Electrically alterable non-volatile memory with n-bits per cell

Abstract

A multi-bit memory device with a memory cell means for storing input information for an indefinite period of time. The multi-bit memory means stores information in up to Kn memory states (Kn>1). A memory cell programming means and comparator means is also included. The present multi-bit memory device also includes a voltage divider arrangement with pull-up devices in a memory array to provide stable and accurate reference voltages over process, temperature, and voltage variations.

Description

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

[0001] This application is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/071,816, filed Jun. 4, 1993 entitled “Electrically Alterable Non-Volatile Memory with N-Bits Per Memory Cell,” which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 07/652,878, filed Feb. 8, 1991 (now U.S. Pat. No. 5,218,569) entitled “Electrically Alterable Non-Volatile Memory with N-Bits Per Cell.”

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

[0002] 1. Field of the Invention

[0003] This invention relates to non-volatile memory (NVM) devices; and, more particularly, is concerned with an apparatus and method for providing a multi-level NVM device with stable reference voltages.

[0004] 2. Description of the Background Art

[0005] In conventional single-bit per cell memory devices, the memory cell assumes one of two information storage states, either an “on” state or an “off” state. This combination of either “on” or “off” defines one bit of information. As a result, a memory device which can store n-bits of data requires n separate memory cells.

[0006] Increasing the number of bits which can be stored in a single-bit per cell memory device relies upon increasing the number of memory cells on a one-for-one basis with the number of bits of data to be stored. Methods for increasing the number of memory bits in a single memory device have relied upon the following advanced manufacturing techniques: manufacture larger die which contain more memory cells or use improved lithography techniques to build smaller memory cells and allow more memory cells to be placed in a given area on a single chip.

[0007] An alternative approach to the single-bit per cell approach involves storing multiple-bits of data in a single memory cell. Previous approaches to implementing multiple-bit per cell non-volatile memory devices have only involved mask programmable read only memories (ROMs). In one of these approaches, the channel width and/or length of the memory cell is varied such that 2n different conductivity values are obtained which correspond to 2n different states corresponding to n-bits of data which can be stored on a single memory cell. In another approach, the ion implant for the threshold voltage is varied such that the memory cell will have 2n different voltage thresholds (Vt) corresponding to 2n different conductance levels corresponding to 2n different states corresponding to n-bits of data which can be stored on a single memory cell. Examples of memory devices of these types are described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,192,014 by Craycraft, U.S. Pat. No. 4,586,163 by Koike, U.S. Pat. No. 4,287,570 by Stark, U.S. Pat. No. 4,327,424 by Wu, and U.S. Pat. No. 4,847,808 by Kobatake.

[0008] Single-bit per cell read-only-memory devices are only required to sense, or read, two different levels or states per cell, consequently they have need for only one voltage reference. Sensing schemes for multi-level memory devices are more complex and require 2n−1 voltage references. Examples of such multiple state sensing schemes for ROMs are described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,449,203 by Adlhoch, U.S. Pat. No. 4,495,602 by Shepard, U.S. Pat. No. 4,503,578 by Iwahashi, and U.S. Pat. No. 4,653,023 by Suzuki. A limitation with the conventional sensing schemes is often inaccurate and unstable reference voltage levels. The conventional sensing schemes have reference voltage levels which cannot accurately track bit line voltage levels through process, temperature, and voltage variations.

[0009] These approaches to a multi-bit ROM commonly have one of 2n different conductivity levels of each memory cell being determined during the manufacturing process by means of a customized mask that is valid for only one data pattern. Thus, for storing n different data information patterns, a minimum of n different masks need to be produced and incorporated into a manufacturing process. Each time a data information pattern needs to be changed a new mask must be created and a new batch of semiconductor wafers processed. This dramatically increases the time between a data -pattern change and the availability of a memory product programmed with that new data pattern.

[0010] Prior art electrically alterable multiple-bit per cell memory approaches store multiple levels of charge on a capacitive storage element, such as is found in a conventional dynamic random access memory (DRAM) or a charge coupled device (CCD). Such approaches are described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,139,910 by Anantha, U.S. Pat. No. 4,306,300 by Terman, U.S. Pat. No. 4,661,929 by Aoki, U.S. Pat. No. 4,709,350 by Nakagome, and U.S. Pat. No. 4,771,404 by Mano. All of these approaches use volatile storage, that is, the charge levels are not permanently stored. They provide 2n different volatile charge levels on a capacitor to define 2n different states corresponding to n-bits of data per memory cell. All of these approaches have the common characteristic that whatever information is stored on such a memory cell is volatile because such a cell loses its data whenever power is removed. Furthermore, these types-of memory cells must be periodically refreshed as they have a tendency to lose charge over time even when power is maintained.

[0011] It would be advantageous to develop a multi-bit semiconductor memory cell that has the non-volatile characteristic of a mask programmable read-only-memory (ROM) and the-electrically alterable characteristic of a multi-bit per cell DRAM. These characteristics combined in a single cell would provide a multi-bit per cell electrically alterable non-volatile memory (EANVM) capable of storing Kn bits of data, where “K” is the base of the numbering system being used and “n” is the number of bits to be stored in each memory cells Additionally, it would be advantageous if the EANVM described above was fully compatible with conventions industry standard device programmers/erasers and programming/erasing algorithms such that a user can program/erase the multi-bit per cell memory in a manner identical to that used for current single-bit per cell memory devices.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

[0012] The present invention provides a multi-level electrically alterable non-volatile memory (EANVM) device, wherein some or all of the storage locations have more than two distinct states and such states are compared to stable reference voltages. The stable reference voltages are generated by way of cells made during the same (or similar) process steps as the memory device.

[0013] In a specific embodiment, the present invention provides a multi-level memory device. The present multi-level memory device includes a multi-level cell means for storing input information for an indefinite period of time as a discrete state of the multi-level cell means. The multi-level cell means stores information in Kn memory states, where K is a base of a predetermined number system, n is a number of bits stored per cell, and Kn>2. The present multi-level memory device also includes a memory cell programming means for programming the multi-level cell means to a state corresponding to the input information. A comparator means for comparing the memory state of the multi-level cell means with the input information is also included. The input information corresponds to one of a plurality of reference voltages. The present comparator means further generates a control signal indicative of the memory state as compared to the input information.

[0014] An alternative specific embodiment also provides a multi-level, memory device. The present multi-level memory device includes a multi-level cell means for storing input information for an indefinite period of time as a discrete state of the multi-level cell means. The multi-level cell means stores information in Kn memory states, where K is a base of a predetermined number system, n is a number-of bits stored per cell, and Kn>2. A memory cell programming means for programming the multi-level cell means to a state corresponding to the input information is also included. The present multi-level memory device further includes a comparator means for comparing the memory state of the multi-level cell means with the input information. The input information corresponds to one of a plurality of reference voltages. The present comparator means further generates a control signal indicative of the memory state as compared to the input information. A reference voltage means for defining the plurality of reference voltages is also included. The present reference voltage means is operably coupled to the comparator means.

[0015] In an alternative specific embodiment, the present invention provides an integrated circuit with a plurality of multi-level cells. The present integrated circuit includes a multi-level memory cell for storing input information for an indefinite period of time as a discrete state of said multi-level memory cell. The multi-level memory cell stores information in Kn memory states, where K is a base of a predetermined number system and n is a number of bits stored per multi-level memory cell, wherein Kn>2. The present integrated circuit also includes a memory cell programming circuit for programming the multi-level memory cell to a memory state corresponding to the input information. A comparator for comparing the memory state of the multi-level memory cell with the input information is also included. The input information corresponds to one of a plurality of reference voltages. The comparator means further generates a control signal indicative of the memory state as compared to the input information. The present integrated circuit also includes a reference voltage cell for providing the one plurality of reference voltages. The reference voltage cell is operably coupled to the comparator. The multi-level memory cell is defined by one of the plurality of multi-level cells and the reference voltage cell is defined by another of the plurality of multi-level cells.

[0016] A further embodiment provides an integrated circuit device with a plurality of multi-level cells. The plurality of multi-level cells defines a multi-level memory cell and a reference voltage cell..

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0017] The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and form a part of this specification, illustrate embodiments of the invention and, together with the description, serve to explain the principles of the invention:

[0018] FIG. 1 is a generic schematic representation of a non-volatile floating gate memory cell.

[0019] FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a prior art single-bit memory system.

[0020] FIG. 3 is a timing diagram of the voltage threshold of a prior art single-bit per cell EANVM system being programmed from an erased “1” state to a programmed “0”.

[0021] FIG. 4 is a timing diagram of the bit line voltage of a prior single-bit per cell EANVM during a read operation. It illustrates waveform levels for both the programmed and erased conditions.

[0022] FIG. 5 is a block diagram of an M×N memory array implementing a multi-bit per cell EANVM system.

[0023] FIG. 6 is a block diagram for reading a multi-bit per cell EANVM system.

[0024] FIG. 7 shows the bit line voltage during a read cycle as a function of time for a 2-bit per cell EANVM which has been programmed to one of four possible states, (0,0), (1,0), (0,1) and the fully erased condition (1,1). Four separate voltage levels are represented on this figure, each representing one of the four possible states. Only one of these would be present for any given read operation.

[0025] FIG. 9 is a timing diagram which illustrates the voltage threshold of a 2-bit per cell EANVM being erased from a fully programmed (0,0) state to one of the other three possible states.

[0026] FIG. 8 is a block diagram of a multi-bit per cell system combining program/verify and read circuitry.

[0027] FIG. 9 is a timing diagram for the voltage threshold for a 2-bit per cell EANVM being programmed from a fully erased (1,1) state to one of the other three possible states.

[0028] FIG. 11 is a timing diagram illustrating the voltage threshold of a 2-bit per cell EANVM during a program/verify cycle using fixed width program pulses.

[0029] FIG. 12 is a timing diagram illustrating the bit line voltage of a 2-bit per cell EANVM during a program/verify process which uses fixed width program pulses.

[0030] FIG. 13 is a timing diagram illustrating the voltage threshold of a 2-bit per cell EANVM during a program/verify cycle using variable width program pulses.

[0031] FIG. 14 is a timing diagram illustrating the bit line voltage of a 2-bit per cell EANVM during a program/verify process which uses variable width program pulses.

[0032] FIG. 15 is a simplified diagram of voltages for a 2-bit per memory cell according to the present invention.

[0033] FIG. 16 is a simplified voltage generator circuit diagram of a voltage divider arrangement for generating multiple reference voltages according to the present invention.

[0034] FIG. 17 illustrates the reference voltages of FIG. 16 according to the present invention.

[0035] FIG. 18 is a simplified voltage generator circuit diagram for an array showing reference voltage columns connected to pull-up devices according to the present, invention.

[0036] FIG. 19 is a simplified voltage generator circuit diagram-for obtaining reference voltages with use of pull-up devices and a voltage divider according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention.

[0037] FIG. 20 is a simplified diagram of a voltage generator circuit according to an alternative embodiment of the present invention.

DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT

[0038] Reference will now be made in detail to the specific embodiments of the invention, examples of which are illustrated in the accompanying drawings. While the invention will be described in conjunction with the specific embodiments, it will be understood that they are not intended to limit the invention to those embodiments. On the contrary, the invention is intended to cover various alternatives, modifications and equivalents, which may be included within the spirit and scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.

[0039] In general, the invention described here allows n-bits of information to be stored on and read from an Electrically Alterable Non-Volatile Memory (EANVM). This is accomplished by electrically varying the conductivity of the channel of a floating gate FET to be within any one of Kn conductivity ranges where “K” represents the base of the numbering system being employed (in a binary system, “K” equals 2). The conductivity range is then-sensed-and encoded. This forms the basis of an n-bit EANVM memory cell. The floating gate FET conductivity is electrically modified by using conventional external programming hardware and algorithms which supply conventional signals and voltages to the EANVM memory device.

[0040] These external signals and voltages are then modified internal to the device to provide an internally controlled program/verify cycle which incrementally stores electrons on the floating gate until the desired conductivity range is achieved. For the purpose of illustration, the n-bit per cell descriptions will assume a binary system which stores 2-bits per memory cell.

[0041] I. PRIOR ART SINGLE-BIT EANVM DEVICES

[0042] FIG. 1 is a generic schematic representation of a non-volatile floating gate memory cell 10 It is not intended that this schematic drawing is in any way indicative of the device structure. It is used to illustrate the fact that this invention refers to an FET memory cell which uses an electrically isolated, or floating, gate 14 to store charged particles for-the purpose of altering the voltage threshold and hence channel conductivity of the FET memory cell 10.

[0043] The FET memory cell 10 includes a-control gate 12 which is used either to select the memory cell for reading or is used to cause electrons to be injected onto the floating gate 14 during the programming process. Floating gate 14 is an electrically isolated structure which can indefinitely store electrons. The presence or absence of electrons on floating gate 14 alters the voltage threshold of the memory cell 10 and as a result alters the conductivity of its channel region. A drain region 16 of the FET is coupled to a source region 18 by a channel region 19. When the floating gate 14 is fully erased and the control gate 12 has been selected, the channel region 19 is in the fully “on”, or high conductivity, state. When the floating gate 14 is fully programmed the channel region 19 is in the fully “off”, or low conductivity state.

[0044] FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a prior art conventional single-bit EANVM memory system 30. The memory system 30 stores a single bit of information in an EANVM cell 32. The cell 32, as described in FIG. 1, is selected for reading or writing when a row, or word, select signal is applied to a control gate terminal 34. A source terminal 36 for the FET of the cell 32 is connected to a reference ground potential. A drain terminal 38 is connected through a: pull-up device 39 to a voltage Vpull-up at a terminal 40. Terminal 38 serves as the output terminal of the cell 32. When the cell 32 stores a “1” bit, the channel of the FET is in a low conductivity, or high impedance, state so that the voltage at terminal 38 is pulled-up to the voltage level Vpull-up on terminal 40. When the cell 32 stores a “1” bit, the channel of the FET is in a high conductivity, or low impedance, state so that the voltage at terminal 38 is pulled-down by the ground potential at terminal 36.

[0045] For reading the value of the single-bit stored in the cell 32, a sense amplifier 42 compares the voltage at terminal 38 with a reference voltage Vref at terminal 43. If a “O” is stored on the EANVM cell 32, the cell will be in a low conductivity state and as a result the voltage at terminal 38 is above the reference voltage at terminal 43. For a “O” stored in the cell 32, the output terminal 44 of the sense amplifier 42 will be a low voltage which will be transmitted through an output buffer 46 to a terminal 48 and then coupled to the I/O terminal 50 as a logical “0”. If a “1” is stored on the EANVM cell 32, the cell is in a high conductivity state and as a result the voltage at terminal 38 is below the reference voltage at terminal 43. The output of the sense amplifier 42 will be a high voltage which will be transmitted to the I/O terminal 50 as a logical “1”.

[0046] For writing the value of an information bit stored in the cell 32, it is assumed that the cell 32 is in the erased, or fully “on”, state which corresponds to a logical A “1”. The I/O terminal 50 is connected to the input terminal of an input latch/buffer 52. The output of the input latch/buffer 52 is connected to an enable/disable terminal 54 of a program voltage switch 56. The program voltage switch 56 provides a bit-line program voltage on a signal line 58 connected to terminal 38. Another output from the program voltage switch 56 is the word line program voltage on a signal line 62, which is connected to the control gate 34 of the EANVM cell 32. When a logical “O” is present bat terminal 54 of the program voltage switch 56 from the output of Input Latch/Buffer 52 and when the program voltage switch 56 is activated by a program pulse on a signal line 62 from a, program pulse 66, activated by a PGM/Write signal, the program voltage switch 56 provides the Program Voltage Vpp from a terminal 68 to the control gate 34 of the EANVM cell 32. The program voltage switch 56 also biases the drain of the EANVM cell 32 to a voltage, typically between 8 to 9 volts, and the gate of the EANVM cell 32 to the program voltage Vpp, typically 12 volts. Under these conditions, electrons are injected onto the floating gate by a phenomenon known as hot electron injection. This programming procedure raises the voltage threshold of the EANVM cell which increases its source-drain impedance.. This continues until the FET memory cell 32 is effectively turned off, which corresponds to a “O” state. When a “1” is present on terminal 54 from the output of the Input Latch/Buffer 52 and when the PGM/Write is enabled, the signal line 58 is driven low and programming is inhibited and the “1”, or erased, state is maintained.

[0047] FIG. 3 is a timing diagram of a prior-art single-bit EANVM cell 32, as described in connection with FIG. 2. The timing diagram shows the change in voltage threshold of the EANVM cell 32, as controlled by the word line and bit line programming voltages, which are illustratively shown as a single signal and which are both controlled by the PGM/Write signal. The memory cell is being programmed from the fully erased “1” state to the fully programmed “0” state. For the duration of the PGM/Write pulse, the bit and word line program voltages, which need not be the same, are respectively applied to the source connected to the bit line 38 and to the control gate 34 of the memory cell 32. As electrons are injected onto the floating gate, the voltage threshold of the memory cell begins to increase. Once the voltage threshold has been increased beyond a specific threshold value as indicated by the dashed horizontal line, the memory cell 32 is programmed to “O” state.

[0048] Note that Fowler-Nordheim tunnelling can also be used instead of hot electron injection to place electrons on the floating gate. The multi-bit EANVM device described here functions with either memory cell programming technique. The prior art programming algorithms and circuits for either type of programming are designed to program a single-bit cell with as much margin as possible in as short a time as possible. For a single-bit memory cell, margin is defined as the additional voltage threshold needed to insure that the programmed cell will retain its stored value over time.

[0049] FIG. 4 is a timing diagram showing the bit line voltage at terminal 38 as a function of time during a memory read operation. In this example, prior to time t1 the bit line is charged to the Vpull-up condition. Note that it is also possible that the bit line may start at any other voltage level prior to time t1. At time t1, the EANVM cell 32 is selected and, if the cell 32 is in the erased or tilt state, the cell 32 provides a low impedance path to ground. As-a result, the bit line is pulled-down to near the ground potential provided at terminal 36 in FIG. 2. If the EANVM cell 32 were in the “0” or fully programmed state, the bit line voltage would remain at the Vpull-up voltage after time t1. The voltage on the bit-line terminal 38 and the reference voltage Vref at terminal 43 are compared by the comparator 42, whose buffered output drives I/O terminal 50. When Vref is greater than the bit line voltage, the output on I/O terminal 50 is a logical “0”. When Vref is lower than the bit line voltage, the output on I/O terminal 50 is a logical “0”.

[0050] II. MEMORY ARRAY FOR A MULTI-BIT EANVM SYSTEM

[0051] FIG. 5 is a block diagram of a multi-bit per cell EANVM system 100 which includes an M×N array of memory cells. The cells are typically shown as a floating gate FET, or EANVM, 102, as described in FIG. 1. The array uses similar addressing techniques, external control signals, and I/O circuits as are used with currently available single bit per cell EANVM devices such as EPROM, EEPROM, FLASH, etc. devices. Row Address signals are provided at input terminals 103A and Column Address signals are provided at input terminals 103B.

[0052] Each of the EANVM cells in a row of cells has its source connected to a ground reference potential and its drain connected to a column bit line, typically shown as 106. Each of the columns is connected to a pull-up device, as indicated by the block 105. All of the control gates of a row are connected to a row select, or word, line, typically shown as 104. Rows are selected with a row select circuit 108 and columns are selected with a column select circuit 110. Sense amplifiers 112 are provided for each of the selected columns. Decode/encode circuits 114 and n-bit input/output latches/buffers 116 are also provided. A PGM/Write signal is provided at an input terminal 118 for activating a mode control circuit 120 and a timing circuit 122.

[0053] A significant feature of this n-bit per cell system 100 as compared to a single-bit per cell implementation is that the memory density is, increased by a factor of n, where n is the number of bits which can be stored on an individual multi-bit memory cell.

[0054] III. BASIC READ MODE OF AN N-BIT MEMORY CELL

[0055] FIG. 6 shows a binary system 150 for reading the state of an n-bit floating gate memory cell 102, as described in FIG. 1, according to the invention, where n is the number of bits stored in the memory cell. For this example, n is set to 2 and one of four states of the memory cell must be detected. The four possible states being, (0,0), (0,1), (1,0), or (1,1). Detecting which state is programmed requires a 4-level sense amplifier 152. This amplifier includes three sense amplifiers 154, 156, 158 each of which have their negative input terminals connected to the output terminal 106 of the memory cell 102. Sense amplifier 154 has a reference voltage Ref 3 connected to its positive input terminal. Sense amplifier 156 has a reference voltage Ref 2 connected to its positive input terminal. Sense amplifier 158 has a reference voltage Ref 1 connected to its positive input terminal. The voltage references are set such as follows: Vpull-up>Ref 3>Ref 2>Ref 1. The respective output signals S3, S2, S1 of the three sense amplifiers drive an encode logic circuit 160, which encodes the sensed signals S3, S2, S1 into an appropriate 2-bit data format. Bit 0 is provided at an I/O terminal 162 and Bit 1 is provided at an I/O terminal 164. A truth table for the-encode logic circuit 160 is as follows: 1 S3 S2 S1 I/O 1 I/O 0 State L L L 0 0 (0,0) H L L 1 0 (1,0) H H L 0 1 (0,1) H H H 1 1 (1,1)

[0056] During a read operation of an n-bit memory cell, the levels of the respective output signals S3, S2, S1 of the sense amplifiers 154, 156, 158 are determined by the conductivity value to which the memory cell had been set during a programming operation. A fully erased EANVM cell 102 will be in its lowest threshold voltage state, or the highest conductivity state. Consequently, all of the reference Voltages will be higher in voltage than the bit line voltage at terminal 106, resulting in a (1,1) state. A fully programmed EANVM cell 102 will be in its highest threshold voltage state, or its lowest conductivity state. Consequently, all reference voltages will be lower in voltage than the bit line voltage at terminal 106, resulting in a (0,0) state. The intermediate threshold states are encoded as is illustrated in the truth table for the logic circuit 160. FIG. 7 shows the bit line voltage as a function of time at terminal 106, during a read cycle,.for a binary 2-bit per memory cell. For purposes of illustration, each of the four possible waveforms corresponding to the four possible programmed states of the memory cell are shown. During a read cycle only the waveform corresponding to the programmed state of the EANVM cell would occur. For example, 25 assume the EANVM memory cell 102 has been programmed to a (1,0) state. Prior to time t1, because the EANVM cell 102 has not yet been selected or activated, the bit line 106 is pulled-up to Vpull-up. At time t1, 22 the EANVM cell is selected using conventional memory address decoding techniques. Because the EANVM cell has been programmed to a specific conductivity level by the charge on the floating gate, the bit line is pulled down to a specific voltage level corresponding to the amount of current that the cell can sink at this specific conductivity level. When this point is reached at time t2 the fit line voltage stabilizes at a voltage level Vref2 between reference voltages Ref 3 and Ref 2 which correspond to a (1,0) state. When the EANVM cell 102 is de-selected, the bit line voltage will return to its pulled-up condition. Similarly, the bit-line voltage stabilizes at Vref1 for the 0,1 state for the other specific conductivity levels, or at zero volts for the 1,1 state. FIG. 8 is a block diagram of an n-bit memory cell system 200. For purposes of illustration a binary 2-20 bit per cell system is shown. However, it is intended that the concepts of the invention extend to systems where n is greater than 2. It is also intended that the invention include any system where the EANVM memory cell has more than two states. For example, in a non-binary system, the memory states can be three or some other multiple of a non-binary system. Some of the components of this system 200 are shown and described with the same reference numerals for the components of FIG. 6 for the read mode of operation. It is intended that these same reference numerals identify the same components.; The system 200 includes a memory cell 102, as described in FIG. 1, with a bit line output terminal 106. For the read mode of operation, a 4-level sense amplifier 152 with read reference voltages Ref 1, Ref 2, and Ref 3 and an encoder 160 is provided. Read data is provided at a Bit I/O terminal 162 and at a Bit I 1/0 terminal 164. For the write mode of operation, a verify reference voltage select circuit 222 provides an analog voltage reference level signal X to one input terminal of the analog comparator 202. The verify reference voltages are chosen so that as soon as the bit line voltage on bit line 106 is greater than the verify reference voltage the threshold of the EANVM cell 102 is set to the proper threshold corresponding to the memory state to which it is to be programmed. To this end the verify reference voltages Vref1, Vref2, Vref3, and Vref4 are set such that Vref4 is above Ref 3, Vref3 is between Ref 3 and Ref 2, Vref2 is between Ref 1 and Ref 2, and Vref1 is below Ref 1. During a normal read operation, the bit line voltage will settle midway between the read reference voltages to insure that the memory contents will be read accurately. The verify reference voltage select circuit 222 is controlled by the 2-output bits from a 2-bit input latch/buffer circuit 224, which receives binary input bits from the I/O terminals 162 and 164. The Y signal input terminal of the analog comparator 5202 is connected to the bit line output terminal 106 of the multi-level memory cell 102. The output signal from the analog comparator is provided on a signal line 204 as an enable/disable signal for the program voltage switch 220. An output signal line 206 from the program voltage switch 220 provides the word line program voltage to the control gate of the EANVM cell 102. Another output signal line 206 provides the bit-line programming voltage to the bit-line terminal 106 of EANVM cell 102. After the program/verify timing circuit 208 is enabled by a PGM/Write signal provided on signal line 212 from a PGM/Write terminal 214, the timing circuit 208 provides a series of program/verify timing pulses to the program voltage switch 220 on a signal line 210. The pulse widths are set to control the programming process so that the voltage threshold of the EANVM cell 102 is incrementally altered by controlling the injection of charge onto the floating gate of the EANVM cell. Each programming cycle increases the voltage threshold and, as a result, decreases the conductance of the memory cell 102. After each internal program cycle is complete, as indicated by signal line 210 going “high”, the program voltages are removed via the Program Voltage Switch 220 and a verify cycle begins. The voltage threshold of memory cell 102 is then determined by using the comparator 202 to compare the bit line voltage at terminal 106 with the selected verify reference voltage from the verify reference voltage select circuit 222. When the bit line voltage exceeds that supplied by the verify reference voltage select circuit 222, the output signal 204 from the comparator 202 will then disable the program voltage switch 220 ending the programming cycle. For this embodiment of the invention, during a write operation, comparison of the current memory cell analog contents with the analog information to be programmed on the memory cell 102 is performed by the analog comparator 202. The verify reference voltage select circuit 222 analog output voltage X is determined by decoding the output of the n-bit input latch/buffer 224. The Y input signal to the analog comparator 202 is taken directly from the bit line terminal 106. Note that the 4-level sense/encode circuits 152, 160, and reference voltage select circuit 222 may be completely independent, as indicated in the drawing. Alternatively, they may be coupled together to alternately time share common circuit components. This is possible because the 4-level sense/encode circuits 152 and 160 are used in the read mode of operation while the verify reference voltage select circuit 222 is used only in the write/verify mode of operation.

[0057] IV. BASIC WRITE MODE FOR A MULTI-BIT PER CELL EANVM SYSTEM

[0058] In the write mode, a binary n-bit per cell EANVM system must be capable of electrically programming a memory cell to 2n uniquely different threshold levels. In the two-bit per cell implementation, because it is assumed that the cell starts from the erased (1,1) state, it is only necessary to program three different thresholds (Vt1, Vt2, and Vt3) which define the (0,1), (1,0), and (0,0) states. Vt1 is the threshold required such that in the read mode, the bit line voltage will fall between Ref1 and Ref2. Vt2 is the threshold required such that in the read mode, the bit line voltage will fall between Ref 2 and Ref 3. Vt3 is the threshold required such that in the read mode, the bit line voltage will be greater than Ref 3.

[0059] FIG. 9 illustrates the change in voltage threshold for a 4-level, or 2-bit EANVM cell as the floating gate is being charged from an erased (1,1) threshold state to any one of the three other possible states. In prior art single-bit memory cells where there are only two states, the design objective is to provide enough charge to the floating gate to insure that the cell's voltage threshold is programmed as high as possible, as shown in FIG. 3. Because there is no upper threshold limit in a single-bit per cell system, overprogramming the cell will not cause incorrect data to be stored on the memory cell.

[0060] As illustrated by FIG. 9, in an n-bit per cell system the memory cell must be charged to a point so that the voltage threshold is within a specific voltage threshold ranges In this example, where the cell is being programmed to a (1,0) state, the proper threshold range is defined as being above a threshold level Vt2 and as being below a threshold level Vt3.

[0061] To accomplish this n-level programming it is necessary to add to or modify the prior art EANVM circuitry. FIG. 8 shows the additional or modified circuits, including a reference voltage select, an n-bit latch/buffer, a program/verify timing circuit, and a comparator. The comparator can be either digital or analog.

[0062] FIG. 10 illustrates the voltage threshold of an EANVM cell as the floating gate is being erased from a (0,0) state. Standard EANVM programming operating procedure calls for a memory cell to be erased prior to being programmed. This erasure can be performed at the byte, block, or chip level and can be performed by electrical, UV, or other means. In this type of system the cell would be completely erased to a (1,1) state prior to initiating a programming cycle. If a system has the capability to erase an individual memory cell, then it is not necessary to erase all of the cells of a group prior to initiating a programming operation. It is then possible to incrementally erase an individual memory cell, as necessary, to program the cell to the appropriate voltage threshold as is indicated by the waveforms labelled (1,0) and (0,1).

[0063] FIG. 11 is a timing diagram which illustrates how a 2-bit EANVM cell of FIG. 8 is programmed from an erased (1,1) state to a (1,0) state using the timing circuitry 208 to generate fixed length timing pulses. A low logic level state of the PGM/Write signal on signal line 212 enables the timing circuit 208. When enabled at time t1, the timing circuit 208 provides an internal fixed-width low level internal PGM timing pulse on signal line 210 to the program voltage switch 220. For the duration of the low state of the internal PGM timing pulse, the bit line and word line program voltage outputs on lines 216 and 206 will be raised to their respective programming voltage levels as shown in FIG. 11. During this programming process, charge is added to the floating gate of the memory cell 102. When the internal PGM timing pulse from timing circuitry 208 switches to a high level, the programming voltages are removed and a verify cycle begins. For this example, verify reference voltage Vref3 is compared with the bit line voltage. This internally controlled program/verify cycle repeats itself until the bit line voltage on terminal 106 exceeds Vref3. At this time, t2, the EANVM cef1 102 is verified to have been programmed to a (1,0) state and programming is halted by the comparator 222 providing a disable signal on signal line 204 to the program voltage switch 220.

[0064] FIG. 12 illustrates the bit line voltage of a 2-bit per cell EANVM as it is being programmed from a fully erased, or fully “on”, state (1,1) to a partially “off” state (1,0) using fixed length program pulses. When the externally applied PGM/Write pulse is applied at time t1, the program/verify timing circuit 208 first initiates a verify cycle to determine the current status of the memory cell 102. This is indicated by the bit line voltage being pulled to a ground condition from, in this example, Vpull-up. Although, prior to time t1, the bit line voltage could be pre-set to any voltage level. Once the cell has been determined to be at a condition below the verify reference voltage, Vref3 in this example, corresponding to the data to be programmed, the first program cycle is initiated. This is represented by the bit line voltage being pulled up to Vprogram. After the first fixed length programming pulse ends, a verify cycle begins. This is represented by the bit line voltage being pulled down to a point midway between ground potential and Ref1. During each successive verify cycle the bit line voltage is observed to incrementally increase. This program/verify cycle continues until the bit-line voltage exceeds the selected verify reference voltage, in this case Vref3, which indicates a memory state of (1,0), at time t2.

[0065] FIG. 13 illustrates how a 2-bit EANVM cell is programmed from an erased (1,1) state to a (1,0) state using variable length programming pulses. The internal PGM pulses for this Implementation start with a low state longer than for fixed-width implementation of FIGS. 11 and 12. The low-state pulse widths grow progressively shorter as the memory cell approaches the appropriate voltage threshold. This approach requires more precise control than the fixed length approach. However, programming times can be greatly reduced on average.

[0066] FIG. 14 illustrates the bit line voltage of a 2-bit per cell EANVM as it is being programmed from a fully erased, or fully “on”, state (1,1) to a partially “off” state (1,0) using variable length program pulses. When the externally applied PGM/Write pulse goes to an active low level at time ti, the program/verify timing circuit 208 first initiates a verify cycle to determine the current status of the memory cell 102. This is indicated by the bit line voltage being pulled to a ground condition from, in this example, Vpull-up. Although, prior to time t1, the bit line voltage could be pre-set to any voltage level. Once the cell has been determined to be at a condition below the verify reference voltage corresponding to the data to be programmed, Vref3 in this example, the first program cycle is initiated. This is represented by the bit line voltage being pulled up to Vprogram. After the first variable length programming pulse is over, another verify cycle begins. This is represented by the bit line voltage being pulled down to a point midway between Ref1 and Ref2. During each successive verify cycle the bit line voltage is observed to incrementally increase. This program/verify cycle continues until the bit-line-voltage surpasses the selected verify reference voltage, in this case vref3 which indicates a memory state of (1,0), at time t2.

[0067] Accordingly, the programming process for an n-bit per cell EANVM uses program/verify cycles, to incrementally program a cell. The duration of these cycles are determined by the timing circuit 208. A key element of the system is to provide a programming scheme which provides for accurate programming of the memory cell 102. This is accomplished by matching the pulse widths of the timing pulses of the timing circuitry 208 to the program time of the EANVM cell being used. As indicated in FIGS. 11 and 13, a desired voltage threshold actually falls within a range of threshold voltages. If the program pulses are too long, then too much charge may be added to the floating gate of the memory cell 102. This may result in an overshoot of the target voltage threshold, resulting in incorrect data being stored in the memory cell.

[0068] The programming pulse width is set such that if the voltage threshold of the cell 102 after the (n−1) programming pulse is at a point just below the target voltage threshold, then the (n)th, or final, program pulse will not cause an overshoot resulting in an overprogrammed condition for a memory cell.

[0069] FIG. 8 may also use a digital comparator rather than the analog comparator 202 shown in FIG. 8. The digital comparator would use the encoded data from the encode circuitry 160 as the input to the comparator represent the current contents of the EANVM cell 102. The verify reference voltage select 222 would provide the voltage to be encoded with the input coming from the output of the n-bit input latch/buffer 224, representing the data to be programmed. Otherwise, the function of the comparator within the system remains the same.

[0070] V. EMBODIMENTS TO ESTABLISH REFERENCE VOLTAGES

[0071] A multi-level (or multi-bit) memory device which contains more than one bit of information per memory cell needs accurate and stable reference voltages. The reference voltages allow a multi-level memory cell to be correctly read over various process, voltage, and temperature ranges. The reference voltages must be implemented into the integrated circuit which can accurately sense the multi-level voltage levels of the memory cells as well as track each memory array voltage level as it drifts with the process, voltage, and temperature variations. An unstable or inaccurate reference voltage tends to cause problems such as an improper voltage level read of a bit line, and the like from a memory cell.

[0072] In a 2-bit per memory cell embodiment, the memory cell includes four voltage levels V0, V1, V2, and V3 at each of the bit lines as illustrated by FIG. 15. To uniquely detect each of the four voltage levels, it is necessary to generate at least three reference voltages, each of the reference voltages falling between memory bit line voltage levels. When V0, V1, V2, and V3 represent the four bit line voltage levels, the reference voltages VREF0, VREF1, AND VREF2 fall between V0 and V1, V1 and V2, and V2 and V3, respectively. Preferably, the reference voltages VREF0, VREF1, and VREF2 fall halfway between V0 and V1, V1 and V2, and V2 and V3, respectively. Each reference voltage is also set to provide a clear and accurate reference level, which can be used as a reference for the bit line voltage.

[0073] In a specific embodiment, a method for establishing reference voltages for a non-volatile multi-bit memory array is provided. Merely by way of example, the present method is applied to the manufacture of a non-volatile multi-bit memory array such as a masked ROM array, an EANVM memory array, and the like. The present method calls for reference voltage sources and in particular reference voltage lines and cells which are fabricated simultaneously with the standard memory cell array. Alternatively, the present method may call for reference voltage sources and in particular reference voltage lines and cells which are fabricated by way of the same method (but at a different step) as the standard memory cell array. By way of the present method, stable reference voltages are established which track bit line voltages in memory cells through voltage, temperature, and process variations.

[0074] In a masked ROM embodiment, for example, the present method calls for reference voltages to be generated using memory cells which have been programmed in the same fashion and preferably in exactly the same fashion as the cells in the standard memory array itself. In the present masked ROM embodiment whose memory cells are programmed using a Vt implant, the memory cells within the reference voltage generator circuit will be implanted at the same time with preferably the same implant dosage as the ROM cells within the standard memory array. This means the implant dosage of the reference voltage cell is substantially the same as the memory cell for the bit line in the standard memory array. The reference voltage level is also substantially the same as the bit line voltage level, that is, assuming the same voltage is applied to both the reference voltage cell and the bit line cell. As show in FIG. 16 for example, memory cells within the reference voltage generator circuit include field effect transistors 1103, 1104, 1105, 1106, 1107, and 1108. A ROM cell in a memory array may include transistor 1102 Coupled to a bit line.

[0075] In the present embodiment, the reference voltage is moved to a voltage point away from the bit line voltage. This allows the multi-bit memory device to sense the relative voltage difference between the bit line and the reference voltage line, and then decode the programmed cell accordingly. By way of the same implant step, the reference voltage tracks the bit line voltage over process, voltage, and temperature variations, and is therefore stable.

[0076] In the present invention, a selected voltage difference exists between the voltage reference levels and memory bit line voltage levels such that they do not interfere with each other. The voltage reference and sensing circuitry are able to detect a single unique voltage level out of four possible levels, in a 2-bit per memory cell configuration for example. Referring to FIG. 15, if VREF0 was inadvertently raised to the level of VREF1, a non-programmed memory state of (1,1) is easy read. Unfortunately, if the memory cell was programmed to an intermediate state of (1,0), the relation between VREF0 to VREF1 makes it difficult to differentiate between the two levels. As a result, the output is often unreliable and the like. Accordingly, the present invention relies upon either a voltage divider arrangement, a pull-up device arrangement, or the like, and combinations thereof to create desired reference voltage levels. Although the present invention is described in the masked ROM embodiment, the present invention may also be applied to any multi-bit memory array such as an EANVM memory array, and the like.

[0077] FIG. 16 is a simplified reference voltage generator circuit in a voltage divider arrangement 1200 for generating multiple reference voltages according to the present invention. In a 2-bit per cell embodiment, a multi-level memory cell includes at least four bit line voltage levels V0, V2, V3, and V4. Each of the four bit line voltage levels is detected by way of three reference voltage levels, each of which falls between two adjacent bit line voltage levels. The voltage divider arrangement includes a VREF0 column 1204, a VREF1 column 1206, and a VREF2 column 1208. Each column includes at least a pull-up voltage VPULLUP. A bit line column 1202 is also shown for illustrative purposes. The bit line column is a portion of the standard memory cell array. As noted above, the bit line produces a voltage at either V0, V1, V2, or V3, depending upon the particular application. A plurality of rows 1212, 1214 (or SELECT lines) are also shown. The SELECT line 1212 includes a plurality of field effect transistors 1109, and the SELECT line 1214 includes a plurality of field effect transistors 1101. Each of the columns also includes a WORD line 1216 operably coupled to each column through field effect transistors 1102, 1103, 1104, 1106, 1107, and 1108. The field effect transistors 1102, 1103, 1104, 1106, 1107, and 1108 include a source/drain region at V, V0, V1, V1, V2, V2, V3, respectively. The field effect transistors may include an NMOS device, a PMos device, and the like.

[0078] As shown, each pair V0 and V1, V1 and V2, and V2 and V3 connect together with a voltage divider arrangement to generate intermediate reference voltages VREF0, VREF1, and VREF2, respectively. By way of the field effect transistors 1103, 1104, and application of voltage at the WORD line and the SELECT line 1212, the reference voltage VREF0 is at a voltage-level between about V0 and about V1. By way of application of voltage at the WORD line and SELECT line 1212, the reference voltage VREF1 is between about V1 and about V2. Similarly, by way of application of voltage at the WORD line and the SELECT line 1212, the reference voltage VREF2 is between about V2 and about V3.

[0079] FIG. 17 illustrates the reference voltage levels of for example FIG. 16 according to the present invention. The voltage divider arrangement defines the reference voltages as follows:

VREF0=(V0+V1)/2

VREF1=(V1+V2)/2

VREF2=(V2+V3)/2

[0080] The reference voltages VREF0, VREF1, and VREF2 fall between V0 and V1, V1 and V2, and V2 and V3, respectively. Accordingly, the present multi-bit memory device provides reference voltages which do not overlap with the bit line voltages. In addition, the references voltages VREF0, VREF1, and VREF2 track well with the memory bit lines over process, voltage, and temperature variations. Preferably, each of the reference voltages fall exactly halfway between adjacent bit line voltage levels.

[0081] FIG. 18 is a simplified voltage generator circuit diagram 1400 of an array showing reference voltage columns connected to pull-up devices according to the present invention. Each of the pull-up devices is a field effect transistor such as an NMOS device, a PMOS device, and the like. Preferably, the pull-up device is a PMOS device. A bit line column 2002 is also shown for illustrative purposes. The bit line column is a portion of the standard memory cell array. As noted above, the bit line produces a voltage at either V0, V1, V2, or V3, depending upon the particular application. The bit line also includes a field effect transistor 1102 and a word line 2016 operably coupled to the field effect transistor.

[0082] The voltage generator circuit includes a plurality of reference voltage column lines 2004, 2006, 2008, each at the same voltage level on one end VPULLUP, a plurality of field effect transistors 1101, 1109, and a reference voltage at the other end VREF0, VREF1, and VREF2. Between field effect transistors 1101, 1109 are cells which include field effect transistors 1103, 1105, and 1107. The field effect transistors 1103, 1105, and 1107 include source/drain-regions coupled to V0, V1, and V2, and source/drain regions coupled to column lines 2004, 2006, and 2008, respectively. A WORD line connects in parallel to each of the field effect transistor (1103, 1105, and 1107) gates. A plurality of SELECT lines 2012, 2014 connect to the transistor (1109, 1101) gates. The bit line and reference voltage lines include pull-up devices 1110, 1111, 1112, and 1113, respectively. The pull-up devices create the reference voltage levels and memory bit line voltage level for sensing multi-levels on the memory bit line.

[0083] The pull-up devices are defined on the reference voltage lines. A pull-up device is also defined on the bit lines in the memory array. The desired reference voltages VREF0, VREF1, and VREF2 can be made by modifying the size and/or number of pull-ups such as field effect transistors and the like. The reference voltages are preferably at voltage levels corresponding to ones illustrated by FIG. 16 for example. Preferably, the pull-ups are added at the point where reference signals (corresponding to reference voltages) feed directly into a sense amplifier circuit, and not on each bit line. Determining the appropriate pull-up device size can occur on a trial and error basis during the course of circuit simulation. Other types of pull-up devices or circuitry such as capacitor and resistor combinations, and the like may also be used. Of course, the type of pull-up device and its configuration depend upon the particular application.

[0084] The embodiment of FIG. 18 generally provides a wider voltage range, than the embodiment of FIG. 17. The circuit for each reference voltage is no longer substantially dependent upon a maximum voltage range on the bit line. The effective voltage range can be scaled up across a wider range through use of selected pull-up devices. This-provides-for a greater margin of manufacture by the wider range between the voltages. The increased voltage range insures that an adequate signal is available to sense the difference between the memory bit line voltage and that of the reference voltage. As previously noted, the pull-up device is preferably a PMOS device and the like.

[0085] FIG. 19 is a simplified voltage generator circuit diagram 1600 for obtaining reference voltages with use of pull-up devices and a voltage divider according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention. A bit line column 1602 is also shown for illustrative purposes. The bit line column is a portion of the standard memory cell array. As noted above, the bit line produces a voltage at either V0, V1, V2, or V3, depending upon the particular application. The bit line also includes a field effect transistor 1102 and a word line 1616 operably coupled to the field effect transistor.

[0086] The voltage generator circuit diagram includes a plurality of reference voltage columns 1111, 1112, 1113, a plurality of field effect transistors 1612, 1614 coupled to SELECT lines, and a plurality of field effect transistors 1103, 1104, 1105, 1106, 1107, 1108 in each cell coupled to a WORD line 1616. Also shown are a plurality of pull-up devices 1111, 1112, and 1113 for a VREF0 line 1604, a VREF1 line 1606, and a VREF2 line 1608, respectively. The embodiment provides for a voltage divider arrangement such that each reference voltage tracks the bit line voltage in variations to process, temperature, voltage, and the like. In addition, the embodiment provides for each of the reference voltages VREF0, VREF1, and VREF2 to be conditioned by way of respective pull-up devices. A pull-up device 1110 may also condition the voltage at the bit line 1602.

[0087] FIG. 20 illustrates a simplified reference voltage generator circuit diagram 2000 according to the present invention. A bit line 2009 with four memory cells 2001, 2003, 2005, and 2007, each of which is programmed to one of four different threshold voltages (V0, V1, V2, V3) representing the possible states in a two bit per cell memory array is shown for illustrative purposes. The bit line is operable coupled through field effect transistors in the memory cells 2001, 2003, 2005, and 2007. The bit line also includes a select line, and word lines 0, 1, 2, and 3.

[0088] The reference voltage generator circuit includes reference voltage lines 2013, 2015, and 2017, for VREF0, VREF1, and VREF2, respectively. The reference voltage generator circuit includes cells 2019 which define a reference voltage array 2021. The reference voltage array includes bit lines 2023 (or reference voltage lines 2013, 2015, and 2017) which were preferably identical in fabrication to the bit lines such as the bit line 2009 in the memory array. For example, the bit lines 2023 in the reference voltage array and the memory array are made by way of the same (or similar) processing steps.

[0089] The cells 2019 in the reference voltage array are programmed to one of four possible voltage thresholds V0, V1, V2, and V3. Optionally, the bit line in the references voltage array which contains cells programmed to the highest threshold voltage V3 may be omitted, as cells programmed to a voltage threshold higher than the voltage on the word line will effectively be an open circuit. This memory bit line in the reference voltage array may be replaced by a voltage source, typically representing the highest voltage potential used in the particular integrated circuit.

[0090] In the present embodiment, the cell (or cells 2001, 2003, 2005, and 2007) in the memory array is programmed by way of a selected threshold voltage such as V0 and the like. All of the cells in the reference voltage array using the same threshold voltage is preferably programmed at the same time (or the same method) as the cell (or cells) in the memory array. For example, a cell(s) 2001 at a threshold voltage of V0 in the memory array is programmed by way of implant or the like at the same step as the cells 2025 at a threshold voltage of V0 in the reference voltage array. The cell(s) 2003 at a threshold voltage of V1 in the memory array is programmed by way of implant or the like at the same step as the cells 2027 at a threshold voltage of V1 in the reference voltage array. The cell(s) 2005 at a threshold voltage of V2 in the memory array is programmed by way of implant or the like at the same step as the cells 2029 at a threshold voltage of V2 in the reference voltage array. Other threshold voltages 2007 may be programmed into the cells by way of similar programming techniques and the like. The selected programming technique may include a single threshold voltage implant or multiple threshold voltage implants corresponding to a series programming steps. An example of such programming step-can be any suitable technique known in the art.

[0091] The foregoing descriptions of specific embodiments of the present invention have been presented for purposes of illustration and description. They are not intended to be exhaustive or to limit the invention to the precise forms disclosed, and obviously many modifications and variations are possible in light of the above teaching. The embodiments were chosen and described in order to best explain the principles of the invention and its practical application, to thereby enable others skilled in the art to best utilize the invention and various embodiments with various modifications as are suited to the particular use contemplated. It is intended that the scope of the invention be defined by the Claims appended hereto and their equivalents.

Claims

1. For an electrically alterable non-volatile multi-level memory device including a plurality of non-volatile multi-level memory cells, each of the multi-level memory cells including a floating gate FET having a channel with electrically alterable voltage threshold value, electrons being capable of being injected into the floating gate, a method of operating the electrically alterable non-volatile multi-level memory device, comprising:

settling a voltage threshold value of at least one non-volatile multi-level memory cell of the plurality of non-volatile multi-level memory cells to one state selected from a plurality of states including at least a first state, a second state, a third state and a fourth state in response to information to be stored in the one non-volatile multi-level memory cell, and

reading status of the one non-volatile multi-level memory cell from an output from a bit line coupled to a drain terminal of the one non-volatile multi-level memory cell,

wherein the operation for settling the voltage threshold value of the one non-volatile multi-level memory cell includes a program operation, in which electrons are injected into the floating gate of the one non-volatile multi-level memory cell by applying at least one programing pulse supplied to the bit line, and

wherein the program operation of the one non-volatile multi-level memory cell is carried out by a plurality of programming pulses, the plurality of programming pulses includes at least a first programming pulse and a second programming pulse after the first programming pulse, the first programming pulse has a first electric parameter and the second programming pulse has a second electric parameter so that a first voltage threshold value change of the one non-volatile multi-level memory cell between after applying the first programming pulse and before applying the first programming pulse is substantially larger than a second voltage threshold value change of the one non-volatile multi-level memory cell between after applying the second programming pulse and before applying the second programming pulse.