METHOD, APPARATUS AND ARTICLE-OF-MANUFACTURE FOR THE CREATION, ISSUANCE, TRADING, AND EXERCISE OF REFUND OPTIONS FOR ATTENDANCE RIGHTS
Computer-related methods, apparatus, and/or articles of manufacture to permit/facilitate the creation, marketing, and/or distribution of options to purchase tickets or obtain refunds to a particular future event, particularly an elimination format competition, when the chosen competitor's qualification for such a game is currently uncertain, but where the uncertainty will be resolved prior to the commencement of the particular future event.
Latest The Ticket RESERVE, Inc. Patents:
- Method, apparatus and article-of-manufacture for the creation, issuance, trading, and exercise of refund options for attendance rights
- METHOD, APPARATUS AND ARTICLE-OF-MANUFACTURE FOR THE CREATION, ISSUANCE, TRADING, AND EXERCISE OF REFUND OPTIONS FOR ATTENDANCE RIGHTS
- SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR TRADING CONTINGENCY BASED OPTIONS AND FUTURES FOR A TRAVEL-RELATED ITEM
- Systems and methods for contingency-based options and futures for contingent travel accommodations based upon a playoff game
- Systems and methods for contingency-based options and futures for playoff tickets based on qualifying teams
This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/401,260 filed Feb. 21, 2012, which is a continuation U.S. patent application Ser. No. 12/762,357 filed Apr. 18, 2010 (now abandoned), which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/716,072 filed on Mar. 8, 2007 (now abandoned), which is a divisional of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/435,168 filed Nov. 5, 1999 (now U.S. Pat. No. 7,206,755 issued Apr. 17, 2007). The entire content of each of the above applications is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
FIELD OF THE INVENTIONThis invention generally relates to the field of computer-implemented business methods and financial instruments; more particularly, the invention relates to a method, apparatus and article-of-manufacture to permit/facilitate the creation of the options to purchase attendance rights (tickets), and derivative instruments on these options, to a particular event and/or subsequent events in an elimination format (or selection based on performance) competition.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTIONIn almost all events that have an elimination style narrowing of the field or a process of selection of a limited number of participants from a larger pool of participants based on prior performance (sports competitions), there are a number of problems faced by supporters:
Inability to purchase desired attendance rights in advance: For playoff type events, fans would like to purchase tickets at the start of the season, but since the outcome is uncertain, the authorized ticketing authorities (e.g., team owners) do not offer these tickets until continuation in the tournament is guaranteed (e.g., end of the regular season). Therefore, there is long lead time between when individuals would like to purchase tickets to these subsequent competitions and when such tickets are usually offered.
Requirements to purchase unwanted tickets, merely to guarantee attendance at a particular event of interest: For tournament type events, fans typically have to commit to buying tickets without being sure who the actual competitors would be, with the possibility of the two participants being competitors that the fan has no desire to watch.
Reliance on “scalpers” and other unreliable sources: As the information on who will participate in future rounds evolves, an individual may find that it is more difficult to obtain tickets to these future rounds. Some preference may be given to season ticket holders, but there is normally a long wait list and a greater financial cost to become a recipient of a season ticket. Therefore, individuals are often forced to purchase such tickets through “scalpers,” “ticket brokers,” or other unsavory characters or risk not obtaining such tickets at all.
Inability to actively manage “ticket availability” risk: For fans willing to absorb the risk of their options never vesting, there is also potentially an advantage to purchasing an “option” to the ticket early on when such uncertainty is great vis-à-vis waiting until there is absolute certainty about the competitor's participation in the chosen event/game. Such “option” could potentially be offered to them at lower cost (i.e., “discounted” in accordance with the probability that the competitor will not qualify for the event). Currently, fans have to wait for the outcome to be finally decided and they risk either not getting a ticket allocation or having to pay a significant premium to scalpers.
Lack of a secondary market: Currently, there is no official secondary market for post-season tickets, so that if individuals cannot attend such events, they are left with the problem of disposing of such tickets themselves.
Moreover, in addition to creating various problems for fans, the current method for selling and distributing elimination- or competition-based attendance rights is not particularly well-suited to the interests of owners/organizers either. Among the problems faced by the event organizers/team owners are:
Absence of an efficient market clearing mechanism: Fan interest in attending these higher round competitions varies depending upon the competitors—i.e., they would want to attend if their favorite competitors advance, but would not necessarily care if their preferred competitors are eliminated. Typically, however, when sporting events reach the point where such fan interest is at a peak (when a team has qualified for the playoffs or the final match-up of a tennis tournament is set), there is a substantial imbalance between the supply of tickets for the games (which is fixed) and the demand for these tickets. Since prices tend to be fixed (by the teams or tournament organizers), there is no efficient market clearing mechanism and tickets are sold on a first come/first-served basis. There is a considerable unmet demand at this point that is never satisfied by the event organizer and hence goes to waste.
Revenue lost to unexploited demand: As explained above, team owners/event organizers are not maximizing their revenues. Currently, only teams that qualify for post-season play make revenues from such ticket sales. To illustrate this point, in a tournament with 64 players, the organizers can allocate 5,000 seats (or 2,500 seats per optioned contestant) for the final match to options holders. If there were sufficient demand for each of the contestants, the organizers could sell up to 160,000 options on all the contestants, and only 5,000 of these options will vest. Similarly, in team sports with a playoff style elimination, all teams can issue such options and get some revenue, where currently, no such opportunity exists. In this way, the organizers have captured all the demand available (thereby maximizing revenues), fans have been able to match their needs to the financial cost of satisfying the need, and the event is attended by fans most interested in the event, because the options allow such matching.
Risk that “popular” teams/competitors will be eliminated in early rounds: Under the current system, team owners/event organizers may face financial difficulties if, for example, the qualifying competitors are not popular, of if all the “favorites” are eliminated in the early rounds of competition. In these instances, there may be very little fan interest in the later round(s) of competition and expected revenues from these rounds may never, in fact, materialize.
Unpredictable revenues, based on performance: Under the current system, team owners (and event organizers) have little, if any, ability to hedge against the risk of poor performance or “upsets”—which may substantially diminish fan interest in the event.
Generally speaking, options represent the right to acquire or dispose a specified asset at a predetermined price within a defined time period. The predetermined price is referred to as the “strike price” and the date on which the option ceases to be effective is called its maturity/expiration date. These parameters, along with the current market value of the underlying asset, largely determine the value of the option. Other factors in the valuation are the volatility of the value of the underlying asset (a measure of the probability that the current value will be favorable vis-à-vis the strike price) and the interest rate (to quantify the carrying cost or the cost of financing the purchase). For a detailed discussion on options, see John Hull “Options, Futures and Other Derivative Securities,” Prentice-Hall, Chapter 7.
Alternative forms of options have included those that provide a pre-specified payoff when an event occurs during a defined time period. These latter types of options are more in the nature of an insurance policy type of application than a true option. See, e.g., U.S. Pat. No. 4,766,539. Examples of these are options on bonds that can be purchased by the owner of the option from the seller of the option, at a pre-specified price, should an earthquake occur in a specified area during a specified period of time.
Options have been used for hedging the risk of changes in the value of the underlying asset or occurrence of event, or for investment and speculation. The option seller, who is willing to make this commitment to the option purchaser, receives the proceeds from the sale of the option and is better off for having been able to sell such rights. Computerized methods for trading traditional futures/options have existed for many years. See, e.g., U.S. Pat. No. 4,903,201, incorporated herein by reference. There have been other applications of options-type instruments beyond financial instruments and commodities, such as options to purchase airline tickets. See, e.g., U.S. Pat. No. 5,797,127, incorporated herein by reference. And there are currently computer systems that manage the sale and issue of tickets to a variety of events and under various sale conditions, like refundable and non-refundable, fixed terms and changeable terms, and so on, e.g., U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,598,477 and 5,953,705, incorporated herein by reference.
At present, significant problems and inefficiencies exist in the selling/distribution of post-season and tournament attendance rights, and there remains a significant need for improved methods, apparatus and articles-of-manufacture to facilitate efficient sale/distribution of such attendance rights.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTIONAccordingly, one object of the present invention relates to computer-related method(s), apparatus and/or article(s)-of-manufacture that solve(s), at least in part, one or more of the above-identified problems with the current system for marketing and distributing attendance rights.
Another object of the invention concerns computer-related method(s), apparatus and/or article(s)-of-manufacture to permit/facilitate the creation, marketing and/or distribution of options to purchase tickets to a particular future event, particularly an elimination format competition, when the chosen competitor's qualification for such a game is currently uncertain, but where the uncertainty will be resolved prior to the commencement of the particular future event.
Still another object of the present invention relates to creation of an online, real-time computer-based system and method to facilitate the initial marketing and valuation of these options, as well as the subsequent trading of these options until their expiration.
A yet further object of the invention relates to attendance right option marketing/trading systems and methods which display the status of a host of options in multiple events, for different stages of competition, and for a multitude of competitors, and which manage a plurality of individual investment/trading accounts, allowing for the purchase and subsequent sale of the displayed options through a payment processing agency (credit card charge or bank facility), payment of revenue share amounts to a ticket issuing authority, a clearing mechanism to manage trades between individuals, charge a transaction fee to the individuals participating, and final payment, if necessary, back to the individuals who may have credit balances if so requested.
Still further objects of the invention relate to computer-based method(s), apparatus and/or article(s)-of-manufacture to store data on all transactions, track current and historical quotes of the various options traded, compute indices that track the investment values represented by various options, compute the relative probabilities that the option prices imply of various outcomes, and provide tools to facilitate option valuation for the participating individuals.
And an additional object of the invention relates to the creation, marketing, trading and valuation of derivative financial instruments based on various attendance right options.
These, and other objects/advantages, are realized, at least in part, by the present invention, the general aspects of which are outlined below.
Generally speaking, and without intending to be limiting, one aspect of the present invention relates to a computer-based method for marketing attendance right options, comprising, for example: storing, in a computer, information related to attendance right options; linking said computer to at least one user terminal through a data communication link; and displaying, at said user terminal, information concerning selected attendance right option(s). “Storing” may include writing said information into a random access memory, writing said information into a magnetic storage device, and/or writing said information into an optical storage device, and may also include storing information identifying a particular attendance right and a current offer or bid for the option to purchase said particular attendance right, storing information identifying a particular attendance right and a current highest bid for the option to purchase said particular attendance right, storing a complete bid history concerning the option to purchase said particular attendance right, storing option expiration information, storing information related to vesting of a particular attendance right option (such as an identification of a particular team or competitor who must qualify for the particular event, an identification of a particular round of play, and/or an identification of home or away status of the particular event). Preferably, each option includes an associated certificate or certification number.
The data communication link preferably includes at least one internet segment, and the linking process preferably includes authenticating the user terminal as an authorized user.
“Displaying” preferably involves use of an internet browser, and includes displaying information identifying a particular attendance right and bid(s) and/or offer(s) on the option to purchase said particular attendance right, information identifying a particular attendance right and a current highest bid for the option to purchase said particular attendance right, a complete bid history for said particular attendance right, a date on which a sale of the option to purchase said particular attendance right will take place, account balance information for the user of said user terminal, option position information for the user of said user terminal, up-to-date option valuation information (wherein the option valuation information is preferably computed from current sports wagering data and/or user-input probabilities concerning option-vesting contingencies), and/or the net profit/loss for positions currently held by the user of said user terminal (wherein net profit/loss is preferably computed from the current bid(s)/offer(s) on positions similar to those held by the user). “Displaying” may further include sending notification to customers regarding the availability of certain specified options through available communication mechanisms (e.g., phone, email, broadcast, letter, etc.).
Other aspect(s) of the invention relate to receiving a command, over said communication link, from a user of said user terminal, which may include a command to purchase the option to purchase a particular attendance right at a previously-displayed offer price, a command to place a specified bid on the option to purchase a particular attendance right, a command to cancel a specified bid on the option to purchase a particular attendance right, and/or a command to place and maintain a bid, higher than the current highest bid, but subject to a limit, on the option to purchase a particular attendance right.
Yet another aspect of the invention relates to receiving bid(s) and/or offer(s) on selected attendance right options, and, optionally, clearing said bid(s) and/or offer(s) through an auction or market clearing process that serves a revenue maximization function for the seller. This may involve a Dutch auction, or an open outcry auction process, or other types of sealed bid/disclosed bid auctions. Further, in matching bid(s) and offer(s), the mechanism may be as simple as pure matching at the highest price and volume levels, or may incorporate more sophisticated ways of clearing the market, like a specialist market maker function or automated closing of the bid offer spread.
Certain aspects of the present invention are depicted in the accompanying drawings, which are intended to be considered in conjunction with the detailed description below, and which are intended to be illustrative rather than limiting, and, in which:
Referring to
In accordance with the invention, an option is preferably an event-strike option with the following characteristics: the individual purchaser of the option acquires the right to purchase tickets at a predetermined price (or the payoff) from the seller of the option, should the competitor on whom they chose the option advance to a pre-specified higher round of competition (or the strike event). The maturity of the option is the date on which it is finally/irrevocably decided whether the competitor progresses or not. If the competitor on whom the option was purchased does not qualify for the specified round of competition, the option expires worthless and the owner of the option receives no compensation. The settlement of the option will take place within an appropriate time frame subsequent to maturity and prior to the specified event commencing. The settlement could take place in a number of ways including physical or electronic acknowledgment of ownership of such tickets.
For example, the customer would pick a team/player underlying the option purchased to reach a specified higher level round of competition (e.g., wild-card, quarterfinals, semifinals, up to and including the final round of competition) in the tournament. If that team/player qualifies for the round of competition specified in the option contract, the customer has the right to purchase an attendance ticket from the authorized ticketing body at a given fixed price. The higher round of play could be either a single event elimination or a multiple event series. The customer can purchase the option to any or all games of the chosen round of competition. The invention is applicable to tournaments where there is a regular season that determines qualification for an ensuing play-off contest (e.g., basketball, football, athletics, golf, soccer, cricket tournaments) or to pure elimination style competitions (e.g., match play golf, tennis, figure skating, etc.).
Reference is now made to
Reference is now made to
Reference is now made to
Reference is now made to
In
Reference is now made to
Reference is now made to
Reference is now made to
The above described arrangement is largely illustrative of the principles of the current invention. For example, while the illustrative embodiment(s) is/are described in terms of “options” to purchase particular attendance rights, the invention can be alternatively implemented by issuing/marketing “contingent attendance rights”—i.e., an actual attendance right for an event that may, or may not, take place, such as a “second round home playoff game at Texas Stadium.” This contingent attendance right is, in effect, the same as an option, but does not require that the ticket issuing authority keep track of vesting and actually issue tickets after the vesting period. Other facilities provided by the creation of these options include the ability to split the rights to post-season tickets associated with season ticket ownership. Further, another alternative implementation could be the sale of tickets to such events with a refund option and a refund fee that would de facto be the option price at initial issue. Finally, it is not critical to this invention that a secondary market to trade these options exists. This is a feature that adds functionality useful to customers but the rest of the advantages of this invention are still available to all parties if only the initial issue of options was available.
Other advantages, modifications, and adaptations of the invention will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art. For example, the present invention allows fans to buy attendance options well in advance—as early as before the entire competition starts and all the way until the settlement time—before the commencement of the actual event(s) covered by the option(s). Therefore, fans are able to lock-in the ability to purchase attendance rights to certain events under certain desired circumstances (e.g., round of play, competitors, etc.). Option holders can thereafter trade their options (until maturity of the individual options), and continue to do so based on the ongoing performance of the competitors.
Based on the prices of the multitude of options on all competitors and competitions, the present invention also facilitates the development of derivative instruments on these options and indices, and probabilities and statistical measures to quantify the odds of the various competitors reaching the different levels of competition. These can be used extensively to evaluate, among other things, competitors across the specified competition or across competitions (i.e., either in different locations or across time periods).
The present invention preferably—though not necessarily—works in conjunction with fixed price attendance rights/tickets, and allows the options to capture the market premium (or consumer surplus) that supply and demand imbalances would create.
The invention allows all team owners to generate revenues by selling options for potential post-season play, so that there is some potential revenue (no matter how small), even if the team does not qualify. For tournament event organizers in single elimination style competition (e.g., tennis tournaments), the present invention allows for the sale of multiple options on a fixed number of seats, thereby expanding the market size (and hence revenues) significantly. The invention also allows team owners/event organizers to hedge against the uncertainty of future revenues.
Unlike traditional financial options, the options marketed and traded in accordance with the present invention relate to attendance rights to events under very specific circumstances, like defined competitors and round of play. Hence, the outcome (i.e., whether the option will be valuable or “in the money”) is uncertain at initial issue and for a large part of the trading period.
Vesting of the options takes place when the chosen competitors underlying the option qualify for the competitive event specified. Such vesting preferably—though not necessarily—produces an obligation to purchase attendance rights/tickets to the specified event at a face value price of those attendance rights/tickets. In traditional options, the vesting takes place over time leading up to maturity, and options are exercised only if they are “in the money” or the strike price is favorable to the price of the underlying asset.
Unlike traditional ticketing systems, which only allow for returns and/or refunds (if at all), the present invention envisions the options either expiring worthless or being converted into the purchase of tickets. Further, a secondary market will be created to allow for the ongoing trade in these options, and to allow subsequent participants to enter and also create liquidity for initial participants.
Thus, the present invention fills a void of unmet market ticket purchaser demand; it provides a product/service that allows the various market participants to interact freely to satisfy such demand; and it simultaneously provides a mechanism that incorporates individuals' subjective evaluation of competitive outcomes to value such products (a price discovery mechanism), and further facilitates the trading of such a product based on an individual's valuation of the option vis-à-vis the rest of the purchasers and sellers (i.e., the marketplace). The present invention also facilitates the hedging of risks. For example, in some competitive events, the individual must purchase tickets today for future rounds, without the knowledge of who the participants may be. As the competition evolves, a ticket holder maybe less interested to see a certain round of competition and would like to hedge against this risk. If he/she has purchased tickets for a particular round of competition, he/she could potentially sell an option on his/her ticket should a competitor he/she dislikes be a competitor in that round. However, another individual may have exactly the opposite desire, and may want to be cautious about spending the entire cost of the ticket on the day tickets go on sale, as he/she may like the competitor that the current holder of the ticket dislikes, but think that that competitor has a low probability of advancing. The invention facilitates the matching of these two desires to create an efficient, market-driven outcome.
Claims
1. A method for providing a marketplace for an option right to attend a future event, the method implemented on a computer system and comprising the steps of:
- facilitating a creation of a contingent right to purchase a ticket to a future event coupled with an obligation to purchase the ticket, the future event being an event at which spectators pay to view activities having a restricted attendance, wherein the contingent right and the obligation to purchase the ticket vest upon an occurrence of a future outcome that is uncertain at the time of the creation of the contingent right;
- providing an online marketplace for a seller to offer for sale the contingent right;
- providing a valuation of the contingent right to the seller based on bidding activity by market participants;
- providing a platform for a bidder to view the offer for sale and submit a bid to purchase the contingent right, the platform including a communication link wherein, when the bidder submits the bid, the seller receives the bid through the communication link and the seller has an option to accept or reject the bid;
- allowing for a transfer of the contingent right from the seller to the bidder when the seller accepts the bid; and
- allowing the bidder to resell the contingent right in the online marketplace.
2. The method of claim 1 wherein the future outcome includes participation in the activities of the future event by certain participants that are uncertain at the time of the creation of the contingent right.
3. The method of claim 2 wherein the certain participants include at least one of a team, an athlete, a band, and a performer.
4. The method of claim 1 wherein the future outcome is an occurrence of the future event itself, which is uncertain at the time of the creation of the contingent right.
5. The method of claim 1 wherein the online marketplace includes an auction.
6. The method of claim 1 further comprising storing information on a plurality of future events, the information including one or more details regarding the future events.
7. The method of claim 6 wherein the one or more details include at least one of a number of seats, a location of seats, a class of seats and their face values, and tentative times and dates for the future event.
8. The method of claim 1 wherein the future event is a competitive sporting event with a playoff style elimination.
9. A method for providing a marketplace for rights to attend a future event, the method implemented on a computer system and comprising the steps of:
- receiving information from a ticket issuing authority regarding a ticket being allocated for a creation of an option right to attend a future event, the future event being a competitive sporting event at which spectators pay to view a competition having a restricted attendance, wherein the option right vests upon occurrence of a future outcome that is uncertain at the time of the creation of the option rights, and wherein the option right includes an obligation to purchase the ticket upon occurrence of the future outcome;
- providing access for market participants to view the option right and an ability to search a plurality of option rights offered in the market based on specified search criteria;
- providing market participants with an ability to post bids on option rights they are interested in acquiring, the option rights including specifications pertaining to a plurality of option factors;
- verifying posted bids to determine whether the bids are accepted, rejected, or pending; and
- performing at least one of (i) processing a payment if a bid is accepted, (ii) notifying a market participant that posted a bid that the bid is rejected, or (iii) forwarding pending bids to a market clearing mechanism configured to determine an optimal pricing to match supply and demand of the option rights.
10. The method of claim 9 wherein the option factors include at least one of a participant competing, a round of play, a series of play, a number of seats, and a bid price.
11. The method of claim 9 wherein the information includes at least one of a number of seats, a location of seats, a class of seats, a face value of a seat, a tentative time, and a tentative date.
12. The method of claim 9 wherein the future outcome is participation in the activities of the future event by certain participants that are uncertain at the time of the creation of the option rights.
13. The method of claim 12 wherein the participants include at least one of a team and an individual athlete.
14. The method of claim 9 wherein the future outcome is occurrence of the future event itself, which is uncertain at the time of the creation of the option rights.
15. The method of claim 9 wherein the access for market participants comprises access to an auction.
16. The method of claim 9 further comprising storing information on a plurality of future events, the information including details regarding the future events.
17. The method of claim 9 further comprising facilitating a revenue maximization objective by adjusting criteria associated with the option rights, the criteria including at least one of a minimum price reserve level and a volume offered.
18. The method of claim 9 wherein the market clearing mechanism is configured to match open sell offers and purchase bids.
19. The method of claim 9 wherein the market clearing mechanism is configured to keep a posted sell offer open for a defined period of time dependent upon the posted bids.
20. The method of claim 9 wherein the market clearing mechanism is configured to close a posted sell offer if there are no matched purchase bids for the sell offer at the end of a defined period of time.
Type: Application
Filed: Mar 10, 2014
Publication Date: Sep 4, 2014
Applicant: The Ticket RESERVE, Inc. (Lake Forest, IL)
Inventor: Sanjay P. Muralidhar (Plano, TX)
Application Number: 14/202,054
International Classification: G06Q 10/02 (20060101);