Method for leakage measurement
A method of high sensitivity for measuring leakage of liquid from a storage tank which comprises introducing a sensor into the liquid in the tank, the sensor being coupled to means for sensing displacement of mass, measuring the displacement over a known period of time and calculating the leakage rate. The sensor is designed to compensate for evaporative losses and temperature changes.
This invention relates to a highly sensitive method to determine the rate of leakage of liquid from a storage tank and is particularly directed to determining the leakage and rate of leakage of fuel hydrocarbons in installed underground storage tanks. Leakage into and out of the tank can be determined by the method of the invention.
There are thousands of underground storage tanks at the numerous fuel service stations throughout the world and over a period of time leaks inevitably occur causing fuel hydrocarbons such as gasoline, diesel oil and the like to flow into the ground. Such leaks are, of course, environmental hazards since they could lead to ground water contamination. Also, the leaking fluid can gather in buildings and result in hazardous and toxic hydrocarbon vaporization in the confined air space. Leaks into storage tanks also occur, most often water, which contaminates the tank contents. Thus, it is essential that such leaks be determined as soon as possible so that corrective measures can be taken. In order that early detection can be made it is essential that the detection method be extremely sensitive (in the range of 0.05 gal. per hour) so as to determine very slight leakage in a relatively short period of time. This is necessary for several reasons including the time value of the test itself, the need to remove the storage tank from dispensing operations for a minimum amount of time, and the like. Heretofore no such suitable method has been available.
It is known in the art to measure the mass of liquid in a storage tank by use of Archimedes Buoyancy Principle using a float in the liquid. However, none of the devices or methods known are adaptable to a highly sensitive, rapid method for leak determination in difficulty accessable storage tanks (e.g. already installed underground tanks). For example, U.S. Pat. No. 967,378 discloses a storage tank fitted with a hydrometer-type weighing device to estimate the weight of liquids stored in the tank. U.S. Pat. No. 988,342 shows a similar device fitted to the storage tank, but where the scale is on the ground for easy access.
In the method of the present invention a sensor of appropriate design is inserted into the storage tank through the fillpipe or other access hole and is coupled to a sensing device to measure mass displacement over a period of time. As will be further explained, the preferred sensor design is such as to compensate for changes due to vaporization of the liquid and changes occuring in density and the level of the liquid due to temperature variations. The sensing device is calibrated to determine the amount of liquid per unit of change and after a short period of time, usually only several minutes, the change in mass displacement due to the leak is noted. In this way the rate of liquid loss can be determined by simple calculation.
Reference is now made to the drawings:
FIG. 1 is a broad overall view of an underground hydrocarbon storage tank with the sensor and detector device in position.
FIG. 2 is a detailed view of the detector system.
FIGS. 3 and 4 are detailed views of preferred sensors.
FIG. 4a shows the quick release mechanism of FIG. 4 in the open position.
FIGS. 5 and 6 show the insertion of a preferred sensor into a tank.
FIGS. 7 and 8 show the removal of a preferred sensor from the tank.
FIG. 1 shows an underground filled hydrocarbon storage tank 11 with the sensor 12 in position in the liquid. The top of the sensor is above the liquid level and the bottom of the sensor is within about 1 to 2 inches from the bottom of the tank. The sensor has a cap 13 and also a cup portion 14 (detailed in FIG. 3) to which supports of wire or string 15 are attached which, in turn, are connected to line 16 which supports the sensor from the weighing arm 17 of a balance shown generally as 18. A coupler 22 may be used for convenience in connecting line 16 to the balance arms. Any change in mass in the tank will result in a liquid level change, which in turn, will result in a change of weight of the sensor. This change of mass detected by the sensor is also sensed by a differential transformer 24 which surrounds the support line 16. The balance 18 may be supported on a box 19 which in turn is supported by a base 20 having leveling screws 21. The box 19 may also contain the desired instrumentation and/or be provided with input and output jacks for connection to appropriate devices which are discussed later. The balance may be shielded from wind by means of a cover 23 as shown.
Referring now to FIG. 2, line 16 is attached to the balance beam 17 by a detachable coupler 22 and passes through a differential transformer (i.e. a displacement transducer) 24. Attached to line 16 and between the coils of the transducer is a ferromagnetic material 25 whose movement changes the electromagnetic flux of the transducer which is detected by the electronic circuitry shown at 26 powered by a power supply 27. It will be understood that the transducer need not necessarily be around the line 16, but may be placed in any convenient position, the only requirement being that it is responsive to movement of the balance beam. A suitable transducer is described in U.S. Pat. No. 3,179,193 where it is used in conjunction with a cantilever type support for a fuel tank to weigh fuel removed from the tank and fed to an internal combustion engine. The electronic circuitry 26 will also contain an amplifier to send an amplified signal to a digital readout device 28 which, if desired, may have a strip chart recorder or other printer 29 attached thereto for obtaining a printed record of the measurements.
In FIG. 3 which is a section taken on line 3--3 of FIG. 1, the preferred sensor having cap 13 and cup portion 14 is shown in detail. The sensor is filled with liquid from the tank and extends from above the top of the liquid 30 in fill-pipe 31 to just above the bottom of the storage tank 11. As is evident from the drawing the inside diameter of the cup section 14 is essentially equal to the outside diameter of the sensor in order to obtain compensation for evaporation of the hydrocarbon in the tank. The entire sensor system is readily supported by line 16 by appropriate wires or strings 15 through coupling means 22.
Compensation for evaporation results from the fact that when the hydrocarbon is in the cup portion, any evaporation that occurs will occur from both the surface of the liquid in the tank and from the surface of liquid in the cup. The buoyancy of the hydrocarbon liquid on the sensor is a function of the sensor diameter, but since the inside diameter of the cup is essentially the same as the outside diameter of the sensor, the evaporative loss of liquid from the cup will compensate for the buoyancy change due to evaporation of the liquid in the tank. Thus, when the liquid hydrocarbon in the tank evaporates, its buoyant force is reduced and the sensor becomes heavier. But the evaporation of the liquid in the cup reduces the weight of the sensor by exactly the same amount of the buoyant force lost and no change in weight of the sensor occurs. It will be understood of course, that instead of the sensor being tubular (i.e. circular in cross-section) it may be of another configuration and the cup-like section then will be made to have the same .[.cross-section configuration..]. .Iadd.interior cross-sectional area as the cross-sectional area of the sensor in contact with the tank liquid. .Iaddend.
By positioning the sensor near the bottom of the storage tank completely filled with liquid and having it extend through essentially the entire height of the liquid in the tank and riser 31 as shown in FIG. 1 the effects of any change in temperature are minimized. This is because the sensor fluid temperature is essentially the same as the tank liquid temperature with the same gradient, if any. As indicated, it is desired that the system measure a change of about 0.05 gallons per hour which is equivalent to about 200 cc per hour. Since the measurements made in accord with the invention are made within a few minutes it is unlikely that there will be a temperature change of more than a fraction of one degree. Tests show that with a tank filled with gasoline using a sensor with a five-eighth inch diameter in a two-inch pipe riser, a one degree (.degree.F.) change effects a change in mass equivalent to about 0.3 cc, which 0.3 cc change represents an insignificant error of 0.15%. Thus, temperature changes are of no significance when the measurements are performed on an essentially full tank and using a sensor extending essentially to the bottom. It will be understood, of course, that where no temperature problems are anticipated, the sensor need not extend to near the bottom of the tank and a shorter sensor may be used. Also, if temperature compensation is not desired, it is not necessary to make the measurement with a full tank of liquid.
In carrying out the procedures of the invention with temperature compensation it is desirable to plug off any conduits in the tank system such as risers and the like to reduce the area of such risers in order to maintain sensitivity during leak measurement. After the necessary plugging is done, the balance is erected over the fillpipe hole, gauge hole or other access hole to the tank, the sensor filled with liquid from the tank and inserted through the hole. The sensor suspension wire is then attached to the beam of the balance. Care must be taken to see that the sensor and its suspension wire do not touch the pipe or tank. The balance is then leveled, and appropriate electrical corrections made to the power supply, transducer, and recorder. It is also often desirable to cover the balance to protect it against gusts of wind or other interferences. Calibration is then carried out by adding a known amount of liquid to the tank and observing the change in the recording instrument. Observation is then made to the recorder device to note changes. With a strip chart recorder, which is preferred, the pen will trace a straight line if there are no leaks. If a leak is present, the pen will deflect and the angle of deflection is indicative of the leak rate. From the number of divisions on the chart paper that the pen has deflected, the time of the trace, and the deflection per unit of liquid obtained from the calibration step, the leak rate is readily calculated. Also, by starting the pen at the center of the paper and standardizing the direction of deflection, the leak can be determined to be into or out of the tank.
As indicated, it is possible to carry out the method with partially filled tanks when temperature compensation is not considered to be critical. In such measurements it is not necessary to plug off the risers and other conduits from the tank and it is preferred to use a different shaped sensor. It will be understood that the sensitivity of the sensor is dependent upon the liquid level in the tank and the shape of the tank. The smaller the area of liquid, the greater the response to change of the sensor. Thus, when the tank is filled with liquid in a riser section, the sensor is most sensitive. At mid-point of a cylinderical tank where the area of liquid level is greater, sensitivity is lowest, and sensitivity will be between these extremes at other positions. Thus, when a partially filled tank is measured, a sensor with a relatively large displacement is desired to increase sensitivity. Also, a more sensitive balance may be used for increased sensitivity.
The preferred sensor for less than a full tank system is shown in FIG. 4 and may be in the shape of a flat board 32 with a dished out upper surface 33 and having supporting wires 34 and 35. The board 32 will be sufficiently narrow so as to pass through a pipe into the liquid in the tank. The sensor is suspended on the liquid surface in a horizonal attitude with some liquid in the dished out portion 33 and the cross-sectional area of the liquid in the dished out surface is essentially the same as the cross-sectional area in contact with the liquid in the tank. In this way the compensation for evaporation is accomplished in the same manner as described above. The means by which the narrow sensor is introduced into and removed from the tank is illustrated by FIGS. 4 through 8. The sensor is provided with means to enter the tank and enable it to function in a horizontal position on the surface of the liquid. These means must also enable the sensor to be removed from the tank through the same opening through which it was introduced. Such means shown generally as 48 in FIGS. 4 and 4a embodies a quick release mechanism to enable the sensor to be easily removed. As seen in FIG. 4 the release means comprises a solid cylindrical core member 36 surrounded by an outer cover 37 made of sheet metal, plastic or other suitable material. An angular bore hole in the core member is fitted with a pushing spring 38 and push rod 39. The support line 16 passes through the center top of the outer cover 37 and is fixed to a small cylindrical fitting 40 with an annular groove 41 which is held in a fixed position within core 36 by a restraining set screw 42. The core also is fitted with a screw eye 43 or other device to which line 34 is attached. A conical spring 42 is positioned between the top of core 36 and outer cover 37. The outer cover is provided with a port 44 in alignment with push rod 39. The edge of the outer cover 37a formed by the port 44 acts as a catch for a pin 45 with an annular groove 46 which is attached to line 35. The port 44 is about twice as long as the diameter of pin 45. Outer cover 37 also may be provided with limiting stubs 47 to hold the assembly together. Before introduction of the sensor into the tank, the pin 45 is inserted through port 44 against push rod 39 and the groove 46 in the pin is positioned at the catch edge 37a of the outer cover. The effect of spring 42 is to hold the outer cover in a fixed position and because of this and spring 38, the pin 45 remains firmly fixed in the catch 37a. The sensor is then placed in the tank through a fill pipe or other access hole as shown in FIG. 5. When it is completely through the pipe the sensor opens as shown in FIG. 6 and after dipping it in the liquid to place liquid in its tray portion it is allowed to rest on the surface of the liquid as shown in FIG. 7. After the determination for leakage is made and it is desired to retrieve the sensor, a weight 50 surrounding line 16 is dropped down the fillpipe 31 onto the quick release system 48. As shown in FIG. 4a, the weight impacts upon the outer cover 37 pushing it downward, which in turn removes the catch 37a from groove 46 of pin 45. This causes the cooperating push spring 38 and push rod 39 to push pin 45 outwardly and causes the sensor to take the position shown in FIG. 8. Removal of the sensor is then simply made by pulling it upwardly through the fill-pipe riser 31.
It will be understood that the above described leak measuring system may be used in numerous applications for both above and below ground installation. Also numerous variations may be made to the system. For example, it is possible to replace the displacement transducer with other means for determining displacement; e.g. capacitance devices and the like. In another alternative embodiment the displacement of the sensor may be replaced by the technique of measuring the change in mass necessary to keep the balance at its null point. Since such a technique will require servo-mechanisms it will be more expensive to build the equipment and therefore it is not a preferred method. Another option is to use telemetering means so as to remotely measure any changes in mass. Other variations and embodiments will be obvious to the skilled art worker.
1. A method of high sensitivity for measuring leakage of liquid into or out of a storage tank.Iadd.normally at atmospheric pressure.Iaddend.which comprises introducing a freely suspended sensor into the liquid in the tank.Iadd.through the fill-pipe or other access hole of said tank.Iaddend., said sensor being coupled to means for sensing mass displacement,.[.and.]. observing the change of displacement of said sensor over a period of time to determine a change of liquid mass in said tank.Iadd., and subsequently removing said sensor from said tank.Iaddend..
2. A method of high sensitivity for measuring leakage of liquid into or out of a storage tank, which comprises introducing a freely suspended sensor into the liquid in the tank, said sensor being coupled to means for sensing mass displacement, calibrating said mass sensing displacement means to determine the amount of liquid per unit change, measuring the units of change of displacement of said sensor over a period of time and calculating the rate of change of liquid in said tank.
3. A method of high sensitivity for measuring leakage of liquid into or out of a storage tank whereby effects of evaporation of said liquid in said tank are compensated, which comprises introducing a sensor into the liquid in the tank, said sensor having liquid from said storage tank in liquid holding means at its top.[.and extending above the level of liquid in said tank.]..Iadd., said sensor being disposed in the tank liquid such that said liquid holding means extends above the tank liquid level,.Iaddend.the cross-sectional area of said liquid surface in said liquid holding means being essentially equal to the cross-sectional area of the.[.outside dimension of.]. said sensor.Iadd.in contact with the tank liquid.Iaddend., said sensor being coupled to means for sensing mass displacement, calibrating said mass sensing displacement means to determine the amount of liquid per unit change, measuring the units of change of displacement of said sensor over a period of time and calculating the rate of change of liquid in said tank.
4. The method of claim 3 where the storage tank is underground.
5. The method of claim 3 wherein the tank is filled with liquid and the sensor extends to near the bottom of said tank whereby the effects of temperature are minimized.
6. A method of high sensitivity for measuring leakage of liquid into or out of a storage tank whereby effects of evaporation of said liquid in said tank are compensated, which comprises introducing a sensor into the liquid in the tank, said sensor having liquid from said storage tank in liquid holding means at its top.[.and extending above the level of liquid in said tank,.]..Iadd., said sensor being disposed in the tank liquids such that said liquid holding means extends above the tank liquid level,.Iaddend.the cross-sectional area of said liquid surface in said liquid holding means being essentially equal to the cross-sectional area of.[.the outside dimension of.]. said sensor.Iadd.in contact with the tank liquid.Iaddend., said sensor being coupled to the arm of a balance for sensing mass displacement and movement of said balance arm being detected by a differential transformer, calibrating the output of said differential transformer to determine the amount of liquid per unit change of displacement, measuring the units of change of displacement of said sensor over a period of time and calculating the rate of change of liquid in said tank.
7. The method of claim 6 where the storage tank is underground.
8. The method of claim 6 wherein the output of said differential transformer is coupled to a recording device..Iadd.
9. A method of improved sensitivity for measuring leakage of liquid into or out of a storage tank having a tank atmosphere whereby effects of evaporation of the tank liquid are compensated, said method comprising the steps of:
- introducing into the tank liquid a sensor containing liquid segregated from the tank liquid and exposed to the tank atmosphere,
- sensing at least one buoyancy-dependent sensor condition which is responsive to the level of the tank liquid in the tank;
- observing the change in the at least one sensor condition to determine a change of liquid mass in the tank..Iaddend..Iadd.10. The method of claim 9 wherein said at least one sensor condition comprises displacement of
said sensor from a predetermined initial position..Iaddend..Iadd.11. The method of claim 9 wherein the cross-sectional area of the surface of said sensor liquid is substantially equal to the cross-sectional displacement area of said sensor..Iaddend..Iadd.12. The method of claim 11 wherein said sensor liquid is liquid taken from said tank liquid..Iaddend..Iadd.13. The method of claim 12 wherein said sensor has liquid holding means at its top for holding at least some of said sensor liquid..Iaddend..Iadd.14. The method of claim 13 wherein said sensor is introduced into the tank such that said liquid holding means is disposed above the level of the tank liquid..Iaddend.
|227539||May 1880||Vila y Jove|
|3841146||October 1974||Cross et al.|
|4013194||March 22, 1977||Moscarini|
|4116062||September 26, 1978||Reip|
|4186591||February 5, 1980||Mooney|
|4244211||January 13, 1981||Carpino|
|4244218||January 13, 1981||Wohrl|
Filed: Aug 5, 1982
Date of Patent: May 14, 1985
Assignee: Hunter Environmental Services, Inc. (Malvern, PA)
Inventors: William B. Hansel (Media, PA), Earl W. Smith (Wilmington, DE)
Primary Examiner: Gerald Goldberg
Assistant Examiner: Joseph W. Roskos
Law Firm: Parkhurst & Oliff
Application Number: 6/405,492