Lensed tapered optical waveguide
An optical coupling element for use in large numerical aperture collecting and condensing systems. The optical coupling element includes a curved surface such as a lens at the output of a tapered light pipe (TLP). The TLP in combination with the curved surface alters the divergence angle and the area of the light exiting the curved surface. Electromagnetic radiation emitted by a source is collected and focused onto a target by positioning the source of electromagnetic radiation substantially at a first focal point of a primary reflector so that the primary reflector produces rays of radiation reflected from the primary reflector that converge at a second focal point of the secondary reflector. The optical coupling element is positioned so that its input end is substantially proximate with the second focal point of the secondary reflector. The converging rays of radiation reflected from the secondary reflector pass through input end and are transmitted towards the curved surface, where their divergence angle and area are adjusted.
Latest Wavien, Inc. Patents:
This application is a divisional of U.S. application Ser. No. 10/155,234, filed May 28, 2002 now U.S. Pat. No. 6,829,412, which claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/293,181, filed May 25, 2001, and U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/294,590, filed Jun. 1, 2001 and U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/296,146, filed Jun. 7, 2001.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates to waveguides that collect and condense light from a light source, transforming the area and divergence angle of the light from their input to their output with minimum loss of brightness.
2. Description of the Related Art
The objective of systems that collect, condense, and couple electromagnetic radiation into a target such as a standard waveguide, e.g. a single fiber or fiber bundle, or output electromagnetic radiation to the input of a projection engine, is to maximize the brightness of the electromagnetic radiation at the target. There are several common systems for collecting and condensing light from a lamp for such illumination and projection applications.
One optical collection and condensing systems, U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/604,921 now U.S. Pat. No. 6,672,740, the disclosure of which is incorporated by reference, provides a dual-paraboloid reflector system. This optical collection and condensing system, as illustrated in FIG. 1(a), uses two generally symmetric paraboloid reflectors 10, 11 that are positioned so that light reflected from the first reflector 10 is received in a corresponding section of the second reflector 11. In particular, light emitted from a light source 12, such as an arc lamp, is collected by the first parabolic reflector 10 and collimated along the optical axis toward the second reflector 11. The second reflector 11 receives the collimated beam of light and focuses this light at the target 13 positioned at the focal point.
The optical system of FIG. 1(a) may employ a retro-reflector 14 in conjunction with the first paraboloid reflector 10 to capture radiation emitted by the light source 12 in a direction away from the first paraboloid reflector 10 and reflect the captured radiation back through the light source 12. In particular, the retro-reflector 14 has a generally spherical shape with a focus located substantially near the light source 12 (i.e., at the focal point of the first paraboloid reflector) toward the first paraboloid reflector to thereby increase the intensity of the collimated rays reflected therefrom.
In FIG. 1(a) is shown light paths for three different rays (a, b, and c) emitted from the light source 12 when viewed in a direction normal to the lamp axis. The light output from a lamp subtends an angle of about 90° around an axis normal to the lamp, as indicated by rays a and c in FIG. 1(a).
The light output from a lamp subtends a cone angle of nearly 180°, on the other hand, when viewed in a direction parallel to the lamp axis, as indicated by rays a′ and c′ in FIG. 1(b).
One shortcoming of the above described on-axis, dual-paraboloid optical system is that a large angle is produced between rays a and c, and rays a′ and c′, at a target. As a result, the rays strike the target 13 at a high angle of incidence relative to the target surface. Thus, the numerical aperture (NA) at the input of the target 13 may be very large, sometimes as high as 1.0, while the area upon which the light is focused is small. A large numerical aperture combined with a small area may be unsuitable for the optical components to which light from the system may be coupled. If a different, e.g. smaller, numerical aperture is desired, some means of transforming the area and divergence angle of the light with minimum loss of brightness may be incorporated into the device.
Representative means of transforming input areas and divergence angles of light are lenses and tapered optical waveguides, also known as tapered light pipes (TLP). While lenses provide an efficient means of transforming input areas and divergence angles of light, they require a certain amount of space in which to operate. Also, they are not well adapted to large numerical apertures. Consequently, tapered light pipes are often used instead of lenses. Tapered light pipes, however, must be relatively lengthy to transform light efficiently.
In U.S. application Ser. No. 09/669,841 now U.S. Pat. No. 6,634,759, the disclosure of which is incorporated by reference, a dual ellipsoidal reflector system is described as providing 1:1 magnification for small light source target. This optical collection and condensing system, as illustrated in
As may be seen in
Another embodiment of the dual-ellipsoid system may be seen in FIG. 3. This dual-ellipsoid system suffers from the same disadvantage as the above-mentioned dual-paraboloid and dual-ellipsoid systems in that a large angle is produced between ray a and ray c at the target. Here too, ray a and ray c strike the target at large angles of incidence, requiring further transformation of the input area and divergence angle of the light.
In practice, light with such a large NA may be transformed such that the NA is smaller and the area is larger following the brightness principle. The transformation may be performed with, e.g. a tapered light pipe.
A standard long tapered light pipe 40a with a flat input surface 41a for use with the above systems is shown in FIG. 4(a). A standard short tapered light pipe 40b with a flat input surface 41b for use with the above systems is shown in FIG. 4(b). Both the long and the short tapered light pipes may be used to transform light having a small area d1 and large numerical aperture NA1 at the input 41 to a larger area d2 and smaller numerical aperture NA2 at the output 42. If light 43 impinges the tapered light pipe 40 at large angles of incidence 44 as shown in
d1*NA1=d2*NA2 (1)
In actual implementation, optimizations need to be performed such that the optimized dimensions may deviate from the ideal configurations.
The output angles 45 are designed for a specific system by matching the tapered light pipe to an output device. In designing a tapered light pipe, three of the variables will often be known, and the fourth can be calculated. In one example, a tapered light pipe of length 75.0 mm was designed with d1=3.02 mm, NA1=0.7, and d2=9.0 mm. The output numerical aperture NA2 is thus predicted to be 0.23. Upon fabricating the tapered light pipe, however, the actual numerical aperture at the output was found to be 0.26, larger than the predicted 0.23. Such a large numerical aperture will result in a loss of coupling efficiency in subsequent optical elements. But if the input area is reduced to reduce the numerical aperture at the output, less light will be coupled into the tapered light pipe in the first place, reducing the overall collection efficiency of the system.
The reason the numerical aperture at the output is larger than predicted is due to an assumption underlying equation (1) to the effect that an ideal tapered light pipe is of infinite length. For a tapered light pipe of infinite length, the angle of taper would be zero. In actuality, however, the angle of taper must be some number larger than zero, since the tapered light pipe is of finite length, and so the actual numerical aperture differs from that predicted by the equation. As the tapered light pipe gets longer, the actual numerical aperture converges to the predicted numerical aperture. A longer tapered light pipe, however, may require more space.
Furthermore, when the output numerical aperture of a tapered light pipe such as those shown in
In
A numerical aperture (NA) of a system, such as the dual paraboloid system shown in FIG. 1(a) may, however, be rectangular as shown in
Therefore, there remains a need to provide an efficient means of transforming input area and divergence angle of light, in a relatively short space, such that the output is telecentric and has a circular or elliptical NA distribution that may be symmetric.
SUMMARYAn optical coupling element for use in large numerical aperture collecting and condensing systems. The optical coupling element includes a tapered light pipe with an input end and a lens on the output side. The input end may be octagonal. The optical coupling element may be placed at the input end of a fiber, fiber bundle, or projection engine. The tapered light pipe and the lens adjusts the area of the area of the light and its numerical aperture to suit the fiber, fiber bundle, or projection engine. The lens can also parallelize or collimate the light to produce a telecentric output.
In particular, a collecting and condensing system comprises a source of electromagnetic radiation, an optical coupling element to be illuminated with at least a portion of the electromagnetic radiation emitted by the source, the optical coupling element comprising a tapered light pipe with a curved surface at its output end, a reflector having a first and second focal points, the source being located proximate to the first focal point of the reflector to produce rays of radiation that reflect from the first focal point to the second focal point and converge substantially at the second focal point; and wherein the input end of the tapered light pipe may be located proximate to the second focal point of the reflector to collect the electromagnetic radiation.
Electromagnetic radiation emitted by the source of electromagnetic radiation may be collected and focused onto the input end of a tapered light pipe by positioning the source of electromagnetic radiation substantially at a first focal point of a reflector so that the source produces rays of radiation that are reflected from the reflector, converging substantially at a second focal point of the reflector. An optical coupling element including a tapered light pipe having a curved output surface may be positioned so that the input end of the tapered light pipe may be substantially proximate with the second focal point of the reflector, whereby the converging rays of radiation reflected from the reflector pass through the tapered light pipe and curved surface, such that the divergence angle and the area of the light may be adjusted to suit further elements such as fiber optics, waveguides, polarization beam splitters, or projection engines.
The above and other features and advantages of the present invention will be further understood from the following description of the preferred embodiments thereof, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
FIG. 1(a) shows a schematic diagram of a collecting and condensing system for use with an embodiment of the invention;
FIG. 1(b) shows a detail of the lamp and the first reflector of the embodiment shown in FIG. 1(a), viewed along the reflector axis;
FIGS. 4(a) and 4(b) shows schematic diagrams of conventional tapered light pipes;
In
Various cross-sections of output end 1015 are shown in FIG. 21. Output end 1015 may have, e.g. a rectangular cross-section as shown in
TLP 1004 has an input end 1007. Various cross-sections of input end 1007 are shown in FIG. 22. Input end 1007 may have, e.g. may have, e.g. a rectangular cross-section as shown in
In a first embodiment, as shown in
In a second embodiment, as shown in
Both of reflectors 1008a and 1008b may be, e.g. substantially ellipsoidal or paraboloidal surfaces of revolution. In the alternative, one of reflectors 1008a and 1008b may be e.g. a substantially ellipsoidal surface of revolution while the other may be a substantially hyperboloid surface of revolution.
In either of the abovementioned embodiments, optical coupling element 1002 may be placed so that input end 1007 may be substantially proximate to second focal point 1011 so that at least a portion of the electromagnetic radiation 1001 emitted by the source 1006 may be coupled into input end 1007.
Electromagnetic radiation 1001 may be transmitted by TLP 1004 to curved surface 1003, modifying the area and the divergence angle of the light along the length of TLP 1004. Curved surface 1003 then further adjusts the divergence angle of the light to more closely match the predicted values. Curved surface 1003 may also direct the beams of the light to have more uniform angular distribution from point to point, making the output substantially telecentric. In one embodiment, input end 1007 of the TLP 1004 can have an octagonal shape such that the output NA distribution is more circular, as shown in FIG. 25.
The taper transition of TLP 1004 can be straight or curved depending on the particular applications. The curved surface 1003 and TLP 1004 can be made in one piece, or made separately and assembled together. If the curved surface 1003 and TLP 1004 are separate pieces, the refractive indices between the curved surface 1003 and the TLP 1004 should be matched. TLP 1004 can be made with cladding or without. The output surface of TLP 1004 can also be curved for proper matching to specific lenses.
Reflector 1008 may be coated with a coating that reflects only a pre-specified portion of the electromagnetic radiation spectrum. For example, the coating may only reflect visible light radiation, a pre-specified band of radiation, or a specific color of radiation. Reflector 1008 may further be a portion of substantially ellipsoidal, toroidal, spheroidal, or paraboloidal surfaces of revolution.
In a fifteenth embodiment, shown in
Plane 2660 may be substantially parallel to second optical axis 2609b, as well, since first optical axis 2609a may substantially collinear to second optical axis 2609b. A corner 2662b of secondary reflector 2608b may be truncated along a plane 2660 substantially parallel to first optical axis 2609a. In this way an overall width of secondary reflector 2608b may be less than the diameter of the half circle formed by the output side of secondary reflector 2608b.
The loss of radiation due to the missing corners 2662a and 2662b is estimated to be on the order of 10% or 20%. Although primary and secondary reflectors 2608a and 2608b are shown having a gap between them for clarity, they may also be placed adjacent to one another. This allows primary and secondary reflectors 2608a and 2608b to be made in one piece by, e.g. glass molding.
In
Source 2706 may, e.g. be removably disposed in a fixture 2770 so that the source 2706 can be removed or replaced at the end of its useful life. The fixture may be, e.g. a fixture of the ‘3:2:1’ variety described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,598,497, the disclosure of which is included by reference.
A power supply 2772 for source 2706 may be disposed proximate source 2706, along with electronics 2774 and ballasts 2776 as appropriate.
In a third embodiment, also shown in
In one embodiment, source 1006 may be a light-emitting arc lamp. Source 1006 may be, e.g., a xenon lamp, a metal halide lamp, an HID lamp, or a mercury lamp. In an alternative embodiment, source 1006 may be a filament lamp.
In a fourth embodiment, also shown in
In a fifth embodiment, as shown in
In a sixth embodiment, as shown in
In a seventh embodiment, as shown in
In an eighth embodiment, as shown in
In an ninth embodiment, as shown in
In one embodiment, as shown in
In another embodiment, as shown in
In a further embodiment, as shown in
Second light pipe 1516 may be made of a material such as, e.g. quartz, glass, plastic, or acrylic. Second light pipe 1516 may be, e.g. an SLP or a TLP. Second light pipe 1516 may be, e.g. substantially hollow.
Input surface 1518 of second light pipe 1516 may have, e.g. a rectangular cross-section as shown in
Output surface 1520 may have, e.g. a rectangular cross-section as shown in
In a tenth embodiment, as shown in
First, second, and third bands of radiation 1624, 1626, 1628 might be, e.g. red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo, violet, pink, white, magenta, infrared, or ultra-violet radiation. In a preferred embodiment first, second, and third bands of radiation 1624, 1626, 1628 are red, green, and blue radiation, in no particular order.
As shown in
In an eleventh embodiment, as shown in
In a twelfth embodiment, as shown in
In an thirteenth embodiment, as shown in
A reflective polarizer 1966 might be used if, e.g. image projection system 1964 was of a type that required polarized light, such as, e.g. a liquid crystal on silicon (LCOS) imager. In this case, if image projection system 1964 were constructed and arranged to, e.g. utilize radiation of first polarization 1968, p-polarized radiation 1968 may be transmitted to image projection system 1964 while s-polarized radiation 1970, which may be unusable by image projection system 1964 directly, may be reflected substantially back towards the input.
S-polarized radiation 1970 will be returned through second focal point 1911 to reflector 1908, and ultimately to first focal point 1910. Some of s-polarized radiation 1970 may pass through first focal point 1910 and be reflected by retro-reflector 1912. There will be substantially no loss of etendue since the recovered s-polarized radiation 1970 follows a path through first focal point 1910 and thus appears to be emitted by source 1906.
The steps of a method for collecting electromagnetic radiation emitted by a source of electromagnetic radiation and focusing the collected radiation onto a target, according to a fourteenth embodiment of the invention, are as follows: position a source of electromagnetic radiation substantially at a first focal point of a primary reflector; produce rays of radiation by the source; reflect the rays of radiation by the primary reflector substantially towards a secondary reflector; substantially converge the rays of radiation at a second focal point of the secondary reflector; position a substantially TLP so that its input end (which may, e.g. have a cross-section that is rectangular, elliptical, or octagonal) may be substantially proximate to the second focal point of the secondary reflector; position a curved surface so that a center of the curved surface may be substantially proximate to the output end of the TLP; pass the rays of radiation reflected by the reflector through the substantially TLP of the optical coupling element and toward the curved surface; adjust the area or the divergence angle of the light as it passes through the substantially TLP of the optical coupling element and toward the curved surface.
While the invention has been described in detail above, the invention is not intended to be limited to the specific embodiments as described. In particular, the embodiments described above may also be applied to standard on-axis elliptical and parabolic reflectors. It is evident that those skilled in the art may now make numerous uses and modifications of and departures from the specific embodiments described herein without departing from the inventive concepts.
Claims
1. A TLP comprising;
- an input end;
- a substantially convex output end substantially transparently connected to said input end;
- said input end being illuminated with electromagnetic radiation;
- wherein a first NA of said radiation is transformed into a second NA by said TLP; and
- wherein said first NA is substantially unequal to said second NA.
2. The TLP of claim 1, comprising further a source of said electromagnetic radiation, said source comprising:
- a reflector having a first and a second focal points;
- said source being located proximate to said first focal point of said reflector to produce rays of radiation that reflect from said reflector to converge substantially at said second focal point; and
- wherein said input end of said TLP is located proximate to said second focal point of said secondary reflector.
3. The TLP of claim 2, wherein said reflector comprises a primary reflector having a first optical axis, and said first focal point is a focal point of said primary reflector, said reflector comprising further:
- a secondary reflector having a second optical axis placed substantially symmetrically to said primary reflector such that said first and second optical axes are substantially collinear, and wherein said second focal point is a focal point of said secondary reflector; and
- wherein said rays of radiation reflect from said primary reflector toward said secondary reflector and converge substantially at said second focal point.
4. The TLP of claim 3, wherein:
- said primary reflector comprises at least a portion of a substantially elliptical surface of revolution; and
- said secondary reflector comprises at least a portion of a substantially hyperbolic surface of revolution.
5. The TLP of claim 3, wherein:
- said primary reflector comprises at least a portion of a substantially hyperbolic surface of revolution; and
- said secondary reflector comprises at least a portion of a substantially elliptical surface of revolution.
6. The TLP of claim 3, wherein:
- a corner of said primary reflector is truncated along a plane substantially parallel to said first optical axis.
7. The TLP of claim 3, wherein:
- a corner of said secondary reflector is truncated along a plane substantially parallel to said second optical axis.
8. The TLP of claim 2, wherein said reflector has a coating that reflects only a pre-specified portion of the electromagnetic radiation spectrum.
9. The TLP of claim 8, wherein said source comprises a light-emitting arc lamp.
10. The TLP of claim 9, wherein said arc lamp comprises a lamp selected from the group comprising a xenon lamp, a metal halide lamp, an HID lamp, or a mercury lamp.
11. The TLP of claim 2, comprising further a retro-reflector disposed opposite said reflector to reflect at least a portion of the electromagnetic radiation that does not impinge directly on said reflector toward said reflector through the first focal point of said reflector to increase the flux intensity of the converging rays.
12. The TLP of claim 11, wherein said retro-reflector comprises a spherical retro-reflector disposed on a side of said source opposite said primary reflector to reflect electromagnetic radiation emitted from said source in a direction away from said primary reflector toward said primary reflector through the first focal point of said primary reflector.
13. The TLP of claim 2, wherein said coating only reflects visible light radiation, a pre-specified band of radiation, or a specific color of radiation.
14. The TLP of claim 2, wherein said source comprises a filament lamp.
15. A NA conversion device comprising:
- a polygonal input end;
- an output end substantially transparently connected to said polygonal input end;
- said polygonal input end being illuminated with electromagnetic radiation;
- wherein a first NA of said radiation is transformed into a second NA by said TLP; and
- wherein said first NA is substantially unequal to said second NA.
16. The NA conversion device of claim 15, comprising further a source of said electromagnetic radiation, said source comprising:
- a reflector having a first and a second focal points;
- said source being located proximate to said first focal point of said reflector to produce rays of radiation that reflect from said reflector to converge substantially at said second focal point; and
- wherein said input end of said TLP is located proximate to said second focal point of said secondary reflector.
17. The NA conversion device of claim 16, comprising further:
- a second light pipe having an input surface and an output surface, said input surface of said second light pipe disposed proximate to said output end of said TLP to collect and transmit substantially all of said radiation;
- a primary reflector disposed proximate to said output surface of said second light pipe, said primary reflector transmitting a first band of said radiation and reflecting a second and third bands of said radiation;
- a secondary reflector disposed proximate to said output surface of said second light pipe, said secondary reflector transmitting said second band of said radiation and reflecting said first and third bands of said radiation; and
- a third reflector disposed proximate to said output surface of said second light pipe, said third reflector transmitting said third band of said radiation and reflecting said first and second bands of said radiation.
18. The NA conversion device of claim 17, wherein said input surface is substantially larger than said output end.
19. The NA conversion device of claim 18, wherein said input surface is substantially twice as large as said output end.
20. The NA conversion device of claim 18, wherein said input surface comprises a first area coextensive with said output end;
- a second area not coextensive with said output end; and
- wherein said second area is coated with a reflective coating.
21. The NA conversion device of claim 18, wherein said input surface comprises a first area coextensive with said output end;
- a second area not coextensive with said output end; and
- wherein a wave-plate is disposed proximate to said second area;
- said wave-plate being coated with a reflective coating.
22. The NA conversion device of claim 17, comprising further:
- a reflective polarizer disposed proximate said output surface, said reflective polarizer collecting and polarizing substantially all of said radiation into a first polarization and a second polarization;
- wherein said radiation of said first polarization is transmitted; and
- radiation of said second polarization is reflected toward said output surface.
23. The light recovery apparatus of claim 22, wherein said reflective polarizer comprises a wire-grid polarizer.
24. The NA conversion device of claim 17, wherein:
- said output end has a first dimension and a second dimension, said second dimension being substantially orthogonal to said first dimension;
- said input surface has a third dimension and a fourth dimension, said third dimension being substantially orthogonal to said fourth dimension;
- said first dimension is substantially equal to said third dimension; and
- said fourth dimension is substantially twice said second dimension.
25. The NA conversion device of claim 17, wherein said output surface comprises a first, second, and third areas; and
- said primary reflector is a first reflective coating over said first area;
- said secondary reflector is a second reflective coating over said second area; and
- said third reflector is a third reflective coating over said third area.
26. The NA conversion device of claim 17, comprising further a color wheel rotatably mounted on a shaft and having a surface comprising a first, second, and third areas disposed spirally about said shaft; and
- wherein all of said input surface is substantially transmissive;
- said primary reflector is a first reflective coating over said first area;
- said secondary reflector is a second reflective coating over said second area; and
- said third reflector is a third reflective coating over said third area.
27. The NA conversion device of claim 17, wherein said second light pipe is selected from the group consisting of:
- an SLP, and
- a TLP.
28. The NA conversion device of claim 17, wherein said second light pipe is substantially hollow.
29. The NA conversion device of claim 17, wherein a substantially anti-reflective coating is disposed on said input surface.
30. The NA conversion device of claim 17, wherein a substantially anti-reflective coating is disposed on said output surface.
31. The NA conversion device of claim 17, wherein said output surface is substantially convex.
32. The NA conversion device of claim 16, wherein said reflector comprises a primary reflector having a first optical axis, and said first focal point is a focal point of said primary reflector, said reflector comprising further:
- a secondary reflector having a second optical axis placed substantially symmetrically to said primary reflector such that said first and second optical axes are substantially collinear, and wherein said second focal point is a focal point of said secondary reflector; and
- wherein said rays of radiation reflect from said primary reflector toward said secondary reflector and converge substantially at said second focal point.
33. The NA conversion device of claim 32, wherein:
- said primary reflector comprises at least a portion of a substantially elliptical surface of revolution; and
- said secondary reflector comprises at least a portion of a substantially hyperbolic surface of revolution.
34. The NA conversion device of claim 32, wherein:
- said primary reflector comprises at least a portion of a substantially hyperbolic surface of revolution; and
- said secondary reflector comprises at least a portion of a substantially elliptical surface of revolution.
35. The conversion device of claim 32, wherein:
- a corner of said primary reflector is truncated along a plane substantially parallel to said first optical axis.
36. The conversion device of claim 32, wherein:
- a corner of said secondary reflector is truncated along a plane substantially parallel to said second optical axis.
37. The NA conversion device of claim 16, comprising further a retro-reflector disposed opposite said reflector to reflect at least a portion of the electromagnetic radiation that does not impinge directly on said reflector toward said reflector through the first focal point of said reflector to increase the flux intensity of the converging rays.
38. The NA conversion device of claim 37, wherein said retro-reflector comprises a spherical retro-reflector disposed on a side of said source opposite said primary reflector to reflect electromagnetic radiation emitted from said source in a direction away from said primary reflector toward said primary reflector through the first focal point of said primary reflector.
39. The NA conversion device of claim 16, wherein said reflector has a coating that reflects only a pre-specified portion of the electromagnetic radiation spectrum.
40. The NA conversion device of claim 16, wherein said coating only reflects visible light radiation, a pre-specified band of radiation, or a specific color of radiation.
41. The NA conversion device of claim 15, wherein said output end is flat.
42. The NA conversion device of claim 15, wherein said output end is convex.
Type: Grant
Filed: Sep 28, 2004
Date of Patent: May 24, 2005
Patent Publication Number: 20050047723
Assignee: Wavien, Inc. (Santa Clarita, CA)
Inventor: Kenneth K. Li (Arcadia, CA)
Primary Examiner: Phan T. H. Palmer
Attorney: Fulbright & Jaworski LLP
Application Number: 10/950,629