
In addition, the foregoing describes only some embodiments of the disclosure, and alterations, modifications, additions and/or changes can be made thereto without departing from the scope and spirit of the disclosed embodiments, the embodiments being illustrative and not restrictive.
Furthermore, the disclosure has been described in connection with what are presently considered to be the most practical and preferred embodiments. It is to be understood that the disclosure is not to be limited to the disclosed embodiments, but on the contrary, is intended to cover various modifications and equivalent arrangements included within the spirit and scope of the disclosure. Also, the various embodiments described above may be implemented in conjunction with other embodiments, e.g., aspects of one embodiment may be combined with aspects of another embodiment to realize yet other embodiments. Further, each independent feature or component of any given assembly may constitute an additional embodiment.
Claims
1. A method of reducing cavitation damage to a component within a pump, comprising:
- (a) mounting a sacrificial body within the pump; and
- (b) operating the pump to pump fluid at a rate that causes at least some cavitation to occur on the component,
- wherein the pumped fluid flows over the sacrificial body to shed electrons into the flowing fluid in the vicinity of said cavitation.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the sacrificial body comprises a material that is more easily corroded than the component.
3. The method according to claim 1, wherein in use the operating step causes hydrogen ions to release from the component, the release of which is mitigated by said shedding of electrons from the sacrificial body.
4. The method according to claim 1, further comprising attaching at least one needle to the sacrificial body to facilitate the shedding of the electrons from the sacrificial body.
5. The method according to claim 4, wherein in use the needle is pointing downstream.
6. The method according to claim 4, wherein the needle is formed of a metal that is less subject to corrosion than the sacrificial body.
7. The method according to claim 1, further comprising the step of mounting an upstream portion of the sacrificial body into the pump, the sacrificial body having a profile to enhance turbulence of the fluid flowing over the sacrificial body.
8. The method according to claim 1, wherein the pump is positioned such that no portion of the pump is immersed in the fluid to be pumped by the pump.
9. The method according to claim 1, wherein the sacrificial body is formed from one or more materials from the group comprising zinc, aluminum, magnesium or alloys thereof.
10. The method according to claim 1, wherein the component comprises a fluid end block having a chamber, a plunger bore leading to the chamber, a suction valve port leading to the chamber, and a discharge valve port passing from the chamber.
11. The method according to claim 10, wherein step (a) comprises mounting the sacrificial body within the chamber.
12. The method according to claim 10, wherein step (a) comprises mounting the sacrificial body stationarily within the plunger bore surrounding the plunger.
13. The method according to claim 10, wherein step (a) comprises mounting the sacrificial body to the suction valve for movement therewith.
14. The method according y claim 10, wherein step (a) comprises mounting the sacrificial body within the suction valve port upstream from a suction valve.
15. The method according to claim 10, wherein the component comprises a plunger in the plunger bore.
16. The method according to claim 15, wherein step (a) comprises mounting a sacrificial body to the plunger.
17. The method according to claim 1, wherein the component comprises a housing having a rotatable impeller therein.
18. The method according to claim 17, wherein step (a) comprises mounting the sacrificial body within the housing adjacent a periphery of the impeller.
19. The method according to claim 17, wherein step (a) comprises mounting the sacrificial body to the impeller for rotation therewith.
20. A pump, comprising:
- a fluid end block having a chamber, a plunger bore leading to the chamber, a suction valve port leading to the chamber, and a discharge valve port passing from the chamber;
- suction and discharge valves mounted for reciprocation within the suction valve port and discharge valve port, respectively;
- a sacrificial body mounted within the fluid end block for immersion during use in fluid flow; and
- the sacrificial body being formed of a material less resistant to corrosion as compared to the fluid end block.
21. The pump according to claim 20, further comprising at least one needle mounted to the sacrificial body, the needle being immersed in use in the fluid flow.
22. The pump according to claim 21, wherein the needle is formed of a metal more resistant to corrosion than the sacrificial body.
23. The pump according to claim 20, further comprising a profile configured to enhance turbulence.
24. The pump according to claim 20, wherein the sacrificial body is formed from one or more materials from the group comprising zinc, aluminum, magnesium or alloys thereof.
25. The pump according to claim 20, wherein the sacrificial body comprises a sleeve mounted stationarily within the plunger bore surrounding the plunger.
26. The pump according to claim 20, wherein the sacrificial body is mounted to a forward end of the plunger for movement therewith.
27. The pump according to claim 20, wherein the sacrificial body is mounted to the suction valve for movement therewith.
28. The pump according to claim 20, wherein the sacrificial body is mounted within the suction valve port upstream from the suction valve.
29. A pump, comprising:
- a housing;
- a rotatable impeller mounted within the housing;
- a sacrificial body mounted within the housing for immersion within fluid flow as the impeller rotates during use; and
- the sacrificial body formed of a material less resistant to corrosion than the impeller and the housing.
30. The pump according to claim 29, wherein the sacrificial body is mounted to an interior portion of the housing adjacent a periphery of the impeller.
31. The pump according to claim 29, wherein the sacrificial body is mounted to the impeller for rotation therewith.
32. An apparatus for retarding damage to a pump due to cavitation, comprising:
- a sacrificial body adapted to be mounted within the pump, the sacrificial body being formed of a material selected to shed electrons when immersed within a flowing fluid of the pump; and
- at least one needle mounted to the sacrificial body and formed of a material more resistant to corrosion due to the flowing fluid than the sacrificial body.
33. The apparatus according to claim 32, wherein the sacrificial body comprises a sleeve having a profile formed on an exterior surface to enhance turbulence of fluid flowing over the sleeve in use, the profile adapted to be upstream of the at least one needle.
34. The apparatus according to claim 32, wherein the sacrificial body comprises a disk having a circular periphery and adapted to be mounted to an inner end of a plunger of the pump, wherein the at least one needle is mounted to a face of the disk in alignment with an axis of the disk.
35. The apparatus according to claim 34, wherein the at least one needle is recessed within a cavity formed in the face of the disk and a flow port extends through a portion of the disk to a base of the cavity for directing fluid to the needle.
36. The apparatus according to claim 32, wherein the sacrificial body comprises a ring adapted to be mounted to a downstream face of an suction valve of the pump, wherein the at least one needle is mounted to the face of the ring in alignment with an axis of the ring.
37. The apparatus according to claim 36, further comprising a flow port leading from one side of the ring to the face of the ring adjacent the at least one needle and the flow port being outboard of an inner diameter of the ring.
38. The apparatus according to claim 32, further comprising a support rod upon which the sacrificial body is mounted and the support rod is adapted to be mounted to an interior portion of the pump.
39. The apparatus according to claim 32, wherein the sacrificial body is formed from of a material from the group consisting of zinc, aluminum, magnesium or alloys thereof.
40. The pump according to claim 23, wherein the profile being located on an upstream portion of the sacrificial body.
Type: Application
Filed: Jun 17, 2011
Publication Date: Dec 22, 2011
Applicant: S.P.M. Flow Control, Inc. (Fort Worth, TX)
Inventor: Joseph H. Byrne (Hudson Oaks, TX)
Application Number: 13/162,815
International Classification: C23F 13/02 (20060101); F01D 25/00 (20060101);