Self-calibrating large baseline interferometer formed from two aircraft
A method to passively locate an emitter using two aircraft to form a large baseline interferometer. The basic two element (two aircraft or helicopters) large baseline interferometer includes self-calibration and allows for various configurations for geo-location of ground-based emitters. The two aircraft large baseline interferometer can measure phase difference of arrival (PDOA) to very precisely locate the emitter in angle. Moving emitters can also be located and tracked using the method of the invention with greater accuracy than can be achieved from a single platform.
Latest The United States of America as represented by the Secretary of the Air Force Patents:
- Method and system for repairing turbine airfoils
- Intelligence surveillance and reconnissance apparatus
- Microfluidic process for the general electrochemical synthesis of geminal dipseudohalide or halide-pseudohalide compounds
- Automated camera search system
- Multi-junction resistance strain gauge design for enhanced gauge factor
The invention described herein may be manufactured and used by or for the Government of the United States for all governmental purposes without the payment of any royalty.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED PATENTSThe present document is somewhat related to my issued U.S. Patents “SELF-CALIBRATING LARGE BASELINE INTERFEROMETER FOR VERY PRECISE EMITTER LOCATION USING TIME DIFFERENCE OF ARRIVAL” and “TIME DIFFERENCE OF ARRIVAL RATE”, U.S. Pat. No. 6,255,992, issued Jul. 3, 2001; and “MOVING EMITTER PASSIVE LOCATION FROM MOVING PLATFORM”, U.S. Pat. No. 6,577,272, issued Jun. 10, 2003, and both commonly assigned to The United States of America as represented by the Secretary of the Air Force. The contents of these, my somewhat related issued patents, are hereby incorporated by reference.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTIONThis invention relates to the field of remote energy-emitting source location through passive received signal processing.
Although radio locating has been used since the early days of radio, current military apparatus with its limited output signal durations and the availability of computerized signal processing, faster analog to digital conversion apparatus and a need to accomplish rapid, accurate signal locations from a moving vehicle provide opportunity for improvement in this art.
Current state of the art for passive geo-location of a ground based emitter using two aircraft requires each aircraft to independently measure time of arrival (TOA) of the radio frequency (RF) signal, exchange the information, so that one or both can then calculate time difference of arrival (TDOA). This will require atomic clocks on both aircraft, or some other method of determining the precise time at each aircraft. The accuracy of this open loop approach is also limited by the sample times of a sampling clock and the linearity of the pulse leading edge. The open loop method is also limited by the differences in the path lengths from the antenna to the measurement receiver. A more precise method of determining TDOA is a differential approach where TDOA is obtained by iteratively adjusting an analog variable delay line until the two signals cancel. This cancellation is very precise because it not only cancels the pulse envelope but also the RF carrier by phase alignment. The method of TDOA measurement by differential delay adjustment requires both RF signals to be available at the two channel measurement receiver and that both channels operate with a common LO and common sampling clock. This method also includes an approach to calibrate the two receive paths of the interferometer.
The present invention improves the precision of currently available methods by using two aircraft to form a large baseline interferometer. This avoids problems associated with using a single aircraft with one or more tethered antennas. The present invention allows for various configurations for geo-location of ground-based emitters from moving aircraft and tracking both stationary and moving emitters.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTIONA method to passively locate a ground-based emitter using two aircraft to form a large baseline interferometer. The basic two element (two aircraft or helicopters) large baseline interferometer includes self-calibration and allows for various configurations for geo-location of ground-based emitters. The two aircraft large baseline interferometer measurement capability includes phase difference of arrival (PDOA) to very precisely locate the emitter in angle. Moving emitters can also be located and tracked with the method of the invention using multiple aircraft.
It is an object of the present invention, therefore, to provide rapid, accurate location of a stationary ground emitter, such as a radar transmitter, from a double moving platform.
It is another object of the invention to provide a radio frequency source locating arrangement which is self-calibrating notwithstanding the presence of environmental-sourced and other inaccuracy influences.
It is another object of the invention to provide a time based moving platform locating system providing angle and range information relative to a distant moving target through use of received radio frequency signals.
It is another object of the invention to provide a stationary emitter locating system that is based on the differing arrival times of a radio frequency signals at two moving aircraft receivers using an iteratively adjusting variable delay line which cancels out two radio frequency signals.
It is another object of the invention to provide a moving or stationary emitter location system based on the use of large baseline signal interferometers.
It is another object of the invention to provide for the location of a moving emitter, such as an airborne radar, using multiple interferometers each formed from two aircraft.
These and other objects of the invention are achieved by the description, claims and accompanying drawings and by a multiple configuration, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating apparatus using two aircraft comprising the combination of:
-
- a first search aircraft containing a first radio frequency measurement receiver, a first radio frequency antenna and a first variable delay component;
- a second aircraft containing a second radio frequency measurement receiver, a second radio frequency antenna and a second variable delay component;
- time difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival rate processing apparatus disposed in each of said first and second radio frequency measurement receivers of said first and second aircraft;
- selectively operable signal propagation time delay calibration apparatus connectable with signal propagating paths interconnecting said first and second aircraft;
- and each of said signals entering each measurement receiver on said first and second aircraft whereby time difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival rate are calculated by said processing apparatus and radio frequency emitter location is determined.
Traditionally interferometers operate by way of measuring signal phase characteristics. In large baseline interferometers, however, phase measurement provides ambiguous results because of the cyclic or periodic nature of the signal phase data. Time difference of arrival measurements are, however, not of this ambiguous nature since they are not cyclic or periodic in character. The time difference of arrival measurement arrangement is therefore the theoretical basis for the present invention as is disclosed in the paragraphs following.
Traditionally large baseline interferometers (LBI) are located on one aircraft. This limits the LBI length to the physical size of the aircraft. Examples are the side of the aircraft, the wing tips of the aircraft, or the nose to wing tip of the aircraft. U.S. Pat. No. 6,255,992 taught how to extend the LBI by using a tethered antenna and also taught how to calibrate the LBI to improve accuracy. (This calibration scheme can also be applied to a LBI installed on a single aircraft.) In U.S. Pat. No. 6,225,992 the geo-location accuracy is improved due to both the self-calibration scheme and the increased LBI length due to the ability to use a tethered antenna. This invention teaches how to form a phase interferometer from two separate aircraft.
In the present invention, self-calibration is achieved primarily by sending the signal received at each aircraft through the same paths. Therefore, the paths are not measured as such by calibration but are instead common to both signals.
TDOA=(R1=R2/c Eq 1
where c is the velocity of light.
The PDOA is given by:
PDOA=(2π/λ)*(R1−R2) Eq 2
where λis the wavelength.
PDOA rate=[PDOA(t2)−PDOA(t1)]/(t2−t1) Eq 3
The invention depicted in
The basic operation of the two aircraft interferometer is illustrated in
The following equations show how the required values are determined. There are four equations. Each equation starts at the emitter 512 in FIG. 5 and ends at the input to the measurement receiver. The equation sums up each path from the emitter to the input to the measurement receiver.
Path 1 is the path from the emitter through antenna 1 to the input of MR1.
R1+P11+P1L+P12+P1g+Pc+P2g+P22+P2L+P22+P2g+Pc=T11m Eq 4
T11m is the measured arrival time of the signal through antenna 1 to MR1
Path 2 is the path from the emitter through antenna 2 to the input of MR1
R2+P21+P2L+P22+P2g+Pc+P1g+P12+P1L+P12=T12m Eq 5
T12m is the measured arrival time of the signal through antenna 2 MR1
Path 3 is the path from the emitter through antenna 1 to the input of MR2
R1+P11+P1L+P12+P1g+Pc+P2g+P22P2L+P22=T21m Eq 6
T21m is the measured arrival time of the signal through antenna 1 to MR2
Path 4 is the path from the emitter through antenna 2 to the input of MR2
R2+P21+P2L+P22P2g+Pc+P1g+P12P1L+P12+P1g+Pc=T22m Eq 7
T22m is the measured arrival time of the signal through antenna 2 to MR2
Now TDOA*c=R1=R2. Eq 8
Solving equation 4 and 5 for R1 and R2 respectively and substituting into equation 8 gives:
TDOA*c=T11m−T12m−Pc+(P21−P11)+(P12P22)−P2g Eq 9
Solving equation 6 and 7 for R1 and R2 respectively and substituting into equation 8 gives:
TDOA*c=T21m−T22m+Pc+(P21−P11)+(P12−P22)+P1g Eq 10
Now equating equations 9 and 10 and solving for Pc gives:
Pc=0.5*[(T11m−T12m)−(T21m−T22m)+P1g+P2g] Eq 11
Pc is the path length between input port 1 of MR1 and input port 2 of MR2 and is one parameter needed to determine TDOA. Pc cannot be pre-calibrated since it varies with aircraft position. (T11m−T12m) is a TDOA measurement made on aircraft #1. Note that T11m and T12m did not have to be measured separately. Only TDOA1=(T11m−T12m) needed to be measured. Likewise only TDOA2 =(T21m−T22m) needed to be measured. The terms P1g and P2g refer to the gap between the two inputs of MR1 and MR2, respectively. They are very small and can be calibrated in the factory so they are known values. Now that Pc has been determined by the measurements, TDOA*c can be determined from either equation 10 or 11 if the terms (P21−P11)+(P12−P22) are known. Again, these terms can be made small and calibrated in the factory. A thermocouple could also be added to these small rigid paths to compensate for length variations as a function of temperature.
To calibrate paths Pr1 and Pr2 in
S+Pt1+Pa+Pr1=Tm1 Eq 12
S+Pt1+Pb+Pr2=Tm2 Eq 13
Subtracting equation 12 from equation 13 gives
Pr2−Pr1=(Tm2−Tm1)−(Pb−Pc) Eq 14
Since Pb−Pa is known or zero then the measure values Tm1 and Tm2 determine the difference in Pr2 and Pr1. Therefore the measurement receiver self calibrates. The reason for the analog variable delays (τ1 and τ2 ) in the
The invention discloses how to form a LBI from two separate aircraft. These two aircraft now form a two element LBI as depicted in FIG. 2.
The proceeding describes how a two element interferometer can be used to geo-locate a stationary emitter on the earth's surface. The TDOA gives the azimuth angle to the emitter. The intersection of this with the earth (aircraft altitude is known) then gives the emitter elevation. The TDOA rate or PDOA rate then determines range. When the emitter is airborne more than one LBI is required. For example as depicted in
The foregoing description of the preferred embodiment has been presented for purposes of illustration and description. It is not intended to be exhaustive or to limit the invention to the precise form disclosed. Obvious modification or variations are possible in light of the above teachings. The embodiment was chosen and described to provide the best illustration of the principles of the invention and its practical application to thereby enable on of ordinary skill in the art to utilize the invention in various embodiments and with various modifications as are suited to the particular scope of the invention as determined by the appended claims when interpreted in accordance with the breadth to which they are fairly, legally and equitably entitled.
Claims
1. A multiple configuration, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating apparatus using two aircraft comprising the combination of:
- a first search aircraft containing a first radio frequency measurement receiver, a first radio frequency antenna and a first variable delay component;
- means for determining a path distance between said first radio frequency measurement receiver and said first radio frequency antenna;
- a second aircraft containing a second radio frequency measurement receiver, a second radio frequency antenna and a second variable delay component;
- means for determining a path distance between said second radio frequency measurement receiver and said second radio frequency antenna;
- time difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival rate processing apparatus disposed in each of said first and second radio frequency measurement receivers of said first and second aircraft; and
- selectively operable signal propagation time delay calibration apparatus connectable with signal propagating paths interconnecting said first and second aircraft;
- wherein a signal received by said first radio frequency antenna and a signal received by said second radio frequency antenna are used by said processing apparatus to calculate time difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival rate; and
- means for geo-locating said emitter by using down range and cross range time and angle error curves to straight-line graph time difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival whereby the time difference of arrival gives an azimuth angle to the emitter and the intersection with the aircraft altitude gives emitter elevation, the time difference of arrival rate and phase difference of arrival determines range and emitter location.
2. The multiple configuration, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating apparatus of claim 1 wherein said first and second radio frequency measurement receivers comprise:
- a plurality of analog-to-digital converters receiving signals using a sampling clock;
- a frequency generating local oscillator, said frequency on said first and second aircraft being similar; and
- a sampling clock, said sampling clock on said first and second aircraft being similar.
3. The multiple configuration, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating apparatus of claim 1 wherein said first and second variable delay component comprise a digital radio frequency memory.
4. The multiple configuration, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating apparatus of claim 1 wherein said firsts and second variable delay components comprise a multiple port switch to switch between fixed delays such as multiple lengths of fiber optic lines.
5. The multiple configuration, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating apparatus of claim 1 wherein said first and second radio frequency measurement receivers are digital receivers.
6. The multiple configuration, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating apparatus of claim 1 wherein said firsts and second radio frequency measurement receivers are analog receivers measuring amplitude difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival.
7. The multiple configuration, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating apparatus of claim 1 wherein said time difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival rate processing apparatus disposed in each of said first and second radio frequency measurement receivers of said first and second aircraft further includes a thermal effects correctable thermocouple.
8. A multiple configuration, dual aircraft, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating method comprising the steps of:
- receiving a first radio frequency emitter signal through a first aircraft antenna and communicating said signal through a first aircraft variable delay line;
- determining path distance between said first radio frequency measurement receiver and said first radio frequency antenna;
- transmitting said first radio frequency emitter signal to a second aircraft measurement receiver and then back to a first aircraft measurement receiver;
- determining path distance between said second radio frequency measurement receiver and said second radio frequency antenna;
- receiving a second radio frequency emitter signal through a second aircraft antenna and then through said second aircraft variable delay line, said first and second aircraft variable delay lines preventing overlap between said first and second radio frequency emitter signals; and
- transmitting said second radio frequency emitter signal to said first aircraft measurement receiver and then back to said second aircraft measurement receiver;
- said first and second aircraft measurement receiver measuring time difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival rate and therefrom determining radio frequency emitter location; and
- geo-locating said emitter by using down range and cross range time and angle error curves to straight-line graph time difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival whereby the time differences of arrival gives an azimuth angle to the emitter and the intersection with the aircraft altitude gives emitter elevation, the time difference of arrival rate and phase difference of arrival determines range and emitter location.
9. The multiple configuration, dual aircraft, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating method of claim 8 wherein steps of receiving first and second radio frequency emitter signals further comprise the steps of:
- receiving signals through a plurality of analog-to-digital converters using a sampling clock;
- generating a frequency using a local oscillator, said frequency on said first and second aircraft being similar; and
- sampling said frequency using a sampling clock, said sampling clock on said first and second aircraft being similar.
10. The multiple configuration, dual aircraft, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating method of claim 8 wherein communicating said signal through a first and second aircraft variable delay line comprises a digital radio frequency memory.
11. The multiple configuration, dual aircraft, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating method of claim 8 wherein said step of receiving a first radio frequency emitter signal further comprises the step of digitally receiving a first radio frequency emitter signal.
12. The multiple configuration, dual aircraft, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating method of claim 8 wherein said step of receiving a second radio frequency emitter signal further comprises the step of digitally receiving a second radio frequency emitter signal.
13. The multiple configuration, dual aircraft, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating method of claim 8 wherein said step of receiving a first radio frequency emitter signal further comprises communicating said signal through analog receivers measuring amplitude difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival.
14. The multiple configuration, dual aircraft, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating method of claim 8 wherein said step of receiving a second radio frequency emitter signal further comprises communicating said signal through analog receivers measuring amplitude difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival.
15. The multiple configuration, dual aircraft, self-calibrating baseline interferometer radio frequency emitter locating method of claim 8 further comprising the step of correcting thermal effects relative to time difference of arrival, phase difference of arrival and phase difference of arrival rate using a thermocouple.
Type: Grant
Filed: Oct 14, 2005
Date of Patent: Oct 7, 2008
Assignee: The United States of America as represented by the Secretary of the Air Force (Washington, DC)
Inventor: Thomas L. Madden (Dayton, OH)
Primary Examiner: Dan Pihulic
Attorney: AFMCLO/JAZ
Application Number: 11/251,003
International Classification: G01S 5/02 (20060101);