METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR VIBRATORY FINISHING OF COMPOSITE LAMINATE PARTS
A method for vibratory finishing of a composite laminate part includes placing particles of a vibratory media, comprising titanium oxide abrasive in a synthetic binder, into a trough of a vibratory finishing machine, placing a composite laminate part into the trough and substantially immersed in the vibratory media, and operating the vibratory finishing machine at a vibrational frequency of 40 Hz to 50 Hz with the vibratory media and composite laminate part disposed in the trough.
Latest The Boeing Company Patents:
The present disclosure relates to the fabrication of composite laminated parts. More particularly, the present disclosure relates to a system and method for finishing composite laminated parts using an automated vibratory deburring process.
BACKGROUNDIn a variety of manufacturing processes, it is desirable to deburr manufactured parts after they have been machined or subjected to other processing steps. Parts that have been produced by casting, machining, laminating and other fabrication techniques frequently have burrs and surface roughness that are not considered acceptable in the final product. Finishing of such an article can include the removal of burrs and modification of the surface finish. Deburring is the general term given to various processes for rounding or smoothing the edges of parts and removing burrs from them, in order to provide a part with the desired finish characteristics.
Traditionally, deburring of manufactured parts has involved significant manual labor, using grinders and other tools to smooth the edges and surfaces of parts. More recently, vibratory deburring processes have been developed for removing burrs and smoothing the surfaces of mass-produced articles. In these processes, articles to be finished are typically placed in a vibratory finishing apparatus such as a vibratory trough or bowl, together with particles of a finishing medium, which can be an abrasive material. The finishing medium is agitated in the trough, causing the particles of the finishing medium to repeatedly contact the edges and surfaces of the articles to be finished. The finishing medium can include particles having relatively sharp points or corners, which can work their way into grooves and crevices of the article, thereby smoothing the article and removing burrs and sharp edges. In some cases, the finishing medium can have a cleaning or surface polishing effect. In many cases, the vibratory deburring process produces a slightly sanded looking surface.
While vibratory deburring of manufactured parts reduces manual labor involved in deburring and can provide more consistent results, it has primarily been applied to metal parts, and is not believed to have been applied to laminated composite parts for a variety of reasons. Consequently, deburring of advanced composite laminated parts that have been machined or fabricated is still generally performed using manual deburring tools and methods. Unfortunately, these manual processes tend to be very labor intensive, and can produce irregular results—leading to over-burring of some parts and providing parts that do not meet specifications for edge-break and surface finish.
The present disclosure is directed toward one or more of the above issues.
SUMMARYIn accordance with one aspect thereof, the present disclosure provides a method for vibratory finishing of a composite laminate part. The method includes placing particles of a vibratory media, comprising titanium oxide abrasive in a synthetic binder, into a trough of a vibratory finishing machine, placing a composite laminate part into the trough and substantially immersed in the vibratory media, and operating the vibratory finishing machine at a vibrational frequency of 40 Hz to 50 Hz with the vibratory media and composite laminate part disposed in the trough.
In accordance with another aspect thereof, the present disclosure provides a method for deburring composite laminate parts. The method includes placing particles of a vibratory media, comprising titanium oxide abrasive in a synthetic acrylic binder, into a trough of a vibratory finishing machine, placing a composite laminate part into the trough and substantially immersed in the particles of vibratory media, applying flush water to the vibratory media at a rate of about 0.35 to 0.50 gallons per hour per cubic foot of volume of the finishing media, and operating the vibratory finishing machine, with the vibratory media and composite laminate part disposed in the trough, at a vibrational frequency of 40 Hz to 50 Hz via a rotating shaft having an approximately 10% eccentric rotation, for a period of 45 to 60 minutes.
In accordance with yet another aspect thereof, the present disclosure provides a system for finishing composite laminate parts, including a vibratory finishing machine, having a trough of suitable volume to contain a composite laminate part, a volume of vibratory media particles, disposed in the trough, and a water inlet. The trough is configured to vibrate at a frequency of 40 Hz to 50 Hz. The vibratory media particles are titanium oxide abrasive in a synthetic binder. The water inlet is configured to provide process water into the trough while the vibratory finishing machine is vibrating with the composite laminate part substantially immersed in the vibratory media particles, whereby the composite laminate part is substantially deburred through contact with the vibratory media particles.
Additional features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the detailed description which follows, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, which together illustrate, by way of example, features of the invention.
While the disclosure is susceptible to various modifications and alternative forms, specific embodiments have been shown by way of example in the drawings and will be described in detail herein. However, it should be understood that the disclosure is not intended to be limited to the particular forms disclosed. Rather, the intention is to cover all modifications, equivalents and alternatives falling within the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.
DETAILED DESCRIPTIONAs noted above, mass finishing or “vibratory finishing” is a mechanical and/or chemical process that is applied to finish component parts. Vibratory finishing processes can remove burrs and smooth the surfaces of mass-produced articles. However, while vibratory deburring reduces manual labor and can provide more consistent results than manual deburring, it has primarily been applied only to metal parts. For example, manufacturers of vibratory finishing equipment acknowledge that metal parts are the major field of application for this technology, and that mass finishing technologies are also used for wood, rubber, stone and plastic. Notably, vibratory finishing is not believed to have been applied to laminated composite parts. One reason is that typical vibratory finishing media is not compatible with composite materials. Another reason is that composite laminated parts tend to “float” atop vibratory media, and do not naturally immerse themselves in the media. Additionally, vibratory finishing machines that are commercially available operate at a fixed frequency and magnitude of vibration that is not suitable to finishing laminated composite parts. Thus, known vibratory finishing systems and methods not only teach away from finishing laminated composite parts, but teach away from systems that are adjustable in a way that they could be made suitable for finishing laminated composite parts.
Advantageously, as disclosed herein, a system and method have been developed for applying vibratory deburring processes to laminated composite parts. This process utilizes automated vibratory deburring machines with specific deburring media, specific RPM and processing times to deburr these parts, which eliminates the need for manual single-part deburring of many composite parts. This saves time, money and eliminates many ergonomic issues that can arise with manual deburring. Preliminary testing with certain media has shown excellent results that meet exacting specifications.
Shown in
As shown in
Previously, vibratory finishing machines of the general type shown in
Advantageously, the vibratory finishing system depicted herein is compatible with composite materials, and its operational parameters, specifically the vibrational frequency and magnitude of vibration, have been developed and optimized for them. In one embodiment, the vibratory finishing machine 100 includes both a motor RPM controller 124 and a tachometer 126 to allow a user to adjust and verify the RPM of the motor 110, which determines the vibrational frequency. This speed adjustment mechanism allows a user to change the RPM to find an optimum RPM for the parts 106 that are to be finished, whether composite parts or other types of parts. This not only allows a user to find a suitable speed for finishing composite parts, but can also allow a single vibratory finishing machine to be selectively adjusted for use with metal parts, composite parts, and other types of parts, if desired.
In one embodiment, it has been found that a motor frequency of around 2700 RPM, with the offset counterweights 116 provided on the drive shaft 112, will vibrate the trough at a frequency in the range of 40-50 Hz, such as a specific frequency of 45 Hz. Frequencies in this range have been found to be effective for composite materials, while the typical 35 Hz frequency of prior vibratory finishing machines is not.
As shown in
Using the modified counterweight system described, it has been found that with the drive shaft rotating at a speed of 2700 RPM, the shaft demonstrates an eccentric rotation of about 10% (relative to the diameter of the shaft), as indicated by the dashed line circle 140 in
A close-up view of the trough 102 loaded with finishing media 104 and having parts 106 being finished therein is provided in
The vibratory finishing machine 100 also includes one or more water inlets 128, which provide a flow of process water to the volume of abrasive media 104. The process water, sometimes with a small amount of mild liquid soap (e.g. 30:1 water to soap ratio), is slowly metered into the media 104 to provide liquidity, some lubricity, and washing action to wash away and remove the media swarf and abraded particles of substrate. As shown in
As shown in
As described above, the finishing media 104 comprises individual abrasive particles 136. Perspective views of individual finishing media particles 136, which can be used in a deburring process in accordance with the present disclosure, are shown in
The particles 136 of finishing media 104 are made of two parts: an abrasive and a binder. In one embodiment, the abrasive includes titanium oxide, and the binder is synthetic acrylic. In a more specific embodiment the media is about 10%-20% titanium oxide, held in a binder of synthetic urea-resin that constitutes 80%-90% of the volume of the particle 104. Vibratory finishing media having this general formulation is commercially available under the product designation SY from Vibra-Finish Co. of Los Angeles, Calif., for example.
For the vibratory finishing of composite parts, as disclosed herein, it is considered desirable that the specific gravity of the finishing media be from about 1.5 to 2.0, so that the sectional density of the total volume of the particles 136 is approximately equal to the sectional density of the composite laminate parts 106 that are to be finished. This aspect of the vibratory finishing media 104 allows the composite part 106 to naturally “sink” in the media, rather than “float” atop it, thus allowing the part to become substantially immersed in the media.
This media formulation is different than the standard media commonly used for finishing metal and other parts. Specifically, many vibratory finishing media formulations use aluminum oxide as an abrasive, which is generally incompatible with composite materials. On the other hand, it has been found that titanium oxide abrasive works well with composite parts. However, it is believed that the suitability of this type of abrasive media for composite materials has not previously been known. Additionally, the binder, being a synthetic, does not require any processing compound (e.g. soap) for the finishing process. Instead, the processing fluid can be ordinary water, leaving the parts soap-free, receiving only a water rinse and towel dry at the end of the process.
The abrasive particles 136 of the media 104 are of a generally constant make-up throughout their volume, such that as each particle 136 gradually wears down with use, its surface retains the same abrasive quality, even as it changes shape and size. That is, during use, the surface of the abrasive particles 136 will gradually wear away, exposing the underlying material, which has substantially the same abrasive quality and characteristics. In this way, the abrasive particles 136 retain their operational characteristics as they gradually wear down during use, until they are of a size where it is considered desirable to replace them with new, full sized particles. Replacing the worn particles 136 can be effectively accomplished by adding new particles 136 periodically, so as to maintain a given percentage of larger full-sized particles.
The vibratory deburring process with this finishing media produces a slightly sanded looking surface on composite materials. One additional aspect of vibrational deburring of parts using the apparatus and method disclosed herein is the provision of an edge break or edge relief on parts. It is well known in manufacturing that sharp edges on mechanical parts are undesirable in many instances, but are the natural byproduct of various fabrication and/or machining processes. Shown in
A logic flowchart outlining the steps in an embodiment of a method 500 for deburring and finishing laminated composite parts in accordance with the present disclosure is provided in
After the process water is flowing, the machine can be started (step 506)—that is, the vibration can be initiated at the desired frequency. Next, the parts to be deburred can be placed into the trough of the finishing machine (step 508), with the parts being immersed in the finishing media. It has been found desirable that the volume of parts placed into the trough not exceed about 10% of the total trough volume, in order to avoid damage from the parts contacting each other, and/or to avoid the parts being inadequately finished. The parts are then left in the vibrating trough for a set time (step 510), while the process goes forward. In one embodiment, it has been found that parts can be processed for about 60 minutes with good results. In general, it is believed that vibratory finishing for about 45-60 minutes is likely to be sufficient. Those of skill in the art will be able to determine optimal settings for any given part and media combination to provide the desired edge-break and surface treatment.
After sufficient processing of the parts, the finished parts can be removed from the machine (step 512). Advantageously, parts can be removed from the trough while the machine is running, which can help to speed up the batch processing flow. Alternatively, the machine and the process water flow can be shut off (step 514) either before or after removal of the parts. After processing, the parts can be rinsed with fresh water (step 516) and dried, making them ready for use. The entire composite laminate part will show signs of deburring, which leaves a slightly dull, sanded appearance on the part, and is especially noticeable on the “tool-side” of the parts (i.e., the side of the composite part that was held against a form or “tool” while being cured). An un-deburred tool-side of a composite part will appear shiny compared to parts processed in the manner disclosed herein. After a part or a batch of parts have been finished in this manner, the process can be repeated by placing more parts into the trough (step 508), or returning to one of the prior steps, if needed.
As noted above, the finishing media particles 136 gradually wear away with use. Consequently, it is desirable to periodically refresh the vibratory media (step 518) by removing particles below a certain lower threshold size and replacing the removed particles with a comparable volume of new particles, so that the particle size distribution is kept within a desired range. This can be done by dumping all of the particles from the trough into a vibratory sieve mechanism (not shown), which sorts out all particles below a certain size, depending on the size of sieve that is used, thus removing the smallest particles. The remaining particles, which are greater in size than the sieve that was used, can be returned to the trough for continued use, and a volume of new particles (or particles of suitable size) can be placed into the trough to bring the particle volume back up to a desired “full” level (step 502). In one embodiment, refreshing of the vibratory media particles involves removing particles below about ½″ in size, and replacing them with a comparable volume of particles of 1″ to 2½″ size.
The process disclosed herein is made possible by combining specifically developed machine operational parameters and processing time with a specific and unique vibratory finishing media formulation, to allow the special deburring media to be applied to a composite substrate. Heretofore in the composite industry it is believed that this sort of process had not been attempted because the technical understanding of how to use abrasive media upon a composite substrate had not been developed.
The apparatus and method provides for the automated batch processing of composite parts, removing burrs occurring on the outer part surface. The use of automated finishing allows for batching of many parts, eliminates the human-error of over-burring, and reduces or eliminates the possibility of ergonomic issues that are often associated with manual deburring, such as carpal-tunnel syndrome. The process disclosed herein has the potential to save a tremendous amount of time and money by providing a much more cost effective and safe way to deburr the large number of composite parts that are and will be made. Labor cost will be highly reduced by transferring the labor-intensive manual deburring to automated equipment.
Although various embodiments have been shown and described, the present disclosure is not so limited and will be understood to include all such modifications and variations are would be apparent to one skilled in the art.
Claims
1. A method for vibratory finishing of a composite laminate part, comprising:
- placing particles of a vibratory media, comprising titanium oxide abrasive in a synthetic binder, into a trough of a vibratory finishing machine;
- placing a composite laminate part into the trough and substantially immersed in the vibratory media; and
- operating the vibratory finishing machine at a vibrational frequency of 40 Hz to 50 Hz with the vibratory media and composite laminate part disposed in the trough.
2. A method in accordance with claim 1, wherein the binder of the vibratory media comprises synthetic acrylic.
3. A method in accordance with claim 1, wherein the particles of vibratory media range in size from about ¼″ to about 2½″ and have a specific gravity of about 1.5 to about 2.0.
4. A method in accordance with claim 1, wherein a total volume of the particles of vibratory media in the trough have a sectional density approximately equal to a sectional density of the composite laminate part.
5. A method in accordance with claim 1, wherein the particles of vibratory media comprise about 10% to 20% titanium oxide abrasive in a binder of synthetic urea-resin.
6. A method in accordance with claim 1, further comprising operating the vibratory finishing machine for a period of 45 to 60 minutes.
7. A method in accordance with claim 1, further comprising applying flush water to the vibratory media at a rate of about 0.35-0.50 gallons per hour per cubic foot of volume of the finishing media.
8. A method in accordance with claim 1, wherein operating the vibratory finishing machine comprises rotating a drive shaft, coupled to the trough, the drive shaft having offset counterweights that cause an approximately 10% eccentric rotation of the drive shaft.
9. A method in accordance with claim 1, further comprising adjusting the vibrational frequency of the vibratory finishing machine.
10. A method in accordance with claim 1, further comprising refreshing the vibratory media by removing worn particles below about ½″ in size and replacing the worn particles with a comparable volume of particles of 1″ to 2½″ in size.
11. A method for finishing composite laminate parts, comprising:
- placing particles of a vibratory media, comprising titanium oxide abrasive in a synthetic acrylic binder, into a trough of a vibratory finishing machine;
- placing a composite laminate part into the trough and substantially immersed in the particles of vibratory media;
- applying flush water to the vibratory media at a rate of about 0.35-0.50 gallons per hour per cubic foot of volume of the finishing media; and
- operating the vibratory finishing machine, with the vibratory media and composite laminate part disposed in the trough, at a vibrational frequency of 40 Hz to 50 Hz via a rotating shaft having an approximately 10% eccentric rotation, for a period of 45 to 60 minutes.
12. A method in accordance with claim 11, wherein the particles of vibratory media range in size from about ¼″ to about 2½″ and have a specific gravity of about 1.5 to about 2.0.
13. A method in accordance with claim 11, wherein the particles of vibratory media have a sectional density approximately equal to a sectional density of the composite laminate part.
14. A method in accordance with claim 11, further comprising refreshing the vibratory media by removing particles below about ½″ in size and replacing a comparable volume of particles of 1″ to 2½″ in size.
15. A method in accordance with claim 11, further comprising removing the part from the trough and rinsing the part with water.
16. A system for finishing composite laminate parts, comprising:
- a vibratory finishing machine, having a trough of suitable volume to contain a composite laminate part, configured to vibrate at a frequency of 40 Hz to 50 Hz;
- a volume of vibratory media particles, disposed in the trough, comprising titanium oxide abrasive in a synthetic binder; and
- a water inlet, configured to provide process water into the trough while the vibratory finishing machine is vibrating with the composite laminate part substantially immersed in the vibratory media particles, whereby the composite laminate part is substantially deburred through contact with the vibratory media particles.
17. A system in accordance with claim 16, wherein the vibratory media particles range in size from ¼″ to about 2½″ and have a specific gravity of about 1.5 to about 2.0.
18. A system in accordance with claim 16, further comprising a speed adjustment mechanism, configured to allow adjustment of the vibrational frequency of the vibratory finishing machine.
19. A system in accordance with claim 16, further comprising a rotating a drive shaft, coupled to the trough, rotatable at about 2700 RPM, having offset counterweights that cause an approximately 10% eccentric rotation of the drive shaft.
20. A system in accordance with claim 16, wherein the water inlet is configured to apply flush water at a rate of up to about 0.5 gallons per hour per cubic foot of volume of the finishing media, and further comprising a water outlet, disposed in the trough, configured to drain flush water from the trough.
Type: Application
Filed: Mar 7, 2014
Publication Date: Sep 10, 2015
Applicant: The Boeing Company (Seal Beach, CA)
Inventor: Brian K. Hovik (Renton, WA)
Application Number: 14/201,083