MULTIPLE SMOOTH ELEMENTS BONDED TO A GROUND; NOVEL TOOLS AND METHODS FOR SURFACE IMPROVEMENT OF METALS AND OTHER MATERIALS
The Present Invention introduces novel methods and tools for improving the surfaces of metals and other flowable materials with smooth-surfaced tools, such as fibers and spheroids bonded to a ground. The new tools deform and compress rather than remove material, thereby increasing surface hardness, density, reflectivity, electrical conductivity, impermeability and corrosion resistance. Benefits include economies in production and maintenance, an improved work environment, and reduced costs for energy, stock materials and precious metal reclamation.
This invention relates to surface treatment of objects by using multiple smooth-surfaced elements bonded to a ground to compress material at high points on a workpiece into a material body, thus smoothing the surface without removal of material, and additionally, according to tool design and use, remove surface material not by abrasion, or cutting, but by adhesion.
More particularly, most surface modification processes involve material removal by sanding or grinding, such that high points are removed until the whole of the surface is at the level of the low points prior to smoothing. This is typically accomplished by using progressively-finer gained cutting materials.
By comparison, the new tools accomplish surface improvement by displacing material at a surface, or removing it by dragging it from the surface, i.e., by adhesion, in an orderly manner.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION Surface Modification by Granular CuttersGranular cutters, or abrasives, suitable for work ranging from heavy grinding to fine polishing, cut away the outermost atoms of a workpiece with grains selected for their size, sharpness and hardness. Since erosion, or removal of material from the workpiece is inherent in the abrasive process, the manufacturer of the workpiece compensates for the material to be cut away by including additional material in the original workpiece. The eroded material is often reclaimed, especially for materials of high value such as gold and silver, via costly, ecologically damaging processes.
The grains are incorporated into tools by processes such as:
-
- Bonding to substrates such as paper, cloth, and plastic film with a bonding medium, examples of these tools being abrasive sheets, belts and disks;
- Embedding in rigid materials to form tools such as grinding wheels and sharpening stones;
- Mixing into transferable matrices, or ‘compounds’, applied to lathe mounted buffs;
- Mixing into transferable creams and pastes;
- Combining with water and/or other ingredients into a slurry for tumbling, in which the work to be burnished is placed in rotating barrels filled with a slurry of water and loose abrasive grains.
Many applications of granular cutters, such as tool and weld grinding, purposely benefit from stock removal. However, granular cutters are used for many applications where erosion of the material is an unfortunate unnecessary byproduct especially regarding inherent reclamation costs and safety issues, examples being the tools' high speed, noise, dust generation and high energy use. Examples of processes with these disadvantages are polishing by manual or robotic lathes in which the lathes generally revolve at feed rates in excess of 200 M/m, and repeated use of household metal polishing products which erode precious metals such as silver or gold along with details such as engraved names and, in the case of plated objects, erosion of the precious metal film through to the base metal, sometimes to the point of destroying the object's structural integrity.
Concerning the ability of surfaces to resist microbial infestation as in food processing and hospital machining, while granular cutters appear to make surfaces cleaner because they make them lustrous, they may also open fissures beneath the surface which can harbor dangerous microbes.
Surface Modification by BurnishingThe term “burnishing”, despite its roots in antiquity, is used differently in various references. According to my present invention, “burnishing” refers to smoothing of a surface by moving molecules from higher points to lower points by pressing a smooth-surfaced tool against the surface with high local pressures while moving the tool with respect to the surface.
Burnishing in the Prior ArtSingle tool burnishing has been mechanized with CAD-CAM and robotic processing with a single tool burnisher, an expensive, highly technical process suited to high production work, and high cost-low volume work such as scientific experimentation and military projects. See METHOD OF BURNISHING METAL PARTS U.S. Pat. No. 5,329,684.
Yet another burnishing process is by tumbling, by which small, hard smooth spheroids or other shapes incorporated into a slurry are disposed in a rotating barrel. Tumbling is limited because of barrel size constraints, and the fact that the workpiece's entire surface is indiscriminately burnished, which may not be the desired goal, for which costly engineering design of the workpiece must compensate, and because the process allows little worker control.
Pads for polishing wax and acrylic resins applied to floors, shoes and other objects are made of cotton, wool, polyester, horsehair and the like, which are harder than the waxes and resins which they burnish. See_CLEANING AND BUFFING PRODUCT U.S. Pat. No. 3,537,121. These pads, in context, are specifically for soft resin covered surfaces as described above, while the tools of my new invention apply to a wide variety of materials including metals.
In other non-woven cleaning pads, where abrasives are not included in the product, the cleaning process is by the removal of soft material from a surface of material harder than the pad, not by burnishing. From EP 0397374 B1 LOW DENSITY NONWOVEN FIBROUS SURFACE TREATING ARTICLE:
-
- The suitability of the article for a particular application is mainly determined by the abrasive character of the article. Articles intended to be more abrasive will generally have larger, harder, and/or a greater quantity of abrasive particles adhered to the fibers. Articles intended to be used for polishing and cleaning surfaces typically will have smaller, softer, and/or fewer abrasive particles adhered to the fibers, and in some cases may have no abrasive material at all.
Brushes for polishing wax and acrylic resins applied to floors, shoes and similar objects deform by each sharp fiber of the brush in which filaments are purposely at right angles to the workpiece surface, create a sharp groove in the workpiece surface. Made of natural or synthetic materials which are harder than the waxes and acrylics used for surface enhancement of wood, leather and similar materials. See POLISHING BUFF U.S. Pat. No. 4,149,294 (bold emphasis mine):
-
- “A buffing pad wherein a layer of fabric has tufting material stitched therein and extending outwardly from one side thereof”
Yet another example of the action by brushes are the bristles of wire brushes.
-
- “Grooves are cut in the thick edge of the wheel with a carbide-tipped tool and it is in these grooves that the actual grinding operation is done. The abrasive action is due to a combination of the glass and high speed.”
In tools of my present invention, the sharp fiberglass ends do not touch the work surface, the work being accomplished by the smoothness and hardness of the glass fibers sides.
Uses of Microspheres for Surface Improvement in the Prior ArtAnother example in the prior art which refers to smooth tools is SHAPING METALS EP 0642398 B1, which limits the context of the patent specifically to the use of an ‘anti-lubricant,’ and the use of such tools at high velocity—an entirely different concept than that of my present invention (emphasis mine):
-
- The rubbing action of a wire brush will be concentrated at many small contact points, such as a point on a bent wire surface or at the tip of a wire. This will tend to leave a heavily lined/grooved surface. However, if a small sphere is attached to the tip of each wire, as shown in
FIG. 5 , then the resulting surface finish is very smooth. If a number of spheres (29) made of suitably hard material are joined to a central hub (30) via flexible wires (301) and the whole assembly is then spun at high velocity, like a wheel, then the arrangement can be used effectively as a grinding wheel to machine hard surfaces (31)—especially in the presence of an anti-lubricant in accordance with the method of the invention.
- The rubbing action of a wire brush will be concentrated at many small contact points, such as a point on a bent wire surface or at the tip of a wire. This will tend to leave a heavily lined/grooved surface. However, if a small sphere is attached to the tip of each wire, as shown in
Therefore, a need exists for a method to improve surface finishes that is safer, simpler, cleaner and more economical than the processes now in use. Abrasive finishing is complex, dirty, and expensive, and requires that the workpiece be designed to include material to be removed in the finishing process.
In SHOT PEENING, U.S. Pat. No. 3,638,464 to Winter et al., and SPHEROIDAL PEENING PARTICLES ADHESIVELY BONDED TO A WOVEN CLOTH, U.S. Pat. No. 3,778,241 to Winter et al., a “flap wheel” comprising a number of flaps of fabric embedded with hard spheroids is shown. When the wheel is rotated at high speed so that the flaps impact a workpiece, the spheroids act as tiny peening hammers. Burnishing is not mentioned.
Adhesion in the Prior ArtAdhesion between a tool and a workpiece is generally regarded as negative. Galling is one such condition. This new invention's tools use adhesion as an advantage by controlling the rate and manner of surface material removal by adhesion.
Definitions Related to the Invention IntroductionAbrasive treatments involve removal of material, while treating a surface with smooth tools modifies a surface by either deforming material from high spots to lower spots on the surface, or removing material by adhesion. However, since the results of these processes often appear similar, the literature is ambiguous. Burnishing, which is an aspect of the present art, is commonly ambiguous, as is evident in BURNISHING TAPE FOR MAGNETIC DISKS U.S. Pat. No. 5,018,311; the method involves “dispersing abrasive grains and a binder to prepare a slurry.”; In METHOD OF SMOOTHING A CONTAINER U.S. Pat. No. 7,921,529, the inventor supplies his own definition of burnishing, which instead describes a silversmithing process correctly known as planishing. Yet another use of the term, ‘burnish,’ describes attaching decals to a surface, for instance in applying stick-ons to boats. These tools are spatulas or rollers that one pushes against the stick-on to attach it to the boat hull. There is no plastic deformation occurring. See, e,g, application IN-MOLD LABELS U.S. Ser. No. 12/802,625, which uses the term thus: “0040 . . . The use of a burnishing tool (such as a rubber roller) helps to ensure that the label is applied smoothly.”
Yet another use of the term ‘burnishing,’ is more correctly described as drawing or rolling; from MEDICAL LEADS WITH SEGMENTED ELECTRODES AND METHODS OF FABRICATION THEREOF US 20100269338A1:
-
- “ . . .
FIG. 3B is a cross-section of a twisted wire . . . .FIG. 3C is a cross-section of the twisted wire ofFIG. 3B after burnishing . . . the exterior surface of each wire may be accomplished by burnishing the wire.”
- “ . . .
As can be seen from review of these figures, outer circular wire strands of a cable having a central strand are reformed so as to more closely conform to the central wire and display a circular outer sectional shape. This is not burnishing as used herein.
Certain floor and automobile paint and wax buffing steps, which use wool bonnets, fiber pads, and/or brushes to develop a high finish, are sometimes referred to as ‘burnishing.’ These processes operate by the application of additives which employ fine abrasive particles, and use additives such as liquid polymers or waxes, that fill surface flaws. Furthermore, the tools drag the soft material along a surface rather than compressing in into the surface.
Abrasion and AdhesionAs with abrasion and deformation, abrasion and adherence may produce similar finishes, as is evident is
Finding the common definitions inadequate to describe my present invention, the definitions below combine the common definitions, in italics, with my own comments.
Definitions BurnishAs used herein, to “burnish” means to deform a surface by plastic deformation with a smooth-surfaced tool of a material harder than the workpiece, the dimension of the tool being larger than the distance between adjacent high points on a surface, so that the material of the surface is moved from high points to lower points, thereby smoothing the surface without cutting or scraping it away. In the process, surface tensile stresses remaining after initial fabrication of the workpiece may be replaced with compressive forces, which is generally beneficial to parts that are repetitively stressed in service.
This definition is consonant with that from Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary: To cause to shine; to make smooth and bright; to polish; specifically, to polish by rubbing with something hard and smooth.
An excellent general description of burnishing, consonant with that used herein, is found in METHOD OF BURNISHING METAL PARTS U.S. Pat. No. 5,329,684, which teaches a single tool burnisher.
-
- It should be recalled that burnishing is a technique that performs surface plastic deformation by pressing a rotary or sliding tool against the surface of a part. As it moves, the tool compresses the microscopic peaks in the surfaces concerned into the adjacent hollows, thereby enabling said surfaces to be densified.
- Burnishing thus serves simultaneously to smooth surfaces and to put such surfaces into compression. The resulting mechanical forces, both on the surface and down to a certain depth, enable the lifetime of materials and structures that are subjected to cyclic changes (fatigue) or to contact corrosion to be considerably increased. This technique appears to be even more effective than shot blasting for obtaining surface compression stress, and it very considerably increases fatigue life, resistance to corrosion under tension, and resistance to the effect of corrosion due to rubbing. (col. 1, lines 14-32)
As smooth tool 703 is urged against and moved along the surface, the force exerted by the tool 703 on the asperities 702, as indicated by arrows 707, causes the asperities 702 to be pressed into the work surface by plastic deformation; forces indicated by arrows 708 are transferred into the workpiece as indicated at 709, resulting in the smoothed area after work as shown at 710. It is important to understand that materials which flow, such as ductile metals, allow the material of the asperities to flow into the workpiece mass, so that the material of the asperities or high spots flows into the adjoining low spots, effectively smoothing the surface.
Thus, one aspect of the invention comprises a method of smoothing the surface of a given object exhibiting asperities by plastic deformation, the method first comprising the step of making a tool by affixing a plurality of smooth-surfaced members of a material harder than the material of the surface of the object to a substrate, and then urging the smooth-surfaced members against the asperities on that surface with substantial local pressure, and simultaneously moving the tool with respect to the surface, so that the asperities are reduced, and the surface is smoothed, by plastic deformation. At the same time, the surface may be compressed to a degree by force exerted on the atoms of the surface by the smooth-surfaced members.
BurnisherFrom Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary: ‘Burnisher: A tool with a hard, smooth, rounded end or surface, as of steel, ivory, or agate, used in smoothing or polishing by rubbing.’ For the purposes of my present invention, the material of which a burnishing tool is made need only be harder and smoother than the workpiece, e.g., soft wood can be burnished with a burnisher made of harder wood.
Burnishing CompoundAn embodiment of my present invention similar to abrasive polishing compound, but with the grease binder combined with burnishing elements in the place of abrasives. During use, high local pressure is effected as the workpiece is pressed against a buff, which may vary considerably in hardness.
Composite ToolsTools of my present invention in which the functions and/or structures of the binder and ground are served by a single material such as in the Composite Wheel of
Yet another principle of the present invention involves material removal by adhesion between smooth elements and a workpiece, by urging the tool against the workpiece at a combination of pressure and speed sufficient to drag material from the surface in a predictable, orderly manner as in
The action described here above is a function of the amount of friction between the workpiece and the tool in
Significantly, the function of friction in the new tools determines the new tools' two abilities; plastic deformation and controlled adhesion. Extremely low friction results in the tool gliding across a workpiece with the force 704 predominant, resulting in maximum deformation with minimal removal of material by adhesion. Conversely, extremely high friction results in asperities being mostly dragged from a surface by adhesion, with minimal deformation by the forward movement of the tool 705. Thus, by controlling for the level of friction between the tool and the work, the amount of deformation and adhesion is controlled.
Fiber/FabricAny contiguous thread-like material, grouping of thread-like materials such as woven fabric or metal screening. In comparison, a grain or spheroid would be discontiguous.
Examples of fibers and fabrics useful in connection with present invention include the following:
Yet another type of fiber by my definition is ERG Duocel® foam, an example of open cell foams.
A variation of this type of fiber is the non-woven 3M abrasive pad made of fibers combined with abrasive grains. The same fiber pad, when embedded with media of my present invention could operate as a burnishing tool.
From the ‘3M Roto Peen Catalog,’ flap peening is described as “For small and/or hard-to-reach surfaces, the captive shot method is more convenient and effective. The shot is integrated into a rotating brush or flap. The spinning brush or flap is held near the surface so that the captive shot strikes the metal surface with each revolution.”
For the purposes of my present invention, grinding means the cutting away of material from a surface by relatively coarse abrasive grains adhered to one another, compared to ‘polishing’ which is the cutting away of material from a surface, with relatively fine grains.
Ground(noun, as distinct from the past participle of the verb, ‘grind.’) From: thefreedictionary.com/ground: ‘10. (Art Terms): b. the support of a painting.’ For the purpose of my invention, the ground is the material to which the multiple smooth elements are attached by a bonding medium. Grounds for media of the new tools include grounds of various rigidities common in the prior art now used for abrasive grains, examples being; papers, meshes, woven and non-woven fabrics, resin impregnated fabrics, felts, polymer films and foams, polishing cloths and plated rigid planes of various materials.
PolishSince the definition of ‘friction’ and ‘burnish’ are themselves confusing, I shall only use the word ‘polish’ in prior art references to fine abrasive stock removal.
ScratchFrom: oxforddictionaries.com: Score or mark the surface of (something) with a sharp or pointed object. For the purposes of my present invention, scratching is a type of surface deformation whereby material is removed by cutting, abrasion being cutting by many small, sharp gouges.
An example of the ambiguity between the terms, ‘polish,’ and ‘scratch,’ is this excerpt from the definition of ‘polish’:
-
- From Google Books: Chemical & Metallurgical Engineering, A Weekly Technical Newspaper, Being the Incorporation of Electrochemical and Metallurgical Industry and Iron and Steel Magazine Volume IV, Jan. 1 to Jun. 30, 1921 NEW YORK McGRAW-HILL COMPANY, INC.:
- Polishing . . . It is the cutting action of the wire ends that cleans, not the rubbing with the sides of the bristles.
- From Google Books: Chemical & Metallurgical Engineering, A Weekly Technical Newspaper, Being the Incorporation of Electrochemical and Metallurgical Industry and Iron and Steel Magazine Volume IV, Jan. 1 to Jun. 30, 1921 NEW YORK McGRAW-HILL COMPANY, INC.:
The Present Invention introduces novel methods and tools for surface treatment of metals and other flowable materials with smooth fibers and spheroids bonded to a ground. Rather than removing material as done by abrasives, the new tools deform and compress material, resulting in increased surface hardness, density, reflectivity, electrical conductivity, impermeability and corrosion resistance. Since the new tools produce negligible waste and can operate at dramatically slower speeds, I foresee that the workplace environment will be quieter, cleaner, brighter and safer, and that other benefits will include economies in production and maintenance, as well as reduced costs for energy, stock, and precious metal reclamation.
The media of the invention can be of any smooth material harder than the material of the surface of the intended workpiece. Fiberglass, glass beads, carbon fiber, ceramics, steel, and carbide are among the most universally effective media.
Many of the tool forms of the present invention are similar to those produced in the prior art employing abrasives, such as films, belts, discs, cylinders, wheels, flap wheels and brushes; polishing, cutting and grinding compounds; non-woven pads such as 3M pads; 3M Microfinishing Films and Micron Sheets; Micromesh™ foam-backed cloth; metal wools, and others.
In contrast with abrasives, which depend on erosion by fragmentation of the tools' abrasive grains to expose new sharp edges to the workpiece, tools of the present invention do not erode, thereby retaining their original forms, allowing the new tools to be customized with specific shapes for specific operations.
In assembly lines, I foresee that the cleanliness and flexibility of the new tools will allow finishing and detailing to occur in the line rather than in separate costly facilities expressly created for the abatement of danger, dirt and noise, and that surface improvement usually done away from the production line by noisy, dirty shot peening, or inadequately done by roto peening, is now possible in the line of production with one clean operation.
During the production of my prototypes I observed that, due to the smoothness surface of the media, lathe tools, saws and knives did not become dulled while shaping the prototypes, leading me to conclude that manufacture of the new tools uses less energy and extends the life of production machinery.
The basic principle of my novel method of finishing surfaces is the use of tools comprised of smooth elements bonded to a ground urged against and moved along a workpiece surface to smooth asperities in the surface by plastic deformation. The structure of the tools and mechanisms employed to move the tool with respect to the surface of the workpiece are generally similar to abrasive papers, belts, discs and wheels of the prior art. However, the new tools produce surfaces that are not achievable with those tools of the prior art.
The functions of the invention's three elements—smooth media, binder and ground—can be performed by separate materials, or materials that are able to serve two or all three of the functions. One example of material serving multiple functions is fiberglass cloth, which can act as both a smooth medium and ground.
A variety of finishes are achieved by varying the tools' speed and pressure. The new finishes can replace current finishes achieved in the prior art by abrasives, and also contribute a series of new, previously unachievable, finishes. While the tool forms which follow are comprised with one type of smooth media, the forms are manufacturable with a variety of smooth media made of any material harder than the intended workpiece, and attached to the ground in any useful manner.
To recall, the present invention's basic principle is graphically described in
As smooth tool 703 is urged against and moved along the surface, the force exerted by the tool 703 on the asperities 702, as indicated by arrows 707, causes the asperities 702 to be pressed into the work surface by plastic deformation. Forces indicated by arrows 708 are transferred into the workpiece as indicated at 709, resulting in the smoothed area after work as shown at 710. It is important to understand that materials which flow, such as ductile metals, allow the material of the asperities to flow into the workpiece mass, so that the material of the asperities or high spots flows into the adjoining low spots, effectively smoothing the surface.
Significantly, the friction between the workpiece and the tool 703 at the interface 706 is intentionally minimized compared to abrasives, for which friction at the interface is intentionally maximized. According to design, lubricants may or may not be used to control friction at the interface 706.
Thus, the invention comprises a method of smoothing a surface of a given object exhibiting asperities by plastic deformation, the method first comprising the step of making a tool by affixing a plurality of smooth-surfaced members of a material harder than the material of the surface of the intended work object to a substrate, and then urging the smooth-surfaced members against the asperities on that surface with substantial local pressure, and simultaneously moving the tool with respect to the surface, so that the asperities are reduced, and the surface is smoothed, by plastic deformation. At the same time, the surface may be compressed to a degree by force exerted on the atoms of the surface by the smooth-surfaced members.
Surfaces worked with tools of my present invention are improved similarly to surfaces created by peening in the prior art, e.g., the replacement of tensile stress in metal with compressive forces. However, since my new tools operate by moving along a surface under high local pressure rather the textured surface generated by roto-peening shown in
In
Regarding fluid flow, the surface texture created by flap peening creates resistance, while burnishing produces a surface with improved fluid flow, contributing to the maintenance of oil and gas wells, high pressure steam and gas turbines, nuclear reactors and other systems where optimal fluid flow is critical. As an example, the following article in the EJoumal of Advanced Maintenance site; jsm.or.jp/ejam/Vol.2.No.2/GA/13/article, which is concerned with the most advanced reactor maintenance processes, now addresses PWSCC (Primary Water Stress Corrosion Cracking) with existing peening technologies. My Present Invention is a substantial contribution to their processing options.
The effectiveness of my new invention in improving fluid flow is shown in the following two images:
Tools of my present invention close fissures in surfaces, making them more impervious to organic foreign matter ripe for contamination by microorganisms in, for example, food and hospital machinery.
Currently, the recommended procedure for finishing in the medical and food industries is the #4 Dairy or Sanitary Finish:
From ofrmetals.com:
-
- ‘Great care should be taken in removing the surface defects in the metal, like pits, that could allow bacteria to grow. #4 Dairy or Sanitary Finish, which is commonly used for the medical and food industry and almost exclusively used on stainless steel. This finish demands great care in removing surface defects like pits, that could allow bacterial growth.’ and, ‘a #4 Dairy or Sanitary Finish is produced by polishing with a 180-240 grit belt or wheel finish softened with 120-240 grit greaseless compound or a fine non-woven abrasive belt or pad.’
Despite the above recommendation, it is my opinion that the traditional abrasives described above do not seal pits that harbor microorganisms. While cutting away the surface material may remove shallow pits, the material removal also may expose fissures that lurk deeper in the metal body, exacerbating the opportunity for infestation.
Burnishing for Pipes and TubesMy Present Invention improves the production of pipes by burnishing and compressing their inner surfaces rather than, as happens during abrasive polishing, removing the surface material and therefore exposing subsurface pores. Burnishing also improves the quality of the welds used to join pipe sections by reducing stress in the weld zone. During maintenance, burnishing cleans and smooths a pipe in the same action while simultaneously reducing porosity, thereby retarding corrosion and microbial infestation, thereby extending the effective maintenance interval. Peening, which also reduces surface pores, creates a rough, flow-resistant surface, while burnishing reduces surface pores while creating a smooth surface with improved flow qualities.
-
- ‘The 316Ti stainless steel tube cracked by transgranular stress corrosion cracking due to the presence of sulfur and chlorine in a moist environment at elevated temperatures.’
It is my opinion that manufacturing and maintaining the pipes in
Porosity in metal castings is an inherent vice. Standard abrasive grinding and polishing creates a finish that erroneously implies that pores have been reduced or eliminated. To the contrary, sub-surface voids are actually opened, exposing the cast's interior to invasion by chemical or organic elements. In contrast, treatment withs the new tooling according to the invention creates an improved surface while reducing or closing the pores, isolating the casting's interior voids from the outside environment.
I first created the new tools to treat plated objects. As compared to abrasive polishing, the new tools remove either no, or dramatically less, material, leading to substantial reduction in the needed thickness of deposited metal plate, substantially less processing time and more efficient use of equipment, while the produced plated parts benefit from improved surface density and reduced porosity. The following Figures explain this more fully.
While hard, brittle oxides are removed with the new tools by adhesion, non-adherent, softer oxides such as rust are also removed. However, the oxide molecules adhering to the iron substrate remain, resulting in a more passive surface on the treated workpiece with reduced tendency toward further oxidation.
Filaments of glass, carbon fiber and other smooth materials operate as media for the new tools. Fibers assembled as woven, non-woven and knitted fabrics, or made individually into spirals such as springs, present multiple burnishers to a surface in the form of many smooth high points. Such fibers modify the work surface according to the radius of each fiber at the point of intersection with the work and the resultant pressure at the point of contact. In contrast to these smooth fibers are steel wool fibers, which are scrapers.
The attack angle of smooth sided fiber tooling according to the invention relative to a workpiece creates a continuum of useful qualities, from moderate burnishing with the fibers moving parallel to the work, to maximum burnishing with the fibers moving at 90° to the work. The effect of smooth sided fiber tooling depends on the pressure of the tool on the work, the weave, knit, or non-woven configuration of the fabric, the fabric's fiber density and the quantity and type of lubrication, if any, between the fiber tool and the work.
In addition to the use of smooth fibers as burnishing media, surface improvement is achieved by the use of smooth surfaced particles of any material harder than the intended workpiece, examples being spheroids of glass, zirconium, ceramic, steel, plated steel and polymers such as polypropylene, and attached by any adhesive means such as used in the prior art to affix adhesive particles to a ground such as paper, woven or non-woven fibers, polymer films and foams.
In addition to the embodiments described above, the following describe tools and prototypes which, although made with a particular medium of the present invention, may be used with any applicable medium of the present invention.
Burnishing media may also be secured to a metallic ground by brazing, similarly to the process described in HIGH-INTENSITY ROTARY PEENING PARTICLE SUPPORT AND METHOD OF MAKING SAME U.S. Pat. No. 5,179,852 A.
Yet another tool of the prior art, the Blitz Silver Polishing Cloth-93118WEB, is comprised of a cloth embedded with abrasives. By replacing the abrasives with smooth media, burnishing is achieved without erosion of the workpieces' surfaces as occurs with the abrasive-embedded cloths. As a result, precious metals are not removed, engraving details are not degraded, and plated films are not eroded by repeated polishings to the point of complete removal of the plated layer and subsequent exposure of the metal substrate. Such cloths may be made of fiberglass of other smooth fabric. Cloths of my present invention may also be infused with thiourea or other chemical tarnish removers.
Replaceable shells with surfaces comprised of smooth media are pressed or otherwise formed into compound curves to conform to standard supports.
Burrs with Smooth Media
U.S. Pat. No. 6,685,547 B2 PNEUMATIC SANDING ROLL FOR FLEXIBLE ABRASIVE CLOTH SLEEVE refers to an abrasive configured to be attached to a pneumatic burr. Tool forms which are developments of replaceable media can also be comprised of smooth media rather than abrasive grains, thereby providing further tool flexibility. Generally, although tools of the new invention media are non-eroding, attachment systems used in the prior art to replace exhausted abrasives are useable with the new tools, such systems being PSA adhesives, mechanical center connectors and other common attachment systems.
Because the new tools often work at low RPM's, these and other burr shapes can be fabricated as desired of a wide range of materials such as plastic foams, tubing, and other material not required to operate under the stresses of high speed tools.
Contoured Disks and Wheels with the New Tools
Consequent to the non-erosive nature of the new tools, tools utilizing my new invention maintain their original forms which remain intact for the life of the tool.
Contoured disks of the present art are improvements based on prior art produced by Alpha Professional Tools of Oakland, N.J.: alpha-tools.com, wherein media of the new tools replace attachable abrasive disks, and a wide variety of profiles and hardnesses not previously produced are possible due in part to the slower speeds required.
Reversible Contoured EVA Disk with Recessed Center
Sewn Buff with Applied Spheroidal Media
A sewn muslin or other fibrous buff of the prior art is impregnated at the working surface with binder, for example acrylic emulsion or epoxy, to which is applied spheroidal media, the tool operating flexibly in the manner of a muslin buff of the prior art to which polishing compound has been applied. In an improvement to the standard compound impregnated muslin buff which are typically used at 3450 RPM, the new tools are effective at roughly 100 RPM and upward, according to application.
Sewn Buff Comprised of Lamina Impregnated with Spheroidal Media
A sewn buff is comprised of laminated sheets of spheroidal media. As in the prior art, the buffs's hardness at the working margin is dependent upon the flexibility of the individual lamina and the stitch frequency.
Spirally Wound BuffWheel with a Metal Mesh Face
Embodiments of planarization devices are made by replacing the abrasives in appropriate stages of the planarization process of the prior art withs tools of the new invention resulting in reduced machine speeds, reduced material waste, improved electrical connectivity and prolonged tool life. An example of such a system in the prior art is POLISH METHOD FOR SEMICONDUCTOR DEVICE PLANARIZATION U.S. Pat. No. 7,172,970 B2, which teaches “that the HSP-CMP process with the fix abrasive polishing pad can be performed to provide a planarized surface with accurate dimension control.”
Pipe ConditionersThe pressure forcing both the burnishing and stabilizer heads against the pipe walls is optionally operated mechanically, pneumatically, hydraulically or any combination thereof.
After the process is complete, the mechanism is removed by deflating the head bladders, and drawing the head and the flexible shaft through the pipe from either end of the pipe.
Composite ToolsSmooth media held in a solid matrix can be of any useful configuration now made with abrasives in the prior art, one example being sharpening stones, and composed of any useful media of the present invention held in matrices of resins or other suitable grounds.
Yet other embodiments adapted as grounds for the present art are tools having forms such as milling cutters, rotary files, drill bits and flexible linked tools such as chain saw blades. With burnishers at the multiple working tips, bound using similar technologies now used for attachment of carbide cutter tips, and generally operating at considerably slower speeds, these tools are, in my opinion, usable with smooth media instead of as cutters as the forms now are used in the prior art.
Composite Hand Held ToolsThe heads of hand held burnishing tools such as those in
The heads of machine mounted burnishing tools such as those produced by Lambda Technologies Group are produced more economically and with greater variability in their forms by replacing the burnisher ends with composites comprised of smooth media. Similarly, ROTARY BURNISHERS U.S. Pat. No. 3,872,594 shows the prior art of multi-headed dental burnishers made of solid materials such as tool steel. My present invention replaces these and similar tool heads with composites made of media with, for example, smooth spheroids in resin bonding material.
Tool for Honing of Razor and Other BladesSee prior art; RAZOR SHARPENING SYSTEM U.S. Pat. No. 8,801,501. Honing of razor blades both manually and mechanically, is done either with or without abrasives. The operation, machine production and cost of such tooling is improved by the honing elements being replaced by smooth media of the present invention.
Foams A New Foaming ProcessA simplified and less costly method for producing foams for the present invention is a direct consequence of the addition of smooth burnishing media to the foam mix. During production of a foam member impregnated with smooth media, the media, being smooth, is continually and uniformly distributed in the mix by the turbulence of the aqueous solvent boiling away in production of the foam. In an experiment, where heat was provided by microwave oven, a homogenous solidified foam product was produced in contrast to the clumping which occurs when manufacturing foams containing abrasives, due to the jagged abrasive grains locking to one another. In the prior art, this problem required the addition of blowing agents and metal fragments to the mix to break up the clumps of abrasive grains and disperse them uniformly in the foam product: From COMPOSITE RETICULATED FOAM-TEXTILE CLEANING PAD U.S. Pat. No. 4,581,287:
-
- . . . it contains, ‘(B) at least one blowing agent which releases gas on heating, and (C) at least one metal powder or metal compound, for example a metal oxide, individually, or a mixture thereof, which has microwave activity.
In contrast to brushes in the prior art which operate on the principle that sharp bristles scratch with their sharp ends, my present invention operates as burnishers and at a wide range of velocities, the lowest speeds being just above zero M/m.
The forms of brushes which may incorporate smooth media include among others; engine cylinder hones, and industrial hand and machine mounted rotary, spiral and straight brushes.
Solid Brush BristlesYet another method for making the new tools is with brush bristles. While brushes of the prior art use the sharpened ends of bristles to abrade materials, such as the common steel bristle brush, or sharp bristles that create fine striations in a surface, bristle ends which are rounded and smooth create tools of the present invention, which smooth a surface by plastic displacement rather than by abrasion or scratching as done with the prior art.
The prior art shown in
In contrast to the prior art are the following tools comprised of smooth media:
This vehicle uses flexible burnishing media in place of fine abrasives in metal polishing creams of the prior art such as Wright's, MAAS, Brasso, Blue Magic Goddard's Simichrome and the like. Additives such as thiourea and other tarnish removers and inhibitors remove surface oxides, allowing the media to operate on the unoxidized metal surface. An early patent for an abrasive cream is METAL-POLISHING COMPOUND U.S. Pat. No. 548,310 A which uses the abrasive qualities of coal ash and Cream of Tartar.
Spheroidal Vehicle in the Form of a SlurryThis embodiment combines smooth media with aqueous, resinous, or other liquid and cream carriers and dispersed onto platens, faceplates, brushes, polishing cloths, polishing pads, gloves and other tools for treatment of work surfaces such as microchip wafers and floors as well as for treatments by manual techniques. A major advantage being the reduced erosion and waste produced. Slurries in combination with applicable tools of my present invention differ by application from slurries used in tumbling barrels of the prior art, wherein burnishing is already a standard practice. The slurries are often combined with tarnish removal agents:
The new tools are also made of solid homogeneous material, for instance glass, disks, bars and other shapes are laminated into groups. The work surface of the lamina may be without a pattern or comprised of any useful pattern in any useful frequency, the individual elements of the pattern presenting themselves consecutively to the work through spinning, as with a wheel, or by hand work, as done in the prior art by files or sharpening stones.
FIG. 119shows a wheel lamina 11901 of a solid medium with a castellated surface laminated into a group 11902. 11903 shows a cross section of one type of castellation. Any suitable geometric and non-geometric configurations of multiple smooth faces are usable.
LimitationsClaims
1. A method of smoothing a surface of a given object by plastic deformation, said surface exhibiting asperities, comprising the steps of:
- making a burnishing tool by affixing a plurality of smooth-surfaced members of a material harder than the material of the surface of the object to a substrate;
- urging said smooth-surfaced members against the asperities in said surface with substantial local pressure, and simultaneously moving said tool with respect to said surface;
- whereby said asperities are reduced, and said surface is smoothed, by plastic deformation caused by force exerted on the molecules of said surface by said smooth-surfaced members.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein said smooth-surfaced members are affixed to said substrate by adhesive bonding.
3. The method of claim 1, wherein said smooth-surfaced members are spheroids.
4. The method of claim 3, wherein the material of said spheroids is selected from the group comprising metals, glass, carbides, and ceramics.
5. The method of claim 1, wherein said smooth-surfaced members are fibers.
6. The method of claim 5, wherein the materials of said fibers are selected from the group comprising metal, glass and carbon fibers.
7. The method of claim 5, wherein said fibers are provided in the form of woven cloth, nonwoven batts, wire, or screen.
8. The method of claim 1, wherein said substrate is provided in the form of a radially-symmetric member adapted to be rotated, such that said surface to be smoothed is pressed against said smooth-surfaced members on the surface of said rotating substrate.
9. The method of claim 1, wherein said substrate is selected from the group comprising papers, meshes, woven and non-woven fabrics, resin impregnated fabrics, felts, polymer films and foams, polishing cloths and plated rigid planes of various materials.
10. The method of claim 1, wherein said substrate is selected from the group comprising films, belts, discs, cylinders, wheels, flap wheels and brushes; non-woven pads; foam-backed cloth; and metal wools.
11. The method of claim 1, wherein the pressure at which the smooth-surfaced members are urged against the surface to be treated increased to the point that material of the surface is removed by adhesion to the smooth-surfaced members.
Type: Application
Filed: Jan 26, 2017
Publication Date: Jul 26, 2018
Inventor: HOWARD NEWMAN (Newport, RI)
Application Number: 15/416,722