High specific mechanical energy extrusion screw assembly
High Specific Mechanical Energy extruder screw assemblies (14, 88, 98) and complete extruders (10, 86, 96) are provided, which include wide-flight intermediate screw sections (104) having axial flight widths greater than the flight widths of the inlet and outlet screw sections (102, 106) on opposite sides of the intermediate sections (104). The intermediate sections (104) provide increased friction and shear serving to enhance the SMEs imparted to comestible food materials during processing thereof.
Latest Wenger Manufacturing Inc. Patents:
This application is a division of application Ser. No. 15/981,557 filed May 16, 2018, which claims the benefit of provisional application Ser. 62/513,899 filed Jun. 1, 2017, each of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION Field of the InventionThe present invention is broadly concerned with helically flighted extrusion screw assemblies and extruders which are specially designed for processing of comestible food or feed products, such as pet and aquatic feeds. More particularly, the invention is concerned with such equipment, and corresponding methods, wherein the extruder screw assemblies are characterized by intermediate screw sections having relatively wide flight widths, as compared with inlet and outlet screw sections on opposite sides of the intermediate sections. This increases the Specific Mechanical Energy (SME) imparted to the products during processing thereof, which enhances the nutritional and handling qualities of the products.
Description of the Prior ArtMany comestible products such as human foods and animal feeds are produced using extrusion equipment, the general configuration and operation of which is well known in the art. During extrusion, energy is imparted to the materials being processed, by two separate contributions, namely SME and Specific Thermal Energy (STE), the latter being accomplished by indirect or direct application of hot water or steam. The amounts of SME and STE can be varied depending upon the type of product desired and other processing considerations. However, certain types of comestible products, such as aquatic feeds, require enhanced properties, such as increased fat/oil uptake and retention, as well as nutritional and feeding characteristics when high levels of SME are employed. SME is normally developed by frictional forces and associated heat during the extrusion process.
Heretofore, attempts at making high-quality aquatic and other feeds using single screw extruders has required the use of specialized tooling or other expedients in order to generate sufficient amounts of SME. For example, it is known that mid-barrel adjustable valves can be helpful in this regard, of the type described in US Patent Publication 2007/0237850. Additionally, use has been made of non-flighted triangular or other types of plates placed between helical sections of extruder screws, as well as breaker rings, all in an effort to increase SME. However, these attempts have not been wholly satisfactory, meaning that many comestible food or feed products produced using single screw extruders have not been of optimum quality.
The following references describe various types of extruder screw assemblies known in the art: U.S. Pat. Nos. 1,677,119, 2,115,006, 2,231,357, 2,508,495, 2,686,336, 3,104,420, 3,577,494, 3,698,541, 4,277,182, 4,405,239, 4,818,206, 5,728,337, 6,599,004, 6,672,753, 7,476,096, and 8,985,034; US Patent Publication No. 2009/0016147; foreign applications Nos. CN204222133U, DE1504449A1, DE10110860B4, DE10206484A1, DE29720689U1, EP1768823B1; FR2063573A5, FR2257409A1, GB1279663A, GB1291997A, JP2010194794A, JP2011224801A, JP2013035234A, JP2014184733A, JP2016943623A, JP2016107509A, JP2016182687A, JP2016215470A, JP2016215473A, JP2016215475A, JPH03231825A, JPH11188764A, JPS5057725A, JPS6384904A, JPS62286708A, JPS63291632A, NL44896C, NL52125C, and WO8606325A1; and two product brochures.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTIONThe present invention overcomes the problems outlined above, and provides improved extruder screw assemblies and complete extruders, which are characterized by the ability to generate high levels of SME without the need for specialized tooling or other add-on equipment. Generally speaking, the extruder screw assemblies of the invention are designed for placement within an elongated extruder barrel having an inlet and a spaced outlet. The screw assemblies are helically flighted along the lengths thereof, axially rotatable, and have a total length. When placed within an extruder barrel, the screw assemblies comprise:
-
- a helically flighted inlet section having an axial length, a pitch length, and a screw diameter, with the inlet section extending from the barrel inlet toward the barrel outlet and presenting an inlet section terminus;
- a helically flighted intermediate section having an axial length, a pitch length, and a screw diameter, with the intermediate section extending from the inlet section terminus toward the barrel outlet and presenting an intermediate section terminus; and
- a helically flighted outlet section having an axial length, a pitch length, and a screw diameter, with the outlet section extending from the intermediate section terminus toward the barrel outlet.
Additionally, the screw assemblies are characterized by the intermediate sections thereof having a flight width greater than the flight widths of the inlet and outlet sections. Such wide-flight intermediate sections create areas of intense friction and heat generation during processing of comestible materials, thereby increasing the SME imparted to the materials. A number of other dimensional and geometric features can be designed into the screw assemblies, depending upon the desired products to be produced. For example, optional preferred features include intermediate sections with flight widths at least about 250% greater than the flight widths of the inlet and outlet sections; intermediate section flight widths which are from about 20-80% of the pitch length of the intermediate section; and/or intermediate section flight widths which are from about 15-50% of the screw diameters of the intermediate sections. Further, other such features relating to the relative axial lengths of the inlet, intermediate, and outlet screw sections, and the pitch lengths or flight depths of these sections can be incorporated into the overall extruder screw assemblies.
The invention also pertains to methods of operating the extruders of the invention, in the processing of comestible food or feed products having starting mixtures comprising respective quantities of starch, protein, and fat, for example.
While the extruder screw assemblies of the invention are particularly useful in the context of single screw extruders, the invention is not so limited. Rather, these same types of screw assemblies can be incorporated into twin screw extruders, if desired. Moreover, while the individual screw sections described herein are preferably flighted throughout the lengths thereof, this is not strictly necessary. Individual screw sections may have unflighted regions along the lengths thereof, but preferably the sections should have at least about 75% of the lengths bearing fighting, more preferably about 90% of such lengths.
Turning first to
In more detail, the barrel 12 includes a total of seven tubular heads 18-30 interconnected in an end-to-end fashion to define an elongated, continuous, substantially circular in cross-section interior 32. As illustrated, inlet head 18 is equipped with a material inlet 34, whereas terminal head 30 presents a processed product outlet 36. Each of the heads 20-30 is equipped with an inner flighted sleeve 20a-30a. The sleeves 20a-28a present substantially tubular passageways, whereas terminal sleeve 30a is tapered along the length thereof. Although not shown, if desired, some or all of the barrel heads may be equipped with external jackets permitting introduction of heat exchange media, such as steam or water; moreover, these heads could also be provided with injectors for allowing direct introduction of steam into the interior 32 of the barrel 12.
The screw assembly 14 is designed to convey material from inlet 34 along the length of barrel 12 and out the outlet 36. Moreover, the screw assembly serves to subject the materials to increasing levels of temperature and shear as material passes through the barrel, in order to cook and form the material. To this end, the assembly 14 is axially rotatable and made up of a series of interconnected, helically flighted sections, namely an inlet section 38, three conventional conveying sections 40, 42, and 44, an intermediate wide-flight section 46, and a conical terminal or outlet section 48. Ring elements 50, 52, and 54 are respectively located between sections 40 and 42, 42 and 44, and 44 and 46.
The back pressure valve assembly 16 is of the type described in U.S. Pat. No. 6,773,739, which is incorporated by reference herein in its entirety. In particular, the assembly 16 includes three interconnected components, namely an inlet transition 60, a valve unit 62, and an outlet 64. The transition 60 is secured to the butt end of barrel 12 and is in communication with barrel outlet 36. The valve unit 62 has an upright tubular segment 66 with a lateral opening 68 in alignment with transition 60. An elongated valve member 70 is situated and vertically shiftable within the segment 66. The valve unit 62 includes a somewhat triangular-shaped, laterally extending through-opening 72, as well as a product diversion passageway or channel 74 including an inlet 76 and an outlet 78. The valve unit 62 is selectively movable within segment 66 by means of a piston and cylinder assembly 80.
The outlet 64 has an outwardly diverging passageway 82 in alignment with the opening 68, and is equipped with a restricted orifice die plate 84, as shown.
It will be appreciated from the foregoing description that the screw assemblies 14, 88, and 98 differ primarily in the length and position of the intermediate wide flight screw section(s) therein. In order to better understand these relationships,
In the ensuing discussion relating to the geometries of the screw sections making up the screw assemblies 14, 88, and 98, reference will be made to certain features of the individual screw sections, each of which include a central shaft S and outwardly extending, helical fighting F. In order to better understand this discussion, reference is made to
Preferred Features of the Screw Assemblies 14, 88, 98
The screw assemblies 14, 88, and 98 are all characterized by helically flighted inlet, intermediate, and outlet sections 102-106 each having respective axial lengths (Inlet-Ls, INT.-Ls, and OUT.-Ls), pitch lengths (PLs), screw diameters (SDs), root diameters (RDs), flight widths (FWs), and flight depths (FLT.DPH.s). Each inlet sections 102 extends from the barrel inlet 34 toward the barrel outlet 36 and defines the terminus 102a. Each intermediate sections 104 extends from the terminus 102a toward the barrel outlet 36 and defines the intermediate section terminus 104a. Finally, each outlet sections 106 extends from the intermediate section terminus 104a toward the barrel outlet 36.
In all of the embodiments, the flight widths of the inlet sections 102 and the outlet sections 106 are less than the flight widths of the intermediate sections 104. However, in different embodiments, the respective sections 102-106 have certain characteristics, as set forth below.
Intermediate Sections 104
-
- The flight widths of the intermediate sections 104 are at least about 250% greater than the flight widths of the inlet sections 102 and the outlet sections 106, e.g., from about 250-750% greater, more preferably from about 300-600% greater, and most preferably from about 325-525% greater.
- The flight widths of the intermediate sections 104 are from about 20-80%, more preferably from about 25-55%, of the pitch lengths of the corresponding intermediate sections 104.
- The flight widths of the intermediate sections 104 are from about 15-50%, more preferably from about 20-40%, of the screw diameters of the corresponding intermediate sections 104.
- The flight angles of the sections 102-106 are from about 20-50°, and more preferably from about 25-35°.
- The axial lengths of the intermediate sections 104 are from about 10-40%, more preferably from about 12-35%, of the total lengths of the corresponding screw assemblies 14, 88, 98.
- The axial lengths of the intermediate sections 104 are less than the axial lengths of the inlet sections 102 of the corresponding screw assemblies 14, 88, 98, more preferably from about 15-80%, still more preferably from about 18-75%, of the axial lengths of the inlet sections 102 of the corresponding screw assemblies 14, 88, 98.
- The pitch lengths of the intermediate sections 104 are from about 30-70%, more preferably from about 40-60%, of the screw diameters of the corresponding intermediate sections 104.
- The pitch lengths of the intermediate sections 104 are less than the pitch lengths of the inlet sections of the corresponding screw assemblies 14, 88, 98.
- The flight depths of the intermediate sections 104 are from about 8-25%, more preferably from about 12-20%, of the screw diameters of the corresponding intermediate sections 104.
- The flight depths of the intermediate sections 104 are less than the flight depths of the inlet sections 102 of the corresponding screw assemblies 14, 88, 98.
- The intermediate sections 104 have substantially constant flight depths, i.e., no more than about a 15% variance in such flight depths.
- The intermediate sections 104 have substantially constant pitch lengths, i.e., no more than about a 15% variance in such pitch lengths.
- The intermediate sections 104 have substantially constant screw diameters, i.e., no more than about a 15% variance in such screw diameters.
- The intermediate sections 104 have only a single flight.
Inlet Sections 102
-
- The inlet sections 102 have flight widths of from about 2-15%, more preferably from about 3-12%, of the corresponding pitch lengths of the inlet sections 102.
- The inlet sections 102 have flight widths from about 0.4-7%, more preferably from about 0.5-5%, of the axial lengths of the corresponding inlet sections 102.
- The inlet sections 102 have flight widths of from about 4-9%, more preferably from about 5-7% of the screw diameters of the corresponding inlet sections 102.
- The inlet sections 102 have substantially constant flight depths, i.e., no more than about a 15% variance in such flight depths.
- The inlet sections 102 have decreasing pitch lengths along the lengths thereof.
- The inlet sections 102 have substantially constant screw diameters, i.e., no more than about a 15% variance in such screw diameters.
- The inlet sections 102 have only a single flight.
Outlet Sections 106
-
- The outlet sections 106 have flight widths of from about 4-15%, more preferably from about 5-12%, of the corresponding pitch lengths of the outlet sections 106.
- The outlet sections 106 have flight widths from about 0.4-10%, more preferably from about 1-7.5%, of the axial lengths of the corresponding outlet sections 106.
- The outlet sections 106 have flight widths of from about 2-8%, more preferably from about 3-7% of the screw diameters of the corresponding outlet sections 106.
- The outlet sections 106 have substantially constant flight depths, i.e., no more than about a 15% variance in such flight depths.
- The outlet sections 106 have substantially constant or decreasing pitch lengths along the lengths thereof
- The outlet sections 106 have portions thereof with decreasing screw diameters.
- The outlet sections 106 are double flighted when a conical terminal segment is employed, but otherwise have only a single flight.
It should be understood that not all of the above-described preferred features for the intermediate, inlet, and outlet sections need be present in every such section; rather, any given intermediate, inlet, or outlet section may embody one or more of the respective preferred features. Additionally, while in some cases the screw assembly sections preferably have essentially constant screw diameters, root diameters, and flight depths, the invention is not so limited. In instances where the screw diameters, root diameters, and/or flight depths vary along the lengths of the sections, for purposes of the percentage ranges given above, the screw diameters, root diameters, or flight depths, as the case may be, should be determined as the arithmetic mean of the greatest and smallest values. For example, if a given section has a decreasing screw diameter, the maximum screw diameter is added to the minimum screw diameter, and this sum is divided by 2. This same analysis would follow for the root diameters and flight depths.
Operation
As noted previously, the extruders of the invention are designed for the production of comestible food or feed products, and are not suitable for processing of rubber and plastic materials. During operations where comestible products are prepared, starting dry mixtures, are formulated typically containing grain(s) (e.g., wheat, corn, oats, milo, soy), proteins, fats, vitamins, minerals, and the like. These mixtures are normally preconditioned by passage through known preconditioner apparatus, such as Wenger DDC or HIP preconditions, in order to moisturize and precook the mixtures. The preconditioned mixtures are then fed into the inlet of the extruder during rotation the screw assemblies therein, in order to move the materials along the length of the extruder barrels for ultimate extrusion. During such passage, the materials are subjected to increasing levels of temperature, pressure, and shear in order to fully cook the materials and allow formation thereof as self-sustaining bodies. The extruded products are then normally dried and may be coated with oil or other liquids to create the final products.
Where use is made of a backpressure valve assembly 16, the valve member 70 is normally placed in its upper position during startup of the extruder so that material from the barrel 12 will pass through the inlet 76 and out through passageway 74. As the extruder run progresses and acceptable extrudates are being produced, the valve member is shifted downwardly to the
In the context of the present invention, the materials are subjected to high levels of friction and shear in the intermediate wide-flight sections 104 of the extruders. Consequently, the products are formed with relatively high levels of SME, which enhances the physical and nutritional properties of the products. The presence of the sections 104 thus permits production of high-quality end products without the use of extraneous tools or equipment characteristic of prior art extruders of this type.
Prior Art Screw Assemblies
As indicated above, the present invention provides improved screw assemblies and extruders, which are capable of producing high-quality feeds, such as pet feeds and aquatic feeds, without the use of expedients such as mid-barrel valves, specialized mixing plates, and multiple die plate arrangements. In order to better understand the nature of the present invention as it relates to the prior art, attention is first directed to
Similarly,
The following examples set forth preferred extruder configurations and test results using these configurations. It is to be understood, however, that these examples are provided by way of illustration only, and nothing therein should be taken as a limitation on the overall scope of the invention.
A series of comparative extruder runs for the preparation of salmon feed were carried out using two different extruder configurations, namely a standard extruder configuration as illustrated in
In each case, the salmon feed recipe was made up of 25.4% ground wheat, 30.5% soy concentrate (60%), 13.1% Menhaden fish meal, 13.2% corn gluten meal (60%), and 17.8% wheat gluten, where all percentages are by weight.
The following table sets forth the conditions used in the comparative tests, as well as the properties of the extrudates, where moisture % refers to the moisture of the products off of the extruder prior to any drying, and oil absorption is the retained oil absorption for the products after 18 hours soaking in water, followed by vacuum drying.
These test results confirm that the W-F extruder configuration gave the same or slightly higher cook levels, lower wet and dry bulk densities, and higher oil absorption values, as compared with the Std. configuration. The latter result is particularly important because salmon feeds produced using Std. configuration extruders tend to lose oil. The physical appearance of the feeds prepared using the W-F configuration were superior to those from the Std. configuration.
Claims
1. A method of producing a comestible food product, comprising the steps of:
- passing a comestible mixture into and through an extruder having an elongated barrel comprising an inlet and an outlet, and an elongated, axially rotatable, helically flighted screw assembly within the barrel to produce said food product,
- said screw assembly including an inlet section, an intermediate section, and an outlet section, each of said inlet, intermediate, and outlet sections having an axial length, a flight width, a pitch length, a screw diameter, and a flight depth, the flight width of said intermediate section being greater than the flight widths of said inlet and outlet sections, respectively;
- rotating said screw assembly in order to move said mixture from said inlet, along the length of said barrel, and out through said outlet; and
- during said movement of said mixture, subjecting the mixture to increasing levels of temperature, pressure, and shear within said barrel, comprising the steps of subjecting said material to greater levels of friction and heat generation in said intermediate section than in said inlet and outlet sections, so that increased levels of specific mechanical energy (SME) are imparted to the material in the intermediate section, as compared with the SME imparted in said inlet and outlet sections.
2. The method of claim 1, the flight width of said intermediate section being at least about 250% greater than the flight widths of said inlet and outlet sections, respectively.
3. The method of claim 2, the flight width of said intermediate section being from about 300-600% greater than the flight widths of said inlet and outlet sections, respectively.
4. The method of claim 1, the flight width of said intermediate section being from about 20-80% of the pitch length of the intermediate section.
5. The method of claim 1, the flight width of said intermediate section being from about 15-50% of the screw diameter of the intermediate section.
6. The method of claim 1, the axial length of said intermediate section being from about 10-40% of the full length of said screw assembly.
7. The method of claim 1, the axial length of said intermediate section being from about 15-80% of the axial length of said inlet section.
8. The method of claim 1, the pitch length of said intermediate section being from about 30-70% of the screw diameter of the intermediate section.
9. The method of claim 1, the pitch length of said intermediate section being less than the pitch length of said inlet section.
10. The method of claim 1, the flight depth of said intermediate section being less than the flight depth of said inlet section.
11. The method of claim 1, said intermediate section having a substantially constant pitch length.
12. The method of claim 1, said intermediate section having a single flight.
13. The method of claim 1, the screw diameter of said inlet section and said intermediate section being substantially the same.
14. The method of claim 1, said comestible material comprising quantities of grain, protein, and fat.
15. The method of claim 1, including the step of preconditioning said mixture in order to moisturize and pre-cook the mixture, prior to passage thereof through said extruder.
16. A method of producing a comestible food product, comprising the steps of:
- passing a comestible mixture into and through an extruder having an elongated barrel comprising an inlet and an outlet, and an elongated, axially rotatable, helically flighted screw assembly within the barrel to produce said food product,
- said screw assembly including an inlet section, an intermediate section, and an outlet section, each of said inlet, intermediate, and outlet sections having an axial length, a flight width, a pitch length, a screw diameter, and a flight depth, at least a portion of the inlet section and at least a portion of the outlet section being tapered along the length thereof, the screw diameter of said intermediate section being substantially constant;
- rotating said screw assembly in order to move said mixture from said inlet, along the length of said barrel, and out through said outlet; and
- during said movement of said mixture, subjecting the mixture to increasing levels of temperature, pressure, and shear within said barrel, comprising the steps of subjecting said material to greater levels of friction and heat generation in said intermediate section than in said inlet and outlet sections, so that increased levels of specific mechanical energy (SME) are imparted to the material in the intermediate section, as compared with the SME imparted in said inlet and outlet sections.
1677119 | July 1928 | Kinyon |
2115006 | April 1938 | Burghauser |
2231357 | February 1941 | Burghauser et al. |
2508495 | May 1950 | Consalvo |
2686336 | August 1954 | Kleinlein et al. |
3104420 | September 1963 | Selbach |
3577494 | May 1971 | Chisholm et al. |
3698541 | October 1972 | Barr |
4184772 | January 22, 1980 | Meyer |
4277182 | July 7, 1981 | Kruder |
4405239 | September 20, 1983 | Chung et al. |
4607797 | August 26, 1986 | Enikolopow |
4818206 | April 4, 1989 | Maillefer |
4839193 | June 13, 1989 | Mange |
4875847 | October 24, 1989 | Wenger |
5262190 | November 16, 1993 | Cunningham |
5665419 | September 9, 1997 | Teraguchi |
5694833 | December 9, 1997 | Wenger |
5728337 | March 17, 1998 | Yoshikawa et al. |
6103290 | August 15, 2000 | Wenger |
6248386 | June 19, 2001 | Willibald-Ettle |
6599004 | July 29, 2003 | Barr |
6672753 | January 6, 2004 | Womer et al. |
7097873 | August 29, 2006 | Asensio |
7476096 | January 13, 2009 | Iwata et al. |
7521076 | April 21, 2009 | Wenger |
7987774 | August 2, 2011 | Wenger |
8246240 | August 21, 2012 | Wenger |
8393780 | March 12, 2013 | Wenger |
8827539 | September 9, 2014 | Wenger |
8985034 | March 24, 2015 | Dummett |
9931603 | April 3, 2018 | Wenger |
20040043094 | March 4, 2004 | Hauck et al. |
20080223223 | September 18, 2008 | Wenger et al. |
20090016147 | January 15, 2009 | Behling et al. |
20100062093 | March 11, 2010 | Wenger |
20110086150 | April 14, 2011 | Plattner |
20110091627 | April 21, 2011 | Wenger |
20150367298 | December 24, 2015 | Wenger |
20180343914 | December 6, 2018 | Wenger |
20200113222 | April 16, 2020 | Wenger |
20200120970 | April 23, 2020 | Rokey |
204222133 | March 2015 | CN |
1504449 | October 1969 | DE |
29720689 | February 1998 | DE |
10206484 | November 2003 | DE |
10110860 | April 2006 | DE |
1768823 | March 2014 | EP |
2063573 | July 1971 | FR |
2257409 | August 1975 | FR |
1279663 | June 1972 | GB |
1291997 | October 1972 | GB |
S62286708 | December 1987 | JP |
S6384904 | April 1988 | JP |
S63291632 | November 1988 | JP |
H03231825 | October 1991 | JP |
35057725 | March 1993 | JP |
H11188764 | July 1999 | JP |
2010194794 | September 2010 | JP |
2011224801 | November 2011 | JP |
2013035234 | February 2013 | JP |
2014184733 | October 2014 | JP |
2016043623 | April 2016 | JP |
2016107509 | June 2016 | JP |
2016182687 | October 2016 | JP |
2016215470 | December 2016 | JP |
2016215473 | December 2016 | JP |
2016215475 | December 2016 | JP |
44896 | January 1939 | NL |
52125 | March 1942 | NL |
8606325 | February 1985 | WO |
- WMV Product Brochure 2017, available online at http://www.wmv.nl/wear_resistant_coating_for_extrusion_and_plast_molding_screw.htm.
- Cowell Product Brochure 2017, available online at http://www.nbcowell.com/content/?93.html.
- International Search Report and Written Opinion dated Jan. 17, 2019, in PCT/US2018/033001 filed May 16, 2018.
Type: Grant
Filed: Dec 11, 2019
Date of Patent: Feb 22, 2022
Patent Publication Number: 20200113222
Assignee: Wenger Manufacturing Inc. (Sabetha, KS)
Inventors: Marc L. Wenger (Sabetha, KS), Philip B. Wiltz (Sabetha, KS)
Primary Examiner: Tony G Soohoo
Application Number: 16/710,379
International Classification: B29C 48/535 (20190101); A23N 17/00 (20060101); A23P 30/20 (20160101); B29C 48/615 (20190101); A23K 40/25 (20160101); B29C 48/505 (20190101); B29C 48/25 (20190101); B29C 48/57 (20190101); B29C 48/60 (20190101); B01F 7/00 (20060101);