Protease Transducers and Sensors Based on DNA Loops
The stiffness and topology of ultra-small circular DNAs and DNA/peptide hybrids are exploited to create a transducer of enzyme activity with low error rates. The modularity and flexibility of the concept are illustrated by demonstrating various transducers that respond to either specific restriction endonucleases or to specific proteases. In all cases the output is a DNA oligo signal that, as we show, can readily be converted directly to an optical readout, or can serve as input for further processing, for example, using DNA logic or amplification. By exploiting the DNA hairpin (or stem-loop) structure and the phenomenon of strand displacement, an enzyme signal is converted into a DNA signal, in the manner of a transducer. This is valuable because a DNA signal can be readily amplified, combined, and processed as information.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62/833,953 filed Apr. 4, 2019 and is a division of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 16/848,286 filed Apr. 14, 2020, the entirety of each of which is incorporated herein by reference.
FEDERALLY-SPONSORED RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENTThe United States Government has ownership rights in this invention. Licensing inquiries may be directed to Office of Technology Transfer, US Naval Research Laboratory, Code 1004, Washington, D.C. 20375, USA; +1.202.767.7230; techtran@nrl.navy.mil, referencing NC 110,926.
BACKGROUNDEnzymes are protein catalysts vital to nearly all biology, allowing nature to perform the myriad room-temperature or near-room-temperature biochemical syntheses that make life possible. A measure of the importance of these processes is that enzymes constitute one quarter of the translation products of the human genome (roughly 500 genes). Furthermore, enzymes are not only key elements of healthy cell activities, but they are also crucial for disease processes and can thus serve as markers for these disease states. As a result, the ability to detect and monitor enzymes such as proteases, esterases, kinases, etc. is a crucial task in a multitude of applications in biology and medicine.
A wide range of enzyme detection systems exist for use in applications in biomedicine, food, etc. Such methods, almost entirely in vitro, can be grouped by the nature of their readouts and the two main classes have optical and electrical outputs. Performance and cost are the two main criteria, and new approaches that have the potential to impact/improve in either of these areas are always welcome. In addition, ideas that have the potential to function in vivo, and can add significant sophistication are of much interest for their potential to broaden capabilities.
A need exists for new techniques for detecting enzyme activity.
BRIEF SUMMARYDescribed herein is a technique for enzyme detection/transduction involving conversion to a DNA signal that can in turn be combined, processed, and/or amplified using known DNA methods.
Before describing the present invention in detail, it is to be understood that the terminology used in the specification is for the purpose of describing particular embodiments, and is not necessarily intended to be limiting. Although many methods, structures and materials similar, modified, or equivalent to those described herein can be used in the practice of the present invention without undue experimentation, the preferred methods, structures and materials are described herein. In describing and claiming the present invention, the following terminology will be used in accordance with the definitions set out below.
As used herein, the singular forms “a”, “an,” and “the” do not preclude plural referents, unless the content clearly dictates otherwise.
As used herein, the term “and/or” includes any and all combinations of one or more of the associated listed items.
As used herein, the term “about” when used in conjunction with a stated numerical value or range denotes somewhat more or somewhat less than the stated value or range, to within a range of ±10% of that stated.
Overview
While DNA is of course the basis of genetics, it has also given rise to the field of DNA nanotechnology [1] wherein the information content of the DNA (i.e., its base sequence) is used to program form and/or function for a variety of potential non-biological applications. As described herein, an enzyme signal is converted into a DNA signal, in the manner of a transducer. This is valuable because a DNA signal can be readily amplified, combined, and processed as information. In doing so, two important concepts of relevance are the DNA hairpin (or stem-loop) and strand displacement. Both arise commonly in nature, and both are widely exploited in DNA nanotechnology, e.g., as molecular beacons [2] and for toehold-mediated strand displacement [3]. These capabilities are also utilized jointly for purposes of DNA logic [4] and DNA amplification [5]. The invention disclosed here makes use of all of these ideas.
The subject invention is of this type in that the DNA is employed as both a constructional and a computational material. From a structural standpoint, the transducer is composed largely of DNA. In this it takes particular advantage of two key characteristics of DNA. One is its stiffness that arises from the base-stacking of double-stranded (ds) DNA and that causes DNA to remain straight when shorter than about 15 nm (coherence length). The other relevant property of DNA is its helical nature which can impose topological constraints on the ability of two strands of DNA to hybridize.
A schematic of the loop sensor concept is shown in
The released hybridizing domain constitutes the DNA output of the loop transducer, and the conversion of this output to a fluorescent signal by the molecular beacon represents the action of this embodiment of the output gate (more complicated output gates are described below). Within the concept just described there are many aspects that can be varied and these may be regarded as of two types, those made with functionality in mind and those associated with optimization. While functionality is obviously of most interest, achieving functionality requires optimization: for example, if the hybridization strand is too short, then the hairpin will never or almost never be open, and vice versa too long a hybridization sequence will tend to leave the hairpin always or almost always open.
A loop sensor design suitable for detecting endonucleases is shown in
The cleavage domain can be varied to detect different substrates. In the case of an endonuclease sensor, the target sequence should be double-stranded, and this is done by the addition of the LC strand seen in
Nuclease Sensing
A loop sensor design suitable for detecting endonucleases was made as shown in
Experiments were conducted to evaluate the optimal lengths of sequences forming the transducer and output gate.
The first aspect of the design to be considered for optimization was the hybridizing domain, in particular varying {h1} in the range from 8 to 15 and {h2} in the range from 12 to 27. For the experiments the target sequence in the cleavage domain was that appropriate for HaeIII (GGCC) with the loop design kept fixed with {LL}=80, {LS}=40, and {LC}=20 and only the output gate varied (and simply shifting where the fixed sequences a2+h1 and b1+h2 divide as {h1} and {h2} change). Using gel electrophoresis, the various designs were assessed in the presence or absence of the target enzyme. Remarkably, all of the hybridizing domain designs worked well, in all cases showing low levels of both false positives (in the absence of enzyme) and false negatives (in the presence of enzyme). This means that there is considerable flexibility in the design of the output gate and of the hybridizing domain. Moreover, it demonstrates the robustness of the overall design, and the effectiveness of the loop stresses and topology in suppressing unwanted responses.
The second parameter considered for optimization was the length of the stiffening LS strand; tested were lengths of 30, 40, 47, and 55. Fluorescence measurements were made to find the true (false) positive rate from an estimate of the number of hairpins open (closed) when the enzyme is present (absent). The best performing designs have the highest true positive rate (TPR or sensitivity) and the lowest false positive rate (FPR or one minus the specificity). All of the tested stiffening strands give good performance with the LS30 and LS47 designs being best, with the former excelling in specificity and in maintaining a low FPR over long periods of time, while the latter is preferred for sensitivity and for the fastest response within the resolution of the experiment, which was carried out for periods ranging from 2 to 21 hours. The general behavior is a rapid rise to a peak followed by a slow degradation in performance, with again LS47 being best at early times but LS30 performing better over longer times because of its relative immunity to false positives. Finally, control experiments were carried out in which the LS stand was either missing entirely (with a ligated loop) or where it was such that the dsDNA at the nick (in an unligated loop) could bend easily. In both cases strong false positives were observed, with the hairpin being opened by the hybridizing domain even when no endonuclease was present. This shows that the stiffness of the loop is essential to the proper functioning of the transducer.
For loop transducers that respond to endonucleases, another variable to be considered for optimization is the length of the LC strand that comprises the cleavage domain. The specific designs examined had {LC} of 10, 20, and 40, with the hairpin labeled with a donor (Cy3) and an acceptor (Cy5) dye. It was found that the system functioned quite well with {LC}=20, but shows high false positive rates when {LC}=10 and high false negative rates when {LC}=40.
Based on the foregoing, an “optimal” design with {LL}=80, {LS}=30, {LC}=20, {h1}=8, {h2}=8, and {□}=15 was investigated. Tests were made not just with the endonuclease of interest but also with a different endonuclease (NcoI-HF, targeting CCATGG instead of HaeIII's target GGCC, designed into the transducer) to look for unwanted non-specific signals.
The molecular beacon was used as the output gate to follow the action spectroscopically with the data presented in
As a test of the modularity of the design, a loop transducer identical to that tested in
Protease Sensing
Proteases are enzymes that cleave peptides, and therefore to create a loop sensor for proteases a peptide segment is preferably be used as the cleavage domain. For example, the protease trypsin targets an eight-residue peptide which was incorporated into the DNA loop. Before conducting physical experiments, a molecular dynamics simulation was performed in order to look for any undesired behavior, and especially for any unwanted interactions between the peptide and the DNA. The simulation confirmed (over its 200 ns duration) that the uncleaved loop transducer stayed in a stressed ‘bow’ configuration as depicted in
The system behavior in the real world was examined using both a gel and fluorescence with the results shown in
As a second example of a protease transducer, a loop transducer was produced that was identical to that described immediately above except for having a cleavage domain for TEV protease (with target sequence of seven peptides) rather than for trypsin. The data for this transducer is shown in
Logic
As shown herein, one can change target specificity of a system by modifying the cleavage domain to convert the activity of various enzymes into signals. An important benefit of performing this conversion is that the products of such sensors are readily combined to perform logical operations. This makes possible information processing of multiple data streams, to improve the reliability of the sensor output. Among other things, such designs can in principle greatly reduce false positive rates, e.g., by introducing an AND function that requires the presence of two different nucleases in order to giving a positive response.
One can create a Boolean OR gate or a NAND gate, specifically by creating two (or more) loop transducers with cleavage domains appropriate to two (or more) target enzymes but sharing the same sequence in their hybridizing domains that matches a particular molecular beacon. This idea is illustrated in
One could feed the DNA output signals from multiple loop transducers into DNA logic circuits, and thereby achieve a modularity in which the transduction and logic functions are separated. As illustration, we here consider realizing an AND function on the outputs of two loop transducers using the design shown in
Further generalizations are possible using methods like those in [4] and in other papers on DNA logic [8].
Amplification
Another use to which one can put the DNA output of the loop transducer is amplification. The process takes advantage of the catalytic capabilities of DNA oligonucleotides as exploited for example in [5]. A depiction of what should readily be possible is shown in
Signal amplification is commonly used with sensors, typically by introducing gain into the electrical readout circuitry. For sensitive detection it is best to do this amplification as early as possible following transduction so as to minimize the amplification of noise. This suggests that for the loop transducers it would best to do the amplification at the molecular level rather than in subsequent optical or electrical stages. Two types of amplification at the molecular level can be considered, with one being inherent in the enzyme itself due to its turnover. The other is DNA amplification either using enzyme-dependent methods such as the polymerase chain reaction or rolling circle amplification (RCA), or with a DNA-based scheme that is enzyme-free.
The output DNA signals from the loop converter system can benefit from the integration of non-enzyme dependent amplification schemes. Due to the high amplification range of the catalytic hairpin assembly (CHA), the output DNA signals can be programmed as an input/catalyst to trigger the amplification process of CHA systems. A modified CHA amplification scheme for the proposed system was tested in the absence of the endonuclease-to-DNA signal converter. Fluorescence results indicate that the input signal was amplified at least 4× times using the modified CHA scheme. Since the modified CHA scheme only leveraged the internal-toehold mediate strand displacement in order to be compatible with the existing endonuclease-to-DNA signal converter, it was expected that the amplification factor was less optimal compared to those systems using the external-toehold mediated strand displacement. To improve the amplification factor, the hairpin structures of the modified CHA scheme were evaluated next. While maintaining the same structure of the first hairpin, the second hairpin's stem was padded with non-trivial bases to (i) increase its stability and (ii) minimize leaks in the absence of the catalyst strand. Fluorescence results indicate that the amplification factor linearly improved as a function of additional non-trivial bases. It is relevant that the proposed enzyme-to-DNA signal converter can be equipped with an amplification circuit to boost the output signal for low concentration detection applications.
Nucleic Acid Detection
Rather than as a detector of enzymes, the transducer can alternatively be used to detect ssDNA or RNA. The idea is that the oligo to be detected would hybridize to the cleavage domain of a nuclease transducer, thus making the latter susceptible to attack by an endonuclease and thereby revealing the presence of the target oligo. To illustrate, we considered an RNA biomarker as the target, with its binding to a loop transducer. In theory, any microRNA biomarkers could be targeted in this way. Gel electrophoresis and fluorescence spectroscopy confirmed the functionality of this design, with the RNA-DNA hybrid indeed being cleaved by the HaeIII endonuclease, thereby opening the loop and activating the molecular beacon. It is expected that a wide variety of nucleic acids could be detected in this way.
Further EmbodimentsBeyond the above-demonstrated enzyme loop sensor effective for both endonucleases and proteases, it should be possible to develop similar schemes for other technologies such as microRNAs and engineered proteins such as zinc-finger nucleases.
The use of a peptide nucleic acid (PNA)-based approach should be possible either as the LS strand for increased rigidity and thermal stability, or as a facile and lower cost means of inserting a peptide into a DNA loop.
Beyond the demonstrated fluorescence outputs, color-change readouts should also be possible, e.g., with the DNA release driving a cross-linking reaction between particles (e.g., gold or magnesium). Or another embodiment could involve tethering to metallic surfaces so as to generate electrical outputs via standard electrochemical methods.
Also contemplated are designs with the hybridized LS and/or LC strands directly attached to the LL loop strand so that they would not get lost and hence could be reconstituted from a dried state.
The proposed system can be tethered to 2D substrates such as lipid bilayers via the cholesterol-labeled DNA oligomer for enhancing speed as well as utilizing the localization effect for sensing surface-bound biomarkers.
Signals from this system should be measurable by, circular dichroism (CD), UV-VIS, and excitonic-coupling phenomenon, in addition to the techniques described in the examples.
Quenchers can be fluorescent dyes or other suitable quenchers of fluorescence as known in the art.
Advantages
Described herein is a new technique for enzyme detection/transduction by converting specific enzymatic activity into a DNA signal that can in turn be combined, processed, and/or amplified using known DNA methods. The advantages and new features of the method over existing approaches may be summarized as follows.
It provides a general technique that can be applied to endonucleases and proteases, and potentially also to many other classes of enzymes. This is made possible by the non-specificity of the principle of operation (based on the loop stiffness and topology) and by the demonstrated modularity of the design. These considerations should make the approach broadly applicability to many different areas in biomedicine, homeland security, etc.
The simplicity of the loop transducer design makes it scalable and makes possible the processing of other information beyond biomaterials.
With the loop transducer's simple DNA oligo output the technique can be readily coupled to the world of DNA nanotechnology, and especially to strand displacement networks. As illustrated in this disclosure, two primary functions achievable in this way are logical processing of the outputs and amplification of the outputs.
The nano-size, non-toxic nature, and robustness to enzymatic attack should make the approach adaptable to in vivo applications, unlike many alternatives.
The approach is accomplished at very low cost in view of the relative ease of obtaining the synthesized oligomers commercially. In standard storage conditions, shelf-life should be excellent given the known robustness of DNA.
The proposed system can withstand exonuclease digestion if using the circular loop for in vivo application.
CONCLUDING REMARKSAll documents mentioned herein are hereby incorporated by reference for the purpose of disclosing and describing the particular materials and methodologies for which the document was cited.
Although the present invention has been described in connection with preferred embodiments thereof, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that additions, deletions, modifications, and substitutions not specifically described may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. Terminology used herein should not be construed as being “means-plus-function” language unless the term “means” is expressly used in association therewith.
REFERENCES
- [1] N. Seeman, Structural DNA Nanotechnology (Cambridge Univ. Press, 2016).
- [2] S. Tyagi and F. R. Kramer, “Molecular beacons: Probes that fluoresce upon hybridization,” Nature Biotech. 14, 303 (1996).
- [3] B. Yurke, “A DNA-fueled molecular machine made of DNA,” Nature 406, 605 (2000).
- [4] G. Seelig, D. Soloveichik, D. Y. Zhang, and E. Winfree, “Enzyme-free nucleic acid logic circuits,” Science 314, 1585 (2006).
- [5] C. Wu et al., “A nonenzymatic hairpin DNA cascade reaction provides high signal gain of mRNA imaging inside live cells,” J. Am. Chem. Soc. 137, 4900-4903 (2015).
- [6] E. Protozanova, P. Yakovchuk, and M. D. Frank-Kamenetskii, “Stacked-unstacked equilibrium at the nick site of DNA,” J. Mol. Biol. 342, 775 (2004).
Claims
1. An enzyme sensor system comprising:
- a loop transducer comprising a stiffening domain of about 30 to 55 base pairs in length, a cleavage domain cleavable by a protease, and a first hybridizing domain of about 12 to 27 base pairs in length; and
- an output gate comprising a second hybridizing domain of about 8 to 15 base pairs in length and complementary to the first hybridizing domain, a fluorophore, and a quencher,
- wherein the system is configured so that in the absence of the first hybridizing domain, the quencher quenches the fluorophore, and upon hybridization of the two domains, the quencher become separated from the fluorophore sufficiently to allow fluorescence thereof.
2. The sensor system of claim 1, further comprising a second output gate comprising a second fluorophore configured as a Forster resonance energy transfer partner of the other fluorophore.
Type: Application
Filed: Jun 16, 2021
Publication Date: Oct 7, 2021
Inventors: Mario Ancona (Alexandria, VA), Hieu Bui (Alexandria, VA)
Application Number: 17/348,819